Full Transcript

·YouTLDR

Harrisburg City Council - Work Session 10/07/2025

1:57:53EnglishTranscribed Jun 15, 2026
0:31

if shoes. But the time is 5:34 p.m. I

0:35

would like to call our work session to

0:37

order.

0:41

>> Mr. Trudale, could you please call the

0:43

role?

0:44

>> Miss Daniels,

0:46

>> here.

0:48

Miss Davis

0:49

>> present.

0:50

>> Miss Green

0:51

>> present.

0:51

>> Mr. Jones

0:52

>> here.

0:53

>> Miss Rolls

0:56

>> present.

0:58

>> Mr. Rodriguez

0:59

>> present.

0:59

>> Miss who?

1:00

>> Present. Thank you. Um

1:04

we have three committees that you will

1:08

hear from this evening. We will begin

1:10

with the administration committee. We

1:12

have two resolutions for discussion.

1:15

Resolution 55 of 2025 and resolution 56

1:20

of 2025.

1:22

Mr. Trudale, could you please read

1:24

Resolution 55 of 2025 into the record?

1:28

>> Resolution 55 2025. Resolution

1:31

appointing Mr. Muhammad M. Bilah to

1:34

serve on the coordinating committee and

1:35

as an alternate member of the technical

1:37

committee of the Harrisburg area

1:39

transportation study.

1:42

>> Thank you. Um Mr.

1:44

are you present?

1:46

>> Okay, if you wouldn't mind.

1:48

>> Thank you.

1:51

>> I would just ask that if you could

1:53

please um move the microphone very close

1:56

to you so that everybody can hear you.

1:59

Thanks for joining us. If you wouldn't

2:01

mind introducing yourself.

2:03

>> Uh thank you. Good evening everybody.

2:06

Mohammad Baha. I'm a new employee with

2:09

the city. This is my fourth month and

2:11

I'm coming from the Fed. I was with the

2:14

US EPA for 21 years and with four

2:17

different three different state for six

2:19

more years. Technically I'm still a fed

2:22

because I'm still on the federal peril

2:24

because I took the fork in the road. Uh

2:27

they call it voluntary deferred

2:29

resignation.

2:31

Uh till December 31st I'm still on the

2:34

EPA payroll but they're allowing me to

2:36

work for the city with approval from the

2:39

office of the general council. I took

2:41

that opportunity and I really appreciate

2:43

city of Heritage giving me the

2:44

opportunity to work for the city.

2:47

Appreciate. Thank you. My background,

2:49

I'm a I'm an I'm a I'm an engineer,

2:51

environmental engineer with strong

2:54

management background. I have beside my

2:56

two engineering degree, I also have an

2:57

MBA. I I'm also like the federal PPM

3:01

level three that is the program and

3:04

project management highest level in the

3:06

federal government. So I have tons of

3:08

experience in the project and program

3:10

management. I used to manage the largest

3:12

wastewater program for the US EPA that

3:14

is called combined sewer overflow and

3:16

Harrisburg is a CSO communities. Just

3:19

give you an example this small city like

3:21

Harrisburg your long-term contra is

3:23

$1.43 billion. So nationwide combined

3:28

overflow program infrastructure value

3:29

was $200 billion and I managed that

3:32

program for 21 years for EPA. So not

3:36

only EPA outside the world also people

3:38

I'm known as the expert in the waste

3:39

weather control like I I help city of

3:42

Barcelona city of London Chinese program

3:44

European Union commission of the

3:46

environment I advise almost all over the

3:49

world so I'm known in that field not

3:51

within the the USA all over the world I

3:54

advise almost everybody like I like to

3:57

do voluntary work also I'm a member of

3:59

the FEMA search capacity force I'm also

4:02

a member of the EPA response support

4:04

corp I have been almost everywhere in

4:06

the emergency situation starting from

4:08

the 911. I was one of the first civilian

4:10

responder walking to the ground zero

4:12

after the 911 incident and I did the air

4:14

quality monitoring in and in and around

4:16

ground zero for over a year and a half.

4:19

I was almost everywhere COVID 19

4:21

hurricane Maria Rita Katrina all over

4:24

the world I was traveling. So I'm making

4:26

it short. My background I'm an engineer

4:28

with a very strong management

4:29

background.

4:33

>> Okay. Thank you. Thank you so much. Um,

4:36

so this appointment this evening is to

4:39

serve on the coordinating committee and

4:41

as an alternate member of the technical

4:44

committee of the Harrisburg Area

4:46

Transportation Study or HATS. Um, just

4:49

for your reference, the Harrisburg Area

4:51

Transportation Study or HATS was created

4:54

in response to the Federal Aid Highway

4:56

Act of 1962,

4:58

which mandated regional transportation

5:01

planning as a condition for receiving

5:03

federal funds for transportation

5:06

projects. The Harrisburg area

5:09

transportation study agreement was made

5:11

and entered into on February 11th, 1965

5:15

by and among the Department of Highways

5:17

of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, the

5:20

county of Cumberland, the county of

5:22

Dolphin, and the city of Harrisburg. The

5:24

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania has ruled

5:26

that there were

5:29

um

5:31

a statute that where a statute gives

5:35

appointment power to the governing body,

5:37

such appointment shall be made by the

5:39

mayor with the advice and consent of

5:41

council.

5:43

Okay. So, we do have your

5:49

resume before us as an exhibit to this

5:51

resolution, but you've shared your

5:53

extens extensive um career and

5:56

background

5:58

um in both environmental engineering,

6:02

civil engineering, and project

6:04

management. So, thank you. So, you serve

6:06

as a project manager for the city of

6:08

Harrisburg. Yes, I'm I'm the project

6:10

manager for the traffic and engineering

6:13

the bureau. Uh I'm actually take

6:16

supervising all the traffic and

6:18

engineering program and I'm working

6:20

under Joel and Joel is my supervisor.

6:23

Actually, I'm taking care of the traffic

6:25

and engineering project for the city of

6:26

Harrisburg. Yes.

6:29

>> Great. Thank you. Um I just have one

6:31

question before I open the floor to my

6:33

colleagues who may have additional

6:35

questions, but what impact do you

6:37

believe that you will be able to make um

6:40

serving at on the coordinating committee

6:43

and as an alternate member of the

6:45

technical committee of hats?

6:47

>> Wonderful question for sure. I was

6:50

always on the other side of the desk

6:53

that I was giving money to the people.

6:56

This will be the first time I'll be

6:58

representing city to take the money. So

7:01

I understand how the money work giving

7:05

and taking. I managed just before

7:08

leaving EPA I was involved in $2 billion

7:12

infrastructure grant money for the

7:14

state. I was I was I'm also a a project

7:19

officer for the EPA grants. I'm one of

7:21

the senior project officer. So I

7:23

understand very strongly how the federal

7:26

grant program works. I also work with

7:29

the three state. I also understand that

7:32

how state grant program works. I work

7:35

for the state of New York. I work for

7:37

the state of Maryland. I work for the

7:39

state of California. So I understand how

7:42

the grant program or the loan program

7:44

that the state works. And I have very

7:47

strong understanding of the federal

7:49

grant programs because I was one of the

7:52

senior grant officer for the US EPA. I

7:55

handled millions and billions dollar

7:57

grant for the EPA for even just before

8:00

moving out. I was a project officer for

8:02

the two big grants for two communities

8:05

in Maryland. So I understand the

8:07

process. So I understand how the whole

8:10

things work. Only difference is I was on

8:12

the other side of the desk. This time

8:14

I'll be this side of the desk asking for

8:16

the money taking the big chunk whatever

8:18

possible for to help the city to better

8:20

fund it for our infrastructure project

8:22

for the capital improvement project.

8:24

What is our priority like example giving

8:26

you you must have as honorable member

8:29

city council you must have some priority

8:31

that you're looking for me that will be

8:33

I'll be going down there and grabbing

8:35

the money from them to help your your

8:38

goal and your objective and ultimately

8:40

helping the city. So like like I

8:44

understand how things work. I'm an

8:46

engineer like I always as an engineer I

8:49

understand 2 plus 2 equals to four. At

8:51

the same times as a program manager

8:54

project manager with my MBA background I

8:56

understand 2 + 2 sometimes three or

8:59

sometimes five. You need to make the

9:01

justification.

9:04

Playing grant is that kind of things.

9:06

How can you make the justification where

9:08

the city need the money? YC city is the

9:11

right right place to invest the money,

9:13

get the grant, get the loan, whatever

9:15

needed. And I'm pretty sure I'm a very

9:17

strong candidate for this position. I

9:20

also understand I very capable candidate

9:22

for this position.

9:25

>> Thank you very much. Um, I will now open

9:28

the floor to my colleagues who may have

9:30

some additional questions for you. Um,

9:33

I'd like to begin with our public works

9:36

committee chair, Councilman Rodriguez.

9:39

Any questions?

9:40

>> Thank you, Madam President. Uh, thank

9:42

you, uh, Mr. Balau for joining us. Mr.

9:44

Ciders as always. Um, I actually see Mr.

9:47

Joel and Jeffrey Knight are currently

9:49

um, sitting members. Is that correct?

9:53

>> So, I'm a sitting member of both the

9:55

technical and committee and then Mr.

9:57

Knight is a sitting member of the

10:01

committee.

10:01

>> Technical committee.

10:02

>> Technical.

10:03

>> Yep. Yep. You're both listed under the

10:04

technical committee. So, um, but thank

10:06

you, uh, for your willingness to serve

10:08

in your capacity. What, uh, of course

10:10

with your extensive background, it's

10:12

pro, it's pretty much obvious what you

10:14

can bring and the benefits of having

10:16

you, but what's some things you're

10:17

looking forward to accomplishing while

10:19

you're sitting on the committee.

10:20

>> Uh,

10:23

I'm working very closely with Joel to

10:26

better understand the city. Like example

10:29

I can give you like one of the situation

10:32

that city have is the American with the

10:33

disability act what needed to be done

10:37

like if I look at the numbers

10:40

>> right now city has close to 10,000 ADA

10:43

amps 10,000

10:45

if I want to modify everything to make

10:48

it ADA compliance we need close to $2

10:50

billion does the city with 150 million

10:53

annual budget has that capability

10:56

>> for sure no so my my understanding how

11:01

can I play a role that city can be in

11:04

compliance with the DOJ ADA requirements

11:07

how can I like example right now like

11:10

Joel never asks me nobody asked me I'm

11:14

taking initiative of 2010 ADA

11:17

requirements for the city I'm taking a

11:19

look I just gave him a three-pager

11:22

yesterday ADA that what the what we're

11:25

missing here

11:26

>> so what I'm trying to Being here for the

11:28

city is my expertise as an as an

11:31

engineer plus as an MBA with extensive

11:35

program and project management

11:38

background. How can city move forward?

11:40

>> Absolutely.

11:41

>> Not backward because understand the 2010

11:44

ADA requirements by the city deadline is

11:48

next year April 26, 2026.

11:51

We need to come up with something that

11:53

city can say yes DOJ we are doing

11:56

something. My goal is making sure city

12:00

is doing everything that needed to be

12:03

done to serve the population of the city

12:06

more effectively, efficiently. Joel

12:08

knows like every time someone call me

12:12

>> I do not just answer the call. Joel

12:15

knows me. I go there. I talk to the

12:17

person. What is your problem? How can I

12:19

help you? It's my responsibility to go

12:21

there. That is my goal. how we all can

12:25

serve the city population more

12:26

efficiently, more effectively, more

12:29

appropriately

12:30

and my goal in that role will be how can

12:33

we build a better infrastructure that we

12:35

can serve it better.

12:36

>> Absolutely. So for for sure it's a long

12:40

way to go but it doesn't mean that we

12:42

need to stop we need to start walking

12:45

one single step moving forward that is

12:48

what I'm trying to bring for the city

12:50

that how can we better serve as a whole

12:52

for the population of the city serving

12:54

the city

12:55

>> I appreciate that too showing how

12:56

proactive you can be not waiting around

12:58

to be asked um plus we know ADA

13:01

compliance is

13:02

>> like example I can give you like I we

13:04

have a ADA situation right now Okay.

13:07

>> Because I I my like I had major surgery

13:11

in my ear because of a vehicular

13:14

incident.

13:16

>> So I use hearing aid but my hearing for

13:19

certain some reason doesn't work in this

13:21

room. I do not know why.

13:23

>> Wow.

13:24

>> So is there any alternative we have? For

13:27

sure we have alternative to resolve the

13:28

situation. That's what I'm thinking

13:30

right now. How can we make the city

13:32

better?

13:32

>> Yeah.

13:33

>> For the future.

13:34

I appreciate you being so transparent.

13:36

Thank you for that. Uh, no further

13:38

questions.

13:39

>> Thank you, Councilman Jones. Any

13:42

questions?

13:43

>> Uh, thank you, President Hill. Um, thank

13:45

you, Mr. um allowed to your willingness

13:48

to serve um you have a very extensive um

13:52

resume and I'm just wondering after

13:55

dealing dealing with billions of

13:57

dollars. What's the interest here? is

13:59

just because you live here. I heard a

14:01

little bit of the passion, but you know,

14:03

I'm asking you specifically, what was

14:05

the interest in wanting to fulfill um

14:08

these these works and in this position?

14:12

>> I'm sorry.

14:14

>> All right.

14:29

Oh, why I picked up? Okay, telling you

14:32

frankly my situation right now I'm still

14:36

a federal employee. Actually, I'm

14:38

getting two paycheck. One from the fed,

14:41

one from the city.

14:43

I was not thinking to do anything

14:45

because if I work 20 years with the

14:48

federal government, I can leave with my

14:50

full federal retirement benefit and I

14:53

have 21 years. I'm getting my full

14:55

federal rate benefit telling her frankly

14:58

if I do not do anything I'll be making

15:01

more money than what I'm making right

15:02

now with the city. I'll be making more.

15:05

But only reason I'm doing it like

15:08

my wife Eva called me workaholic.

15:13

And she also called me OCD

15:16

because of the workaholic situation. I

15:19

wake up 4 in the morning. So because I

15:22

cannot leave not doing anything. So I

15:25

thought that I need to do something. Do

15:26

anything. My wife said do okay. If you

15:28

want to do something, do anything. Go

15:29

get pump gas, go to the grocery store,

15:31

do anything. Then suddenly

15:34

I don't know why I opened up the

15:37

Harrisburg web page and I saw they're

15:39

hiring a project manager. I thought it

15:40

sound interesting but the salary is

15:44

difference is pretty big with the fed

15:46

and my salary the city is pretty big

15:48

it's less than half telling you frankly

15:50

it's less than half but I applied why is

15:54

my friend

15:57

your human resource deputy

16:00

>> she left okay he called me Muhammad we

16:04

we are we we want to interview you and I

16:07

came here I talked to Joel and Dave

16:10

and they almost hired me on this spot.

16:12

Then I got stuck. What should I do? I

16:14

said, "Yep, I love city of Harrisburg.

16:17

Joel is a wonderful person. Dave is a

16:19

wonderful person. The reason I love

16:22

because I EP I was going to work suited

16:24

and booted, which I never like. I like

16:27

this and this shirt." Okay. And Joel was

16:30

wearing the city engineer shirt. Dave

16:33

was wearing the, you know, the director

16:35

shirt. And I said, "Oh man, this is the

16:37

place I want to work. This is the place

16:40

I'm more comfortable. Dur I left EPA

16:43

FedEx. I was tired tired of twisting the

16:47

fact tired of making the story. I was I

16:52

was planning to leave anyway if there is

16:55

a this situation like forcing people out

16:59

or not. So I thought okay I was planning

17:02

to leave. I'm not losing anything.

17:03

Getting my 100% benefit getting one

17:06

years of salary free doing nothing.

17:08

Absolutely. If the city Joel offer me a

17:11

job day, it's a wonderful opportunity.

17:13

I'll take it because I like to work. I

17:14

love to work. It is better than pumping

17:16

gas. And I took that way. I said, "Okay,

17:19

I'll take it." And on the top of that

17:21

one, the environment I was still

17:25

confused first couple of month. But more

17:29

I'm learning, more I'm falling in love

17:31

with the city. I realize I told you that

17:35

my federal salary is more than two times

17:37

what city is paying me right now. Money

17:40

cannot make you happy all the time.

17:42

Coming to work smiling going back going

17:45

back home smiling is a situation that

17:48

you you want as a professional. After

17:51

working 27 30 years I have nothing to

17:53

achieve. I did almost everything in my

17:55

life I could do. Like I have a wonderful

17:57

story you can see in the FEMA homeless

18:00

search capacity force. When I first came

18:02

to this country on the very first day I

18:04

was homeless. My uncle didn't show up at

18:06

the airport. I came here when I was 14

18:08

years old. He didn't show up at the I

18:10

was homeless. From there I came all the

18:12

way here. All the way here. So I

18:16

realized that happiness is different

18:18

things. How to be happy and that's why

18:20

actually I accepted the job. First of

18:23

all, first my impression of Joel and

18:25

Dave,

18:27

city engineers, director public

18:30

department and I love I work this for

18:33

project manager. That is the answer to

18:35

you.

18:36

>> Thank you. Uh was very detailed. Um

18:39

again I just you know just for my own

18:41

edification just wondering um you know

18:44

how'd you land here? I always ask people

18:46

how did they find Harrisburg and on the

18:49

map, but uh I would just say that man

18:52

your your your background um speaks

18:55

volumes that um this is your wheelhouse.

18:57

You know, this is definitely your

18:58

wheelhouse and and again the the passion

19:01

is jumping off the page and I really

19:03

don't have any other questions. I again

19:05

tell you uh thank you for your

19:06

willingness to serve.

19:07

>> Thank you.

19:09

>> Thank you Councilwoman Ross. Any

19:11

questions?

19:13

>> Well, good evening Mr.

19:14

Mr. Cider, thank you both for being

19:16

here. Um, your answers were very

19:19

detailed that every question I've had,

19:21

you answered it for me. Um, you seem

19:24

very proactive. I feel like you already

19:25

know what you want to do for Harrisburg

19:28

and that's what we need because we do

19:29

need to move forward. um we're stuck in

19:32

the past a little bit and we need those

19:34

minds here that see the whole city and

19:38

are ready to implement a plan and you're

19:40

ready for that and and Joel is great and

19:43

I can already see that you all got

19:44

things cooking up there. So I will not

19:46

get in the way and um just thank you for

19:49

coming here tonight and just loving the

19:51

city honestly. Thank you.

19:53

>> Thank you. Just to let you know just I'm

19:55

I'm not answering your question that I'm

19:57

giving you some information. I'm a very

19:58

people person like one of my

20:01

responsibility was actually training EPA

20:04

region and the state and the permites

20:06

and some of my workshop was five days

20:08

long week long and I was the only

20:11

speaker

20:12

>> just you can imagine that I like to talk

20:15

>> yes you do

20:17

>> but it's good you give so many detailed

20:19

answers that it doesn't leave people

20:21

wondering but it leaves people thinking

20:24

I can't wait to see what he's going to

20:27

do so and that's what I love. So,

20:29

>> thank you.

20:29

>> You're welcome. No, thank you. That's it

20:31

for me.

20:32

>> Thank you, Vice President Green. Any

20:34

questions?

20:35

>> Thank you for being here, Mr. Balau. Uh,

20:37

I don't really have any questions for

20:38

you. I believe you've given pretty

20:40

extensive answers so far. Um, you seem

20:43

like you're really passionate about what

20:45

you do. Uh, and I can always appreciate

20:47

that. Um, if you love the city of

20:50

Harrisburg now, you'll just love it as

20:52

you continue on. um not just for the

20:54

city and everything that it has to

20:56

offer, but also um in every position

20:58

with the city, you'll have a variety of

21:00

tasks to deal with um and and issues

21:03

that you'll be a part of solving. So, I

21:05

think your personality will fit right in

21:07

and you'll be a great asset to us. So,

21:08

thank you very much for being here.

21:10

>> Thank you for being Miss Green.

21:12

Appreciate

21:14

>> Thank you, Councilwoman Davis. Any

21:17

questions?

21:18

>> Thank you, President Hill. Good evening,

21:20

Mr. Ciders, Mr. Balo. Thank you for

21:23

being here and your resume is

21:27

exceptional.

21:29

Um, and I like to talk too, but I think

21:32

you got me beat.

21:33

>> Yep. Yep. Then we could talk a sideburn.

21:40

>> Can you um tell us about a challenge in

21:46

your career or

21:49

uh a job that was very challenging? um

21:52

in how you solve the problems.

21:56

>> Wonderful question. I love challenges

21:58

because first the eology man can realize

22:02

is problem is the solution of everything

22:04

in disguise. So I always look for

22:07

problem. I'm a problem maker. Give me a

22:10

problem, I'll find out the solution. I

22:13

have and fortunately

22:17

EPA used me as a problem solver a lot.

22:22

a lot when there was a situation people

22:27

was lost. I was there. Example I can

22:30

give you Puerto Rico used to issue

22:35

Puerto Rico was a combined SE overflow

22:38

communities like Harrisburg long time

22:41

ago. Back in 1980s Puerto Rico took some

22:44

federal funding to separate their

22:46

combined sewer system into the separate

22:48

sewer system. So Puerto Rico EPA field

22:52

office suddenly realized the system was

22:55

not properly separated because whenever

22:57

it was raining San Juan downtown Puerto

23:00

Rico was having basement backup.

23:04

So they try to the field office engineer

23:06

actually he was trying to pursue to the

23:10

region two that okay Puerto Rico may not

23:13

be totally separated community region

23:16

two ignore him because the challenge was

23:19

actually Puerto Rico took federal money

23:21

EPA money to separate and EPA certified

23:25

that one region couldn't agree because

23:27

of the legal situation Puerto Rico field

23:30

office reach out to me that Muhammad we

23:32

need your help the way the infra

23:34

structure work the city goes to the

23:36

state state goes to the region region

23:38

goes to the headquarter to me with the

23:40

issue when he reached out to me said

23:42

okay I'm coming down to Puerto Rico to

23:45

take a look what's going on I went down

23:48

there have a tour and realized the

23:50

system was not effectively separated my

23:53

challenge was actually convincing PRAA

23:56

Puerto Rico field office and EPA region

23:58

the system was not effectively separated

24:01

because of the political situation the

24:03

it was playing the role of the g taking

24:05

money for the federal government. So

24:07

what I did I did nothing. I didn't push

24:10

it. I said okay I'll be going down to

24:12

Puerto Rico couple of times for the week

24:14

long and training everybody what is CSO

24:16

combined server overflow how it works

24:18

what is the control requirement and

24:19

everything. So I did that I did that

24:22

multiple time going down to Puerto Rico

24:25

training people advising people what

24:27

needed to be done. At the very end they

24:29

realized that actually Puerto Rico

24:31

system was the properly separated. Their

24:33

infrastructure was totally broken old

24:34

system like Harrisburg had the same

24:36

kinds of situation. Harrisburg

24:38

infrastructure is almost like 150 years

24:42

old especially the S system. Puerto Rico

24:43

has the same situation and it was a big

24:45

success. That means ultimately almost

24:48

year and a half region 2 realized the

24:50

Puerto Rico EPA region 2 realized Puerto

24:52

Rico is still a combined SE system and

24:54

PRASA was on board and and I was lucky

24:57

enough that actually I was I was able to

25:00

get another grant for the Puerto Rico

25:02

$1.8 billion to make sure they can

25:04

effectively now separate the system that

25:07

will not cause the basement backup in

25:09

the Sanan Puerto Rico downtown Sanan

25:11

Puerto Rico.

25:12

many many time like another example I

25:15

can give you it is little bit out of the

25:18

things of my challenge like I do I do I

25:21

told you that I also do the emergency

25:23

response the first day I walk into the

25:26

ground zero after the 911 horrific

25:28

incident I knew nothing absolutely

25:31

nothing what needed to be done because

25:33

that kind of incident we environmental

25:35

engineer never faced what needed to be

25:38

done I walked in with one asbesttor

25:41

sampler tiny little 1 PM10 sampler

25:46

and knowing nothing. Ultimately I

25:49

accepted the challenge and I realize

25:52

that this tool do everything. We set up

25:55

28 different environmental indicator

25:57

sampler inside the ground zero just

26:00

outside the ground zero just out to the

26:02

city to compare the basement baseline

26:05

condition of the ground zero with other

26:06

outside. So I took challenges like this

26:09

almost throughout my career. My life was

26:13

a challenge. I told you that I started

26:14

as a homeless here in this country and I

26:17

realized I need to accept the challenge

26:19

and I did it. I can give you I can talk

26:22

to a sidebar

26:24

long time if you want what kind of

26:26

challenges I took.

26:27

>> Thank you Mr.

26:28

>> I know the time is short.

26:29

>> Thank you for the examples though. I

26:31

appreciate it. Thank you president.

26:34

>> Thank you Councilwoman Daniels. Do you

26:37

have any questions?

26:40

>> Yeah, thank you.

26:41

>> Okay. Thank you. Thank you for your

26:44

presence here this evening. I move to

26:46

add resolution 55 of 2025 to our next

26:51

legislative session agenda for a formal

26:53

vote. Thank you.

26:54

>> Thank you. Thank you everybody.

27:03

Next we have resolution 56 of 2025. Mr.

27:07

Trudale, could you please read it into

27:09

the record?

27:10

>> Resolution 56, 2025, a resolution

27:13

appointing Sharon Horn to serve as a

27:15

member of the board of the Harrisburg

27:17

Housing Authority.

27:18

>> Thank you, Miss Horn, if you wouldn't

27:20

mind joining us.

27:44

Good evening. I'll ask or remind you of

27:46

the same thing if you could please move

27:48

the microphone very close to you so that

27:50

those listening and watching are able to

27:52

hear. if you wouldn't mind taking a few

27:54

minutes to please introduce yourself.

27:56

>> Okay. My name is Sharon Horn.

27:59

Um I've been living in Harrisburg all my

28:01

life. Um I have worked for Department of

28:04

Environmental Protection for 36 years.

28:06

I'm retired. Um doing administrative

28:09

work. I did a lot of other work too. So

28:12

I just don't want to I'm going to be

28:13

mindful of the time. I just don't want

28:14

to take a whole lot of time. But I did a

28:15

whole lot of work far as um payroll, you

28:19

know, customer service and stuff like

28:21

that. And also I went to school for

28:23

criminal justice. But um that's about

28:26

it. I I mean just like helping people um

28:30

u just like I said I help 14 people get

28:33

healthc care services. Um and that's the

28:35

type of work I like to do. Just help

28:38

people when they in a need or they're

28:39

trying to get information to get them to

28:41

the right place. Um writing letters for

28:44

them you know just walking with them and

28:46

sitting with them make sure they get

28:48

through whatever their situation they

28:49

need to get through.

28:53

Okay. So, just as a reminder, this

28:55

appointment is to serve as a member of

28:57

the board of the Harrisburg Housing

28:59

Authority.

29:00

>> Um, the city of Harrisburg formed the

29:02

Harrisburg Housing Authority in 1938 in

29:06

accordance with the Housing Authorities

29:08

Law. The Housing Authorities Law, as

29:10

amended, provides for a five member

29:12

board made up of residents of the city

29:15

who shall serve staggered five-year

29:17

terms. Under the statutory framework

29:20

provided through the Harrisburg or

29:22

excuse me through the housing

29:24

authorities law, the current staggered

29:27

terms of board seat should expire in

29:30

2025, 2026,

29:33

2027,

29:35

2028, and 2029.

29:39

What makes you interested in this

29:40

appointment, Miss Horn?

29:42

>> Because I used to work for housing

29:43

authority back in 19 1979.

29:47

So, um, back then I'm seeing ins and

29:49

outs is it's a little bit different

29:51

today than it was back then. Um, a lot

29:55

of times the managers would go out and

29:57

communicate with the comm their

29:58

residents. Um, walk the premises and,

30:01

you know, just to, you know, get

30:03

acquainted with the re the residents.

30:06

Um, I just feel the reason why I really

30:10

would um like to be on a committee

30:12

because it needs some transparency. It

30:16

needs some things needs to be changed.

30:19

Um

30:21

to make sure you know those who are

30:23

waiting on a list, they have a list and

30:26

people been on that list for four or

30:28

five and six years. Then you have and

30:31

and trying to get into a larger units,

30:34

right? And they can't get in larger

30:36

units because they're seeing if somebody

30:38

else takes presidents over what what

30:40

they've been on the list all the years,

30:42

get presidents over them. We don't know

30:45

the emergencies. So, I think they need

30:47

to be transparent with that. Um people

30:51

um residents have children that's of age

30:53

that should not be in the same rooms

30:55

with their siblings. Um they need that

30:58

needs to be changed. Um something needs

31:01

to be done about that. Why should

31:03

somebody be on six years and somebody

31:05

else come in and just get presence over

31:08

them? I understand they have rules and

31:10

regulations of what they need to do, but

31:12

still yet

31:14

what what what presence they take was

31:17

over them that for them to be able to

31:18

get be their unit the larger unit and

31:21

they still in the smaller unit. So it

31:24

just need to be a lot of transparency

31:25

there to make sure you know those a on

31:27

list are being treated fairly. Um also

31:30

um the resident services would I want to

31:33

know are the residents are being

31:35

provided with supportive services to

31:36

improve self-sufficiency,

31:39

employment, education outcomes for

31:40

residents? Um are they providing them

31:43

the services that they say they are they

31:45

have listed? I would like to see um

31:48

Harrisburg Housing Authority create a

31:50

community resident newsletter to send

31:52

out to the tenants, you know, regarding

31:54

th those services they say that they

31:57

have and how can they receive these

31:59

services providing the service um the

32:00

resident with updates, you know,

32:02

whatever kind of programs they have for

32:04

the residents. Um I think that will be

32:06

good to educate our residents. Some of

32:09

them, you know, have a program of

32:11

teaching them how to budget if you're

32:13

trying to move them forward out to to um

32:16

to get out of, you know, because really

32:18

you should use them them the homes, the

32:21

projects I call them, you know, the the

32:23

housing that if you're trying to move

32:25

them out, then educate them so they can

32:28

be able to move out. Um I the Harrisburg

32:31

Housing Authority has a thing as far as

32:35

um the employment. Oh, I'm going use me

32:38

for example. One time I said, "Well, I

32:40

wanted to go back." Cuz I was retired,

32:42

so I wanted to go back. And I said, "Let

32:44

me see." Cuz they had a a position open.

32:46

I said, "Well, let me go see if I can

32:48

get in." I could not get in. I can even

32:51

put an application in. And no

32:53

disrespect, but they said because I was

32:54

a bilingual. So, you know, you have they

32:58

go, they have a lot of bilingual in the

33:01

offices. Is nothing wrong. Everybody

33:02

needs a job. Don't get me wrong.

33:04

Everybody needs a job. But I'm saying it

33:06

should be fair practices because

33:08

sometimes you have people that commu

33:10

community that may not commu can

33:12

communicate with those that speak about

33:15

they want to communicate with someone

33:17

else. So I think it should be a fact a

33:21

factor in there that they should be able

33:23

to get a job. I mean back then they had

33:25

translators you know people that was in

33:27

there that would be able to translate

33:29

and then you had your English too. So

33:31

you know that's another factor. it's

33:33

hard for them to get jobs in housing

33:35

authority. So, cuz I seen when I went

33:38

there and how it was I have helped um

33:42

uh a young lady who was facing eviction

33:46

um did everything try to help her been

33:48

in the went to the meetings with her

33:49

went back to back with her to make sure

33:51

you know things was being done in the

33:53

perspective and decency order but she

33:56

and she did not get evicted because she

33:59

did everything she needed to do. I

34:00

helped her do everything that she needed

34:01

to do. She was able to get section 8.

34:04

She got section 8, which was good. I was

34:07

really glad for that. But, you know, um,

34:10

they waited two year. I helped her clean

34:12

up her place. They waited two years to

34:14

give this girl a maintenance bill.

34:18

How's that? How you wait two years to

34:20

give somebody a maintenance bill? So, it

34:22

just think things need to be changed. I

34:24

think things need, you know, a lot of

34:26

changes need to be done in Harrisburg

34:29

housing authority. I think um with the

34:31

management how I have instances when

34:35

people have moved out of of out of a

34:38

residence and the same people moved back

34:40

in the same residence. I seen that my

34:42

mother-in-law was living out there. Um

34:44

it was one next door to her and it was

34:47

one across the street for her that did

34:48

that. So I'm like how can you move out

34:50

and come right back in the same place

34:52

when people are on the list waiting to

34:54

get in? So I just think it needs to be

34:56

some transparency. need things need to

34:58

be some changes done and I think you

35:00

know and I and I go back to back I will

35:02

you know fight hard for the residents

35:04

the residents need to know that it's

35:06

somebody there that's going to help them

35:08

that's going to back help back them

35:10

because I'm not saying all residents are

35:12

you know where they need to be but there

35:14

some are that you know that needs help.

35:16

So you know that's what I would like to

35:18

do to try to get in there and try to

35:19

make some changes.

35:21

>> Thank you. I just wanted to uh note just

35:23

a few things. Um, the Harrisburg Housing

35:26

Authority operates independently from

35:28

the city, but its work is essential to

35:31

community stability, economic

35:33

opportunity, and neighborhood

35:34

revitalization.

35:36

>> The general functions of the authority

35:39

include public housing management owns,

35:43

manages, and maintains public housing

35:45

developments within the city. Housing

35:47

Choice Voucher Program administers

35:50

section 8 vouchers to assist income

35:52

eligible families in securing affordable

35:55

rental housing. Redevelopment and

35:57

modernization undertakes projects to

36:01

rehabilitate, modernize or replace aging

36:04

housing stock. Resident services provide

36:07

supportive services to improve

36:09

self-sufficiency, employment, and

36:11

educational outcomes for residents.

36:14

Partnerships works with federal, state,

36:16

and local agencies as well as private

36:19

developers to expand affordable housing

36:22

opportunities, financial powers

36:24

authorized by state law to issue bonds,

36:27

apply for federal housing funds, and

36:30

collect rents or service charges, and

36:33

governance directed by a board of

36:35

commissioners appointed under provisions

36:38

of the housing authorities law. So, I

36:41

just wanted to note that.

36:43

I do have a question for the law bureau.

36:46

Um I believe Miss Horn would be

36:50

replacing an individual there one term

36:53

has expired

36:56

finishing a term.

36:57

>> I believe that when this originally came

37:02

>> okay wait

37:05

>> my bad.

37:06

>> Can you hear me now?

37:07

>> Yes.

37:08

>> There we go.

37:08

>> Thank you. So, I believe when I

37:09

originally sent it down, the terms were

37:12

in there, but I did not. It's set in

37:15

committee, so I don't remember off top

37:16

of my head. If not, I can get it.

37:18

>> I have it. Hold on.

37:20

>> I thought so.

37:20

>> Okay. So,

37:23

yes, this was in June that you sent

37:25

this, but I got you. Okay. So, um,

37:30

Miss Gloria Martin Roberts was appointed

37:32

through resolution 28 of 2024 and her

37:36

term expires June 30th, 2029.

37:40

Miss Sheila Bennett was appointed

37:41

through resolution 46 of 2022 and her

37:45

term expires June 30th, 2027.

37:49

Mr. Ja Zachary Jackson was appointed

37:52

through resolution 29 of 2024 and his

37:56

term expires June 30th, 2026.

38:00

Um, two openings will end in 2025 and

38:04

2028. Whoever is appointed to 2025

38:09

should also be appointed to the term

38:11

ending in 2030 as their term for 2025

38:15

would only last 5 days. Okay.

38:20

Okay. So, um this is a fiveyear

38:25

appointment.

38:26

>> Okay.

38:26

>> So, just so you know that. Okay. I don't

38:29

have any other questions. I'm going to

38:31

open it up to my colleagues who may have

38:34

additional questions for you. I'll begin

38:36

with our building and housing committee

38:39

chair, Councilwoman Davis. Do you have

38:42

any questions for Miss Horn?

38:45

>> Thank you, President Hill. And good

38:47

evening, Miss Horn. How are you?

38:49

>> I'm fine. Thank you. Thank you for your

38:50

willingness to serve. Um

38:54

and thank you for um noting all of the

38:58

things that you would like to do, things

39:01

that you observed and that you realize

39:04

that there needs to be some support and

39:06

some additional help there. One of the

39:09

things that I was concerned about as the

39:11

building and housing chair

39:13

>> is the safety of the residents. Um, I

39:16

guess I could take the time right now to

39:18

thank uh Chief Eterling Line and the

39:22

deputy uh fire chief. Also, the fire the

39:27

evacuation system for the residents at

39:31

the various facilities um under the

39:34

Harrisburg Housing Authority. I like to

39:38

um this you can note make sure that

39:42

every building is safe and that everyone

39:46

knows how to evacuate

39:48

>> right

39:49

>> in case of an a fire um or something.

39:53

So, I know that our fire department has

39:57

been working on ensuring that uh the

40:01

evacuation system is up to date, but I

40:04

just thought I would mention that to

40:07

you. So, you can kind of oversee if you

40:11

get selected for this.

40:13

>> Okay.

40:13

>> To make sure that Yeah. Because we had a

40:16

couple of residents come down here

40:19

>> to talk about their concern.

40:22

um and their concern for being safe in

40:25

the facility.

40:26

>> Okay.

40:27

>> So, once we went through, you know,

40:30

checking with the logs and everything,

40:33

the fire department actually realized

40:36

that the um evacuation system was not up

40:40

to par and helped to make the correction

40:43

at that particular facility. So,

40:47

we can never be too safe,

40:49

>> right? We want to make sure that our

40:51

residents know how to get out in case of

40:54

a fire. So,

40:56

>> right.

40:57

>> That's uh

40:58

>> my own those are my only statements.

41:00

>> Do they do they give them any kind of

41:03

like

41:03

>> I have no idea. I don't know. I just

41:07

>> kind of

41:08

>> Yeah, because you know

41:09

>> followed up based on uh a resident who

41:12

came two residents that came down here.

41:14

>> Okay. So, um I did report back to our

41:18

director, Director Gloria Martin

41:20

Roberts, um and the housing authority, I

41:24

guess, um the new president or director

41:27

of the housing authority. I can't

41:29

remember his name right now, but

41:31

>> I did, you know, follow up with them as

41:33

well. So, um that was just one of the

41:37

things that came to mind, the safety of

41:40

the residents,

41:41

>> the Harrisburg house Housing Authority

41:44

in the facility. So, thank you for being

41:46

here again and thank you.

41:48

>> Welcome.

41:50

>> Thank you, Councilwoman Daniels. Do you

41:52

have any questions?

41:57

>> Just for the conflicts of interest.

42:02

>> Conflicts of interest. You broke up a

42:04

little bit, but I think that's what you

42:05

were asking.

42:08

>> Yes.

42:11

>> Do you have any conflicts of interest?

42:13

>> No. No, I'm trying to, you know, I have

42:15

no confident interest at all.

42:21

>> That wasn't perfect. Thank you.

42:23

>> Thank you, Vice President Green. Any

42:25

questions?

42:26

>> Thank you, President Hill. Uh, first,

42:28

thank you for being here tonight. Um,

42:29

and thank you for your willingness to

42:31

step up, uh, you know, even outside of

42:33

the election to to still follow through

42:35

and say, I want to to be a part of the

42:36

change and and help the city in any

42:38

capacity possible. So, thank you for

42:39

that.

42:40

Um my only question is how did you hear

42:42

about the position and what made you

42:44

want it?

42:45

>> Because um I I wanted to be on a

42:48

committee, you know, something do

42:49

something in house, you know, try to

42:52

help somebody. I mean, you know, cuz I

42:54

did run for city council, but you know,

42:57

just to to help some, you know, just to

42:59

help. Yeah.

43:01

>> And how did you find out about it?

43:02

>> I found out um who somebody was telling

43:05

me about that. Was it was

43:10

I don't want to put I don't like putting

43:12

people's names out there like that, but

43:15

you know what I mean. I found out. Okay.

43:19

So, um don't want to put people's names

43:22

out there. I'm not that type of person.

43:24

Okay. I'm respectful to people who, you

43:28

know, to just like I'll be respectful

43:29

for you to you. So, I don't do that. So

43:32

I was I was informed about committees

43:34

that was being open and and I and they

43:38

named some of the committees and that

43:39

was one of the committees I chose.

43:41

>> Okay. So they told you about several

43:43

different positions that were open

43:45

couple a couple committees was open and

43:49

I

43:51

wanted to be on one.

43:52

>> Okay. Um, I don't ask it in any

43:55

disrespectful way or ask you to call out

43:57

anybody's name. No, but more in the

43:58

sense of, you know, when people come

44:00

before us, people always ask, well, how

44:01

did so and so get on that committee? How

44:03

did that get filled? How did people even

44:04

know these were available? So, I like to

44:06

be able to say, well, someone approached

44:08

them or they just took the initiative

44:09

and got on the website or they were

44:11

listening to a city council meeting.

44:12

>> I do get on your website.

44:13

>> They listened to last week's meeting and

44:15

heard about all the empty positions. you

44:17

know, like we like to figure out how

44:19

people find out about these cuz there

44:20

are lots of positions that are open and

44:22

we're always trying to fill them. Um,

44:25

and we we also know that it's impossible

44:27

for every position to be filled by

44:29

someone going specifically to someone

44:31

and saying, "Hey, I think you'll be a

44:32

fit for this committee." So, it's like

44:34

what's the best way to get people

44:36

engaged? because that's the only way we

44:37

can really move our city forward if we

44:39

have different perspectives and

44:40

different ideas and different

44:42

backgrounds because the city itself is

44:44

diverse and we can't have the same

44:45

thought processes uh picking and

44:47

choosing who's on every board. So, no I

44:49

appreciate

44:50

>> I go on your I go online I'll be

44:52

checking I'll be looking. So,

44:54

>> Okay. Yeah.

44:55

>> Well, I'm glad to hear that that you're

44:57

continuing to be engaged and that you're

44:58

always looking for ways to be involved

45:00

in the city. So, I appreciate you being

45:02

here tonight and I appreciate your

45:03

willingness to serve the city and the

45:05

residents.

45:06

>> Right. Thank you.

45:08

>> Thank you, Councilwoman Ross. Any

45:10

questions?

45:11

>> Thank you. Thank you for being here

45:13

tonight and thank you for um being

45:15

willing to serve and showing your

45:17

commitment even outside of

45:19

>> um the race and saying, you know, I

45:21

still want to help the city in some way.

45:23

So, thank you. Um one of my questions

45:25

were already um asked about how did you

45:27

hear about the position? So my other

45:29

question was just

45:31

>> um how do you think you will be a leader

45:33

that will promote change um on this

45:36

board because it is a very important

45:38

board. So

45:39

>> how do you think you will be a leader

45:40

that will promote change?

45:41

>> You know first of all you got to do

45:44

things of decency and order. You know

45:46

you have to have like mind. You have to

45:48

work together on a committee. I don't

45:50

care what committee you're on work it

45:52

work together. Everybody's not going to

45:54

be agreement but this you just agreed to

45:56

come to an agreement. I mean, you know,

45:58

just do what I know how to do and lead,

46:02

you know what I mean? So, that's where

46:04

I'm at.

46:05

>> Thank you. Thank you, Miss Horn. That's

46:07

it for me, President Hill.

46:09

>> Thank you, Councilman Rodriguez. Any

46:11

questions?

46:12

>> Thank you, Madam President. Thank you,

46:13

Miss Horn, for joining us this evening.

46:15

Great to see you again. Um, I just

46:17

thought, uh, Madame Vice President's

46:19

question was so important because a lot

46:21

of times we never know where a lot of

46:23

these individuals come from and in the

46:25

capacities they like to serve in and we

46:27

just want to make sure we're handpicking

46:28

the best of the best as you've always

46:30

been engaged. Um, sometimes we never

46:32

know what behind the scenes and behind

46:34

the veil brings. So, the question was

46:36

just very transparent also was one of my

46:38

questions as well. So, I just wanted to

46:39

kind of um, beat on that. But also, if

46:42

you could uh create anything innovative

46:44

for HHA, what would that thing be or

46:47

what would you advocate for as a new

46:49

board member?

46:50

>> I would advocate for try to get, you

46:53

know, like that um the residents in that

46:56

community to come together and try to

47:00

put something together. what what they

47:02

want fixed or what what is needed what

47:05

you know what what is what is express

47:07

their concerns about what's going on

47:09

where they live at you know what I mean

47:11

and try to get that information and to

47:14

see what you we can decipher out of it

47:16

and see what we can do about helping

47:18

them with their their um their

47:20

situations. That's what I would like to

47:22

hear more or less from the community

47:25

just to see where they're at and see

47:26

what's going on. I know cuz some of

47:29

them's I I have heard some of them is

47:31

not too happy about certain things that

47:33

goes on. So, you know, I mean, things

47:35

need to be addressed. It always have

47:37

been needed to be addressed. They're not

47:39

being addressed. Um I just wonder if all

47:42

these programs or policies they're

47:44

doing, are they really informing the

47:47

residents of what, you know, what's

47:49

going on? You know, like I have read,

47:51

you know, um the services, the support

47:53

services they have. Are they really

47:56

letting them community know that these

47:58

services are available?

48:01

>> And that's why you mentioned the

48:02

newsletter previously.

48:03

>> They should have a kind of you don't

48:05

have to do it every month. You could do

48:06

it every quarter. You know what I'm

48:07

saying? Just get something out there to

48:09

the to the residents to let them know,

48:11

you know, you know, you're involved with

48:13

them. You want to make sure they in the

48:14

know, you know, and you know, they have

48:16

a lot of questions. I know a lot of them

48:18

has things a lot of questions. They just

48:20

don't know who to go to to get the

48:23

answer.

48:24

Thank you for that answer and your

48:26

willingness to serve. Um, no further

48:28

questions for me.

48:29

>> Thank you,

48:31

>> Councilman Jones.

48:32

>> Thank you, President Hill. How you doing

48:33

today?

48:34

>> How you doing?

48:35

>> Good. Good. Um, just like everyone else,

48:37

thank you for your willingness to serve.

48:40

Um, I have a couple questions for you.

48:42

And, um, I think one that Vice President

48:44

Green had asked again and he re

48:47

reiterated was was the honest question.

48:50

And reason being um I'm just want to

48:53

speak for me.

48:54

>> Okay.

48:54

>> Um I see a lot of these uh positions

48:56

that come open and people that come are

48:59

sent to fill them

49:01

>> um just don't meet the qualifications

49:03

for these positions. I want to say to

49:06

you that I am proud of you continuing to

49:09

fight

49:10

>> right

49:10

>> and what and your willingness to serve.

49:13

But I would question this particular

49:15

committee. I'm not saying you don't meet

49:17

any other ones. I'm just looking at your

49:20

resume, but I feel your passion and I

49:22

see and I hear you saying what you want

49:24

to do um to help these residents. But

49:27

how familiar are you with HUD

49:29

regulations and and

49:30

>> Yeah, I'm familiar. I said I familiar

49:33

>> Yeah, I have worked with them in 1979.

49:36

So, you know, they have their like HUD

49:39

is a certain way that criteria you have

49:41

to go through to even get on getting to

49:43

section 8. They have different rules and

49:46

regulations as far as how you can um get

49:49

in, you know, get section A get into the

49:52

um into the residence, you know. But the

49:54

point is is my thing is how HUD how the

49:59

uh transparency of how people are on the

50:01

list? How do they move the people on the

50:04

list? How do they get to these places?

50:06

you know the timing how people be on

50:09

years and why aren't they being moved

50:11

but you're bringing other people in over

50:14

them giving them bigger larger units

50:16

when other people are waiting for you I

50:19

just want to know the process I'm just

50:21

finding

50:21

>> and that's pretty much what I'm trying

50:22

to ask you how how do you understand the

50:25

policies and the thing this is a this is

50:27

a huge

50:28

>> they say is like like when people they

50:30

they were say well it was an emergency

50:33

like a lot of times when people want to

50:35

get you know get moved into larger

50:37

units, they will say, "Well, it was

50:39

emergency something. This family had

50:41

presence over this family, but they're

50:45

sometimes it's not clear of what they're

50:47

they're they're saying because sometimes

50:49

it's not an emergency. Some people are

50:51

getting there because of certain favors

50:54

of people they know. So I do know that

50:57

know that you know

50:58

>> again that's the that's the part that I

51:00

hear that's very strong in you that

51:02

>> I don't I don't I'm like for far as HUD

51:05

HUD changed changed from the years that

51:07

I have been working for them. So as far

51:09

as their ruling and how they operate I

51:11

can't tell you exactly how they operate.

51:13

>> Yeah because we're talking about um

51:15

making decisions on revitalization in

51:17

these communities. I mean this is a this

51:19

is a a huge responsibility and again

51:22

what I'm hearing is the the passion that

51:24

you have to serve the people. I am just

51:27

not sure that this is the place um what

51:30

you want to change. You're talking about

51:32

changing law.

51:34

>> I'm not trying to change.

51:35

>> Yeah. Yeah. You're saying you want to

51:37

look at the policy. I mean

51:39

>> no I just want to see how

51:42

I'm sorry.

51:44

Uh what I'm saying is how you're seeing

51:46

how the treatment of the residents are,

51:49

how people are getting picked for this

51:50

and that. That's why I'm asking you how

51:53

familiar are you with uh you know the

51:55

housing authority and its policies. You

51:58

know a lot of these things this is a a

52:00

huge responsibility and that's just my

52:03

only concern. your passion and

52:05

everything else for the people of this

52:06

city is strong and I I know it's real

52:09

but again my concern is just on this

52:11

particular board I'm just a little

52:13

concerned personally of of of giving the

52:16

>> So what is your main concern you're

52:17

saying the revitalization of what the

52:20

>> so do you let me ask you this okay

52:22

>> do you know the scope of work in this

52:24

seat

52:24

>> the scope of work of the seat

52:26

>> that you're willing to serve on yes

52:27

>> yeah I'm willing to ser willing to serve

52:29

on this on the um committee yeah to um

52:32

to make Sure. It's transparency, but

52:35

also like you said, what she had just

52:38

read, I didn't read I read the whole the

52:40

whole thing, but

52:41

>> it's a lot.

52:42

>> I mean, it's a lot. I work for 36 years.

52:44

I know how to work and it's a lot. I

52:46

worked in I did um work for

52:49

comprollers's office, so it work. I'm

52:51

not afraid to work. I'm not afraid to

52:53

learn I mean to learn new things cuz you

52:55

you just can't every time when you get

52:57

in a position, you're not everybody's

52:59

not going to get a position and know

53:01

what that position is doing. You're

53:02

going to have to be taught some things.

53:03

You're going to have to learn some

53:04

things. So, I'm the type I research. I

53:07

search things. If I need to know what I

53:09

need to know, I'm going to find out what

53:11

I need to know.

53:12

>> And that's just me,

53:13

>> okay?

53:14

>> I'm a go-getter. So, you know what I

53:16

mean? I'm going to make sure that I'm

53:17

not going to go overstep no kind of

53:19

boundaries that I don't need to

53:21

overstep. I'm going to make sure I'm

53:23

doing things in decency and order.

53:25

>> Okay. No further questions.

53:28

>> Thank you. I have one more question and

53:30

then no more. Okay. Um, I was just

53:34

curious because I didn't see it on your

53:36

resume. You said you worked for the

53:38

housing authority in 1979.

53:40

>> Yeah, cuz I graduated in 78. Um, came

53:43

right out of school and work for

53:44

>> Oh. What was your role then?

53:46

>> I was upfront a receptionist clerical

53:48

worker. Okay.

53:49

>> But I, you know, I I took rents. I did

53:51

bookkeeping and everything like that. I

53:53

was more or less out in the front.

53:54

>> Okay.

53:55

>> Calming things down.

53:58

>> Okay. Thank you.

53:59

Um, are there any other questions for

54:02

Miss Horn?

54:05

Okay, seeing and hearing none, I move to

54:08

add resolution 56 of 2025 to our next

54:12

legislative session agenda for a formal

54:15

vote. Thank you.

54:16

>> Okay. Thank you. Appreciate it.

54:20

Next,

54:22

we have the discussion of the committee

54:24

business for the community and economic

54:27

development committee. I will defer to

54:30

our community and economic development

54:32

committee chair, Councilwoman Daniels,

54:34

to lead discussion.

54:37

>> Thank you. Um, today the committee is

54:39

only uh seeing resolution 60th in 2025.

54:43

So, uh, Mr. Triel, do you mind reading

54:45

that into the record?

54:48

Resolution 60, 2025, a resolution

54:51

approving the preliminary/final land

54:53

development plan for 315 North Second

54:56

Street submitted by Adam Brenamman with

54:57

Brenamman Properties LLC to convert the

55:00

existing office building into a 10-unit

55:02

multifamily dwelling and associated site

55:05

and access improvements.

55:08

>> Thank you. Um, is there a representative

55:09

for the applicant here?

55:12

>> It does not appear so at this time.

55:14

>> Okay. Okay. So, I would just like to

55:16

disclose based on the name there's a

55:19

possibility I might have a conflict, but

55:21

I will check on that. I'll have I'll ask

55:24

the clerk to check on that tomorrow. Um,

55:27

and we'll in the meantime, we'll proceed

55:28

and if there's a conflict, I'll just uh

55:30

refrain from voting or further

55:32

deliberations. Um, so uh Mr. Jeeoff, if

55:37

you don't mind uh introducing yourself

55:38

and giving us a brief dis description of

55:40

the project, the process, and if you

55:42

have any information on timeline and

55:44

things like that for the project, that

55:46

would be great as well.

55:47

>> Uh sure, and I'll try and provide as

55:49

much uh background as I can on this

55:50

project. Uh Jeffrey Knight with the uh

55:53

uh planning director for the city of

55:54

Harrisburg. Uh the application before

55:57

council tonight is a land development

55:59

plan for the property at 315 North

56:01

Second Street. Uh this is um a uh parcel

56:07

that's um comprised of three different

56:10

uh buildings uh that were internally uh

56:13

connected I think sometime in the 1980s

56:15

I believe. Uh and since that time, it's

56:18

been operating as an office building. Uh

56:20

as uh council is aware, uh as I

56:23

presented several of these uh this year,

56:25

uh to you all, um the long-term trends

56:28

of office vacancy in the city here is uh

56:31

being met uh by redevelopment as

56:34

residential uh uh apartment buildings.

56:36

Um and this uh project is uh along those

56:40

same lines. Uh the space is being uh

56:43

redeveloped into a 10 unit uh multif

56:46

family dwelling. Um the the uh

56:51

applicants uh could uh probably provide

56:54

a little bit more on the um layout and

56:56

configuration of the space, but they'll

56:57

be in one and two unit configurations.

57:00

Um I believe they were up to uh 1,200

57:04

square ft for one of the two unit

57:05

buildings or two uh bedroom units. uh

57:08

that was on the uh second and third

57:10

floors uh has a loft configuration. So,

57:13

uh, the project is going to, uh, propose

57:16

several different types of unit designs

57:18

as opposed to maybe the smaller, uh,

57:20

more uniform designs that, um, council

57:24

has maybe seen for some of the other

57:25

buildings. And I think that's a lot of

57:26

that's due to the internal configuration

57:28

of the space, uh, with different, um,

57:31

stairways and entrances and building

57:33

support systems like walls. Um and uh

57:36

the project required the approval of a

57:39

variance application which the applicant

57:41

did receive uh during the June meetings.

57:44

Um so this is the second component uh of

57:47

the project, the land development

57:49

portion. Um and um the applicant uh in

57:54

addition to the internal configuration

57:56

of the space, the applicant does have

57:57

eight off- streetet parking spaces uh in

58:00

the lot directly behind the uh

58:02

buildings. Um it's the same lot that's

58:04

shared with uh I believe the Verizon

58:06

Tower there at the corner of um Second

58:08

and um Pine Street. Um and so even

58:13

though the property is located in the

58:15

commercial neighborhood zoning district

58:16

and is thus not required to have off

58:18

streetet parking, they are able to

58:19

provide uh eight spaces for residents

58:22

and their guests. Um, with that all

58:25

being said, the planning commission has

58:29

recommended that city council approve

58:31

the request with the following um for

58:35

the following reasons. The project has

58:38

received the requisite zoning relief

58:39

approval to convert the property into a

58:41

10-unit multif family dwelling. Uh, the

58:43

adaptive reuse of vacant and

58:44

underutilized office spaces into

58:46

apartment buildings is a long-term trend

58:48

uh for the neighborhood in downtown

58:50

Harrisburg. Uh other conversions of

58:52

former office buildings in the

58:53

surrounding neighborhood have

58:54

demonstrated the proposed use will not

58:56

adversely impact the character of the

58:57

neighborhood and the project will help

58:59

retain existing architecturally and

59:01

historically significant buildings.

59:04

And the proposed reuse will add

59:06

residents to the neighborhood to

59:07

activate the street on nights and

59:09

weekends and grow a customer base to

59:10

support local businesses and will

59:12

provide additional units to the downtown

59:13

housing inventory.

59:20

Thank you. Um I'm just going to open

59:22

this up for my colleagues. I'll start to

59:26

my my immediate left, Councilwoman um

59:30

Davis.

59:33

>> Thank you, Councilwoman Daniels. And uh

59:36

good evening, Mr. Knight. Thank you for

59:38

being here. I don't have any questions

59:40

about this project. Thank you.

59:43

>> You vice president Green.

59:45

>> Thank you very much. I don't have any

59:47

questions regarding this.

59:49

>> President Hill,

59:50

>> I do have questions, but Mr. Knight, I

59:53

don't I think they're for the applicant.

59:56

>> Okay.

59:56

>> Um,

59:58

so thank you,

1:00:01

>> Councilwoman.

1:00:03

>> Thank you, Councilwoman Daniels. I also

1:00:05

have questions, but they were for the

1:00:07

applicant. And

1:00:09

not that you wouldn't do a great job,

1:00:11

director Knight, but I also feel that um

1:00:14

coming into the city and wanting city

1:00:16

and wanting to have a project here, it's

1:00:19

um nice to show up and let us see who

1:00:21

you are and what you're going to bring

1:00:23

to the neighborhood and get a feel for

1:00:25

you because if you don't show up here,

1:00:27

you're going to show up for the

1:00:27

residents. I mean, you know, it's all

1:00:29

those kind of thoughts.

1:00:30

>> Um so I would prefer to ask them were

1:00:33

they why aren't they here? That would be

1:00:35

my question if anybody knows

1:00:37

>> here.

1:00:38

>> So, I had spoken to I had sent an email

1:00:40

out like I do with all of the the other

1:00:42

attendees here tonight and then I had

1:00:44

spoken to Mr. Brenamman on Friday who

1:00:46

assured me a team member would be here.

1:00:47

It just doesn't look like they made it.

1:00:50

>> Okay. No call, no show maybe. I don't

1:00:52

know. But, um yeah, maybe if they could

1:00:54

come in, I don't know. Um that would be

1:00:57

nice. So, I don't have any other

1:00:58

questions.

1:01:00

>> Thank you,

1:01:00

>> Councilman Rodriguez. Uh, it's always

1:01:03

good to see you all the time, Jeff. I

1:01:05

appreciate you being here, but I too had

1:01:07

questions to the applicant targeted the

1:01:09

demographics, affordability, WBE, MB

1:01:12

participation, etc., etc., etc. Um, so

1:01:15

it's, you know, I don't want to kind of

1:01:17

beat that horse down on you because it's

1:01:18

only but so much you can give us, but

1:01:20

um, I was highly hoping to speak with

1:01:22

someone from Brenamman today. So, um, I

1:01:25

guess the questions I do have I have to

1:01:26

keep on reserve. So, thank you for

1:01:28

joining us.

1:01:29

>> Thank you, Councilman Jones. Thank you,

1:01:32

Councilwoman Daniels. I'm going to stay

1:01:34

in tune. No questions.

1:01:41

>> Um, well, you have several options,

1:01:43

Councilwoman. Um, the deemed approved

1:01:45

date is not Oh.

1:01:49

>> Oh, sorry, Councilwoman Daniels. Um, the

1:01:53

deemed approved date is November 4th.

1:01:56

So, you could move it to the legislative

1:01:58

session. suspend discuss in front of the

1:02:01

applicant. They do have time to not move

1:02:05

until the next legislative session, you

1:02:07

know, so it's up to how she would they

1:02:10

were very active. Um, Mr. Brenamman

1:02:13

himself came to planning and then his uh

1:02:17

site managers came to zoning. So, I

1:02:20

don't know if it's miscommunication.

1:02:22

>> I'm sorry, I didn't hear what Mr.

1:02:23

Councilman Jones had said.

1:02:26

Uh, I just said that I was just going to

1:02:28

stay in uniform. I didn't have any

1:02:30

questions. Um,

1:02:31

>> Oh,

1:02:31

>> yeah, that's all.

1:02:33

>> Okay. Thank you. Sorry. So, um, you were

1:02:35

saying do the deemed do the deemed

1:02:37

accepted day is November 4th.

1:02:40

>> Yes, ma'am.

1:02:41

>> Okay. Thank you. So, I'm going to just

1:02:43

recommend I'm not going to rep recommend

1:02:46

that it be placed in on the next

1:02:47

legislative session just because I also

1:02:49

have the conflicts of interest questions

1:02:51

myself. So, I'm going to wait for Mr.

1:02:53

choose to speak with the applicant and

1:02:55

see whether they want to come in and

1:02:58

introduce themselves or at the very

1:02:59

least get the conflict questions for

1:03:01

myself out of the way and then proceed

1:03:03

accordingly. Um so I I'll just recommend

1:03:07

that we not add this to the next

1:03:09

legislative session and we'll

1:03:11

communicate with um a President Hill

1:03:14

when I hear back from Mr. Brenamman.

1:03:17

>> Okay, that sounds like a plan. Thank

1:03:19

you. Thank you, Mr. Knight. All right.

1:03:22

>> Yeah. And that concludes the business

1:03:24

for the community and economic

1:03:25

development today.

1:03:27

>> Thank you. Our final committee business

1:03:29

this evening lies with the public safety

1:03:32

committee. So I will defer to our public

1:03:34

safety committee chair, Councilman

1:03:36

Jones, to lead discussion.

1:03:38

>> Thank you, President Hill. I see we have

1:03:40

Chief Interline in the building.

1:03:42

Uh Mr. Trudell, can you please read

1:03:45

resolution 65 of 2025? Resolution 65205,

1:03:51

a resolution approving the adoption of

1:03:53

the Dolphin County 2025 hazard

1:03:56

mitigation plan as the official hazard

1:03:58

mitigation plan of the city of

1:04:00

Harrisburg.

1:04:01

>> Thank you. Uh Chief Inline, how are you

1:04:04

today, sir?

1:04:05

>> I'm well. How about yourself, council?

1:04:07

>> Good, good, good. Um yeah, can you just

1:04:10

give us a little uh well for for the the

1:04:12

public's because this is a huge document

1:04:15

um and it's very important one in my

1:04:17

opinion. Um can you just give us uh a

1:04:20

synopsis of what we're dealing with here

1:04:22

today with the uh DMA?

1:04:25

>> Sure. So uh this is just a readoption uh

1:04:29

council has adopted I think in under my

1:04:32

watch four of these plans. I believe

1:04:34

it's about every 3 years. Uh this one

1:04:36

actually uh because Dolphin County had

1:04:38

some grant money were two years ahead of

1:04:41

schedule of of readopting. But uh at the

1:04:44

end of the day, the hazard mitigation

1:04:46

plan uh is required under the disaster

1:04:49

mitigation act of 2000. Um and every

1:04:52

municipality has to adopt one. Back

1:04:54

early uh a long time ago, Harrisburg had

1:04:56

its own uh disaster mitigation plan that

1:04:59

we had a put together and a lot of a lot

1:05:01

of manpower. Uh Dolphin County has

1:05:04

stepped in as a department of uh

1:05:06

emergency services and has combined

1:05:09

every municipality in Dolphin County

1:05:11

under one uh plan. So, it makes it a lot

1:05:13

easier to to uh work. So, everything

1:05:16

that affects the city of Harrisburg is

1:05:18

in Dolphin Countyy's plan. We just adopt

1:05:19

that through the resolution uh which

1:05:23

allows us to comport with what the uh

1:05:26

the DMA of 2000 uh is looking for. When

1:05:30

we look at the plan u you know it it

1:05:32

goes through man-made disasters, natural

1:05:34

disasters, all those things that we deal

1:05:36

with those big scale incidents. uh and

1:05:39

also having this plan uh allows us then

1:05:42

to if we do have when not if when we

1:05:45

have those disasters. So whether that is

1:05:47

we look back at wintertorm Jonas the

1:05:49

city spent a substantial amount of money

1:05:52

uh there was a disaster declaration we

1:05:54

were able to uh bring money back to the

1:05:56

city as part of the FEMA reimbursement

1:05:58

process because we had a disaster

1:06:00

mitigation plan. So, uh, we look at, you

1:06:03

know, obviously one of the biggest

1:06:04

things we have, one of the biggest

1:06:05

threats we have is the river. Um, so

1:06:07

flooding. So, protecting and being able

1:06:09

to protect, uh, those residents that we

1:06:11

have that are in the flood plane. Um,

1:06:13

and then also looking at other disasters

1:06:15

from tornadoes, you know, that we saw.

1:06:17

And unfortunately, we didn't meet the

1:06:19

criteria, uh, the threshold uh, for any

1:06:22

reimbursement for the the tornado we

1:06:24

had. Uh but uh also uh one of the one of

1:06:28

the big things that's in this plan uh we

1:06:31

worked very closely with Capital Region

1:06:33

Water and Harrisburg Redevelopment

1:06:34

Authority to ensure that the

1:06:36

dchalization of Paxton Creek uh is

1:06:38

included in this hazard mitigation plan

1:06:40

which allows us then to apply uh and

1:06:43

receive federal dollars for that

1:06:45

pre-planning, the engineering and then

1:06:47

uh ultimately the construction of that D

1:06:49

channelization project which takes

1:06:51

approximately 400 acres I believe it is

1:06:54

out of the out of the flood plane. So,

1:06:56

it's a huge project and probably a

1:06:57

hund00 million project. Uh but without

1:07:01

this plan, uh we're unable to get any of

1:07:03

those federal dollars to assist with

1:07:05

that mitigation efforts. That just a

1:07:07

real high level overview.

1:07:09

>> Yes. Um thank you for that. And I think

1:07:12

that this is um again um an important

1:07:15

plan. And I was just speaking with uh

1:07:17

Commissioner

1:07:19

um Yeah, he's is the commissioner,

1:07:22

right? Carter.

1:07:24

Commissioner Carter about a a a a

1:07:26

disaster plan or an evacuation plan that

1:07:29

we can come up with and I think of

1:07:31

course you would be involved in this as

1:07:33

well. Um again with the and I'm not

1:07:36

scaring anyone but just to re um start

1:07:38

out this TMI. I can remember when I was

1:07:40

a kid when when that leak was there I

1:07:42

know we had eye pills and all of these

1:07:44

different things. I just want to be able

1:07:46

to make sure that we can put something

1:07:48

together cuz this is is is huge right?

1:07:51

And and by the way, let me say this that

1:07:53

the public, you can see this uh plan at

1:07:57

um hazard

1:08:00

mitigation plan. PDF hazard

1:08:06

mitigation

1:08:08

plan. PDF. And you can take a look at

1:08:11

this plan. It's it's very extensive. And

1:08:15

speaking of which, I want to also

1:08:16

reiterate to the public that um

1:08:18

yesterday, the 6th of October, Capitol

1:08:22

Region Water began to temporarily pump

1:08:25

and treat water from the Sescuana River,

1:08:29

which is our secondary drinking water

1:08:31

source and it be temporarily operating

1:08:34

um and to support some critical

1:08:36

maintenance and vital components of

1:08:38

CRW's drinking water infrastructure. So

1:08:41

again, I just wanted to make sure the

1:08:42

public know that that they are pumping

1:08:44

water, drinking water from uh the

1:08:47

Suscoana River. And that's pretty much

1:08:50

what I have. Go ahead. I see you.

1:08:52

>> So I I I do want to touch on the Crane

1:08:54

Clean Energy uh restart. So uh the

1:08:57

Bureau of Fire uh by designation uh is

1:09:01

the emergency managers for the city. So

1:09:03

that disaster mitigation plan for

1:09:05

anything that happens at Crane uh the

1:09:07

the upcoming reopening of Crane Clean

1:09:09

Energy uh all runs through u emergency

1:09:12

management which is uh led by the fire

1:09:15

chief and deputy chiefs. U we are

1:09:18

working very closely with Dolphin

1:09:20

County. They've hired a u they've hired

1:09:22

another uh person on staff to work with

1:09:25

that. And what we found and what Dolphin

1:09:28

County has found, what other counties

1:09:29

have found is it works better on a

1:09:31

regional level as opposed to singularity

1:09:34

uh as it comes to these large disaster

1:09:35

mitigation plans. So when we look at the

1:09:38

u the emergency evacuation plan for uh

1:09:41

Crane Clean Energy, that's going to

1:09:43

we're again we're already in discussions

1:09:45

uh working with nuclear regulatory

1:09:47

commission uh with the uh with the state

1:09:50

and uh trying to determine what that

1:09:52

looks like going forward. uh knowing

1:09:54

that the plan that we originally had uh

1:09:58

doesn't meet criteria. So, they're

1:09:59

looking now at science as opposed to

1:10:00

just blotting things on a map and uh and

1:10:03

that may change uh not may it will

1:10:05

change uh the way the city of Harrisburg

1:10:07

deals with uh you know any potential

1:10:10

emergency issues at uh Crane Clean

1:10:12

Energy uh when uh it comes back online

1:10:16

probably uh in 2027.

1:10:18

>> Yeah, thank you. Then I just want to see

1:10:20

if we can get something because this is

1:10:22

so huge and some of these things really

1:10:24

may not specifically

1:10:26

happen in the city so I I can see the

1:10:29

bigger map of the county itself. But

1:10:31

again, hoping that we can try to put

1:10:33

something um for the public. I I'm I'm

1:10:35

always been worried about this though.

1:10:37

Like seriously, like what if stuff

1:10:38

happened? I know we might get a break in

1:10:40

the in our phones and TVs, but is there

1:10:42

something that we can actually look at

1:10:44

as a city to just in case something

1:10:46

happens and we're prepared to do

1:10:48

whatever it is that we need to do? I'm

1:10:50

saying something condensed in layman

1:10:52

terms for our residents to understand.

1:10:54

>> Yeah. And that will come out. That is a

1:10:56

that is a requirement of the Nuclear

1:10:57

Regulatory Commission to the owner and

1:10:59

operator of the nuclear power plant. So

1:11:02

uh while we were while we were supported

1:11:05

uh and it is quite frankly an unfunded

1:11:07

mandate to the city uh from Crane Clean

1:11:10

Energy uh for the for the emergency

1:11:12

management stuff that we have to conduct

1:11:14

in addition to our normal what's really

1:11:16

covered here even though nuclear is in

1:11:18

here uh they're required uh by the

1:11:21

nuclear regulatory commission to have

1:11:22

all that stuff and to do that

1:11:24

pre-planning and to make those contacts

1:11:25

the like the eye dive pills you talk

1:11:27

about things like that are all required

1:11:29

and expenses of Crane Clean Energy uh at

1:11:32

the end of the day uh by law. So we'll

1:11:36

we are working closely with them.

1:11:37

Dolphin County is working closely with

1:11:38

them. We've already had two or three

1:11:40

meetings uh dealing with uh you know

1:11:42

potential evacuation sites. Just as an

1:11:44

example, um you know the plan uh the the

1:11:48

original plan for TMI, what is TMI? Uh

1:11:51

the evacuation point for uh the small

1:11:55

area of Harrisburg that was affected was

1:11:57

the Scotland School for Children in

1:11:58

Scotland, Pennsylvania, just off of

1:12:00

Interstate 81. That school is no longer

1:12:01

open and no longer a functioning

1:12:04

receiving facility for those being

1:12:06

evacuated from the um you know from the

1:12:09

affected the Temount EPZ. Uh so now

1:12:12

they're looking at other uh other areas

1:12:14

potentially um Shippensburg University.

1:12:17

So there there's a lot of moving parts.

1:12:18

Crane has a lot of work to do um prior

1:12:21

to turning that switch on and and

1:12:23

starting to uh uh

1:12:26

>> create energy again. Correct.

1:12:27

>> So, thank you, man. I I think u this is

1:12:30

a no-brainer for me. Um those are just

1:12:32

my my uh my input in it. I think um you

1:12:35

know, the public should really lay eyes

1:12:36

on this, especially in today's times.

1:12:39

Nothing is really too certain. Just

1:12:40

paying attention to, you know, any

1:12:42

potential things that can happen in our

1:12:44

area. So, um, I'll open the floor up to

1:12:48

my colleagues and I'll start to my

1:12:50

immediate left with your truth. I mean,

1:12:53

Mr. uh, Rodriguez.

1:12:58

>> Thank you, Chair Jones. Um, always a

1:13:00

pleasure to see you, Chief Enterline.

1:13:02

Um, I just wanted to go over the five

1:13:03

goals briefly of the mitigation plan

1:13:05

just for the residents watching that

1:13:07

might not even know what the mitigation

1:13:08

plan um, entitles. To mitigate the

1:13:11

effects of those hazards, the planning

1:13:12

team identified the following goals for

1:13:14

hazard mitig mitigation over the next

1:13:16

five years. Goal one, to protect life,

1:13:19

property, the environment, and the

1:13:20

critical infrastructure from natural and

1:13:22

humanmade hazards, preventing injury,

1:13:24

death, and damage. The second goal would

1:13:27

be to increase public awareness and

1:13:28

education on the impacts of natural

1:13:30

hazards, and promote activities to

1:13:32

mitigate these risks. Goal three,

1:13:34

protect and restore natural resources to

1:13:37

strengthen environmental resilience.

1:13:38

Number four, reduce the risk of natural

1:13:41

hazards for socially vulnerable

1:13:42

populations and underserved communities.

1:13:45

And of course, number five, to develop

1:13:47

and improve infrastructure to better

1:13:49

protect citizens and both public and

1:13:51

private properties from hazards. Um,

1:13:54

very good kind of breakdown of that. But

1:13:56

chief, when I was overlooking the plan,

1:13:58

there was one, of course, it's all

1:14:00

concerning when we're talking about

1:14:01

mitigating great risk hazards, but there

1:14:04

was one number that really stood out to

1:14:06

me that was a bit concerning. Um, so in

1:14:10

2010 to 2020, we actually had a 2%

1:14:13

increase in the population in

1:14:14

Harrisburg. So we're at about a 50,000

1:14:17

about 50,99 in population. But the

1:14:20

projections for 2030, we're actually at

1:14:23

a negative 7% decrease, losing over

1:14:25

3,000 residents. Why do you think that

1:14:28

they're projecting such a substantial

1:14:30

decrease?

1:14:31

>> So that came from that did not come from

1:14:34

us. Uh that came from uh statistics that

1:14:37

the uh architects of the plan look at.

1:14:40

So it was this was the plan really um

1:14:44

that minutiae in the plan if you will um

1:14:47

that we don't have the expertise to look

1:14:49

at is done by a consultant. So they look

1:14:51

at at uh trending uh statistics on

1:14:54

population trends and things like that.

1:14:57

That's how they come up with that. Um

1:14:58

you know look do we agree with that?

1:15:00

Probably not. Right. Um but what I what

1:15:03

I can say that to me that is minutiae in

1:15:06

the mix. I'm looking at um do do the

1:15:09

things that we identify that are a you

1:15:12

know as you outlined in those in those

1:15:14

five bullet points do they fit the plan

1:15:16

that that we're putting in there. So

1:15:18

when we identify a project does it fit

1:15:20

into the plan and is it going to be

1:15:22

money well spent? Is it going to be

1:15:24

something that's going to protect the

1:15:25

public and is it going to have uh

1:15:27

achievable outcomes? Absolutely. Uh, and

1:15:29

so I I think for us as emergency

1:15:30

managers, that's what we're looking at.

1:15:32

Not necessarily with all due respect,

1:15:34

the the population,

1:15:35

>> right? But as a legislator, being a

1:15:37

representative of the people, that's

1:15:38

what we're looking at. Sure. So when we

1:15:40

see residents fleeing at an all-time

1:15:42

high, council definitely would be

1:15:44

concerned. So it's just two different

1:15:45

perspectives coming from two different

1:15:47

sides of the table.

1:15:48

>> Yeah. And again, it's a, you know, it's

1:15:50

an outside consultant. Um, and quite

1:15:53

frankly, the the u you know, if I'm

1:15:55

being blunt, and you guys know I'm

1:15:56

pretty blunt, uh, the first consultant

1:15:58

we started working with was from down

1:16:00

south, and quite frankly, you know, it

1:16:04

is what it is. They they had really no

1:16:06

idea. They're looking at statistics,

1:16:09

right? They're number crunchers.

1:16:10

>> Uh, with all due respect,

1:16:12

>> Yep. No, I I totally understand. But if

1:16:14

it's something we're looking to, you

1:16:15

know, um, approve, it's definitely

1:16:17

concerning. And then it kind of makes me

1:16:19

think of what we can do better to keep

1:16:20

it, retain our residents, offer a bit

1:16:23

more, but it is just for mitigation um

1:16:25

of different hazards. Do you as the

1:16:27

chief uh of the fire department feel

1:16:29

like it is a very good plan to move

1:16:32

forward with something that they've

1:16:33

taken some great time and really

1:16:35

dissolved everything that could happen?

1:16:37

>> You know, I I think I look back on uh

1:16:38

and again it was a couple of years ago.

1:16:40

We look back on wintertorm Jonas um and

1:16:43

you know we exercised that plan pretty

1:16:45

extensively which was and you know I

1:16:47

look at this as the uh the the pen and

1:16:49

ink to the checkbook of the federal

1:16:51

government right uh so we followed

1:16:54

everything we needed to follow and we

1:16:56

documented everything we had to document

1:16:58

um volumes and volumes of paperwork uh

1:17:01

and you know the money we spent at that

1:17:03

time and we were we were signed a

1:17:05

contract for snow removal for $200

1:17:07

$300,000 at at a crack Um, and we to we,

1:17:11

you know, as we massaged that down, uh,

1:17:14

because of the diligence and because of

1:17:16

of following everything we had in the

1:17:18

plan, following the FEMA guidelines,

1:17:20

there was only about $400 of almost a

1:17:24

million dollars of expense that they

1:17:26

denied for us. Uh, and again, that's

1:17:28

that's being able to exercise and and

1:17:31

use the plan as designed uh, to fall

1:17:33

back on and not get outside of that

1:17:35

scope. Again, looking at those five

1:17:36

bullet points, as long as we're

1:17:37

following those, we're in good shape.

1:17:39

Now, um, just for my own edification

1:17:41

because I'm not even sure, uh, is there

1:17:44

a separate just Harrisburg mitigation

1:17:46

plan or are we incorporated with the

1:17:48

Dolphin County?

1:17:48

>> Correct. We're incorporated right with

1:17:50

Dolphin County. So, there's projects in

1:17:52

here again, there's Capital Regional

1:17:54

Water Projects, D channelization of of

1:17:56

Paxton Creek, but there's also um, you

1:17:59

know, some things in Derry Township,

1:18:00

right? it it is countywide. Uh which

1:18:02

gives us a a more regional approach to

1:18:05

emergency management which is you know

1:18:07

while every emergency goes to the local

1:18:09

level of government the smallest form of

1:18:11

government city or burrow like Steelton

1:18:13

uh when we look at it globally and

1:18:15

looking at it regionally uh it gives us

1:18:18

more uh more oomph behind it to to get

1:18:20

that assistance for the residents that

1:18:23

need it.

1:18:23

>> Gotcha. Thank you.

1:18:24

>> Whe whether that's pre incident or post

1:18:26

incident right awesome. Thank you. No

1:18:29

further questions.

1:18:29

>> Councilwoman Ross.

1:18:31

>> Thank you, Councilman Jones, and good

1:18:33

evening, Chief Interline. Thank you for

1:18:35

being here today to explain this

1:18:36

important plan. Um, I had one question.

1:18:40

It may go into two, but kind of the

1:18:42

same. Um, I was wondering being as

1:18:45

though um in Dolphin County, but also

1:18:48

Harrisburg, everyone does not speak the

1:18:49

same language, doesn't have the same

1:18:51

background. How is this plan is it

1:18:53

translated into different languages? How

1:18:56

do other members of our community um be

1:19:00

how do they translate this plan and be

1:19:02

able to understand it if English is not

1:19:03

their first language?

1:19:05

>> That's a good question and I am not 100%

1:19:08

sure because it is housed on Dolphin

1:19:10

County's website. I am not sure. I

1:19:12

believe that there was supposed to be a

1:19:13

Spanish version but I'm not 100% sure of

1:19:16

that.

1:19:16

>> Uh and I believe so it is a it is an

1:19:19

editable PDF. So, I believe through that

1:19:22

edit function, if you speak a different

1:19:24

language, you can go in and change and

1:19:26

it will convert. Um, it's probably going

1:19:28

to take some time because it's 800 and

1:19:30

some pages if you sat and read the whole

1:19:32

thing.

1:19:33

>> Correct. Would you be able to get that

1:19:35

answer and and maybe email us just in

1:19:37

case we get that question as well? Um,

1:19:40

because even Spanish isn't even just the

1:19:42

other languages in our community. Um,

1:19:45

there's there's so many. Um, so I'm just

1:19:47

wondering because sometimes we get those

1:19:49

type of questions and I would not know

1:19:51

how to answer that because I don't know

1:19:52

if there's a translation to it, but I

1:19:54

know it probably is important for it to

1:19:57

be. So

1:19:59

>> yeah, I I will reach out to Dolphin

1:20:00

County tomorrow and get an answer or

1:20:02

not. I believe it would be a simple

1:20:03

email and it could be converted.

1:20:05

>> Thank you. I appreciate that. Thank you

1:20:07

so much. That's all I have actually. It

1:20:09

went into one question.

1:20:11

>> Thank you, President Hill.

1:20:12

>> I don't have any questions. Thank you

1:20:14

for being here this evening. Many of my

1:20:16

questions were asked and answered.

1:20:18

>> Thank you,

1:20:18

>> Vice President Green.

1:20:20

>> I don't have any questions, but it's

1:20:21

good to see you as always. Thank you

1:20:23

>> as always. Thank you,

1:20:24

>> Councilwoman Davis.

1:20:26

>> Thank you, Councilman Jones. Good

1:20:28

evening, Chief Erline.

1:20:30

>> Good evening.

1:20:32

>> So, I don't have any questions. Um,

1:20:36

well, actually, I do have one question.

1:20:38

I read over the uh hazard mitigation

1:20:41

plan briefly and I understand that the

1:20:45

city wants to adopt the county's plan.

1:20:49

Um it says here that uh one of the

1:20:53

processes would be to assess or even one

1:20:57

out of four two out of four assess the

1:20:59

counties and each municipalities

1:21:02

vulnerabilities to these hazards. So,

1:21:05

natural hazards, tornadoes,

1:21:08

wildfires,

1:21:10

invasive species, utility interruptions,

1:21:14

winter storms, tornadoes, radon,

1:21:17

exposure, and there's uh some more

1:21:20

identified here. Um, and I was just

1:21:25

complimenting you and your deputy chief

1:21:27

on ensuring that the evacuation plan was

1:21:30

updated for one of our senior high-rise

1:21:34

uh buildings. Um, but I think it's

1:21:36

important that

1:21:38

if we as a community need to evacuate

1:21:43

for whatever reason,

1:21:45

each facility should at least know how

1:21:48

to get out in case of an emergency. So,

1:21:51

um, you guys have already been working

1:21:54

on that and that's just one of the

1:21:57

things that I'd like to see, you know,

1:22:01

follow through to make sure that the

1:22:03

residents know how to get out of the

1:22:05

building in case they do have to

1:22:07

evacuate because can you imagine

1:22:10

all of a sudden we our phones emergency

1:22:12

system starts going off and they're

1:22:15

telling everyone to go to a specific

1:22:18

point, but the residents in the

1:22:20

buildings don't know where to go and

1:22:22

everybody's scrambling around. We have

1:22:23

disabled members, people in wheelchairs

1:22:26

and so

1:22:28

>> yeah, my concern.

1:22:30

>> Yeah, very valid points. Um and

1:22:32

understanding this plan is for large

1:22:34

disasters. So, this isn't for a building

1:22:36

fire. This doesn't cover a building fire

1:22:38

or uh while it does cover building

1:22:41

collapse, right? It it doesn't it

1:22:44

doesn't cover those small incidents, if

1:22:46

you will. a a a kitchen fire on the

1:22:48

fifth floor of the Jackson building, the

1:22:51

Jackson Tower. Uh and and that falls to

1:22:54

the local that falls to what our

1:22:55

planning already is working with

1:22:57

Harrisburg Housing as we had talked. So,

1:22:59

this plan looks at the the bigger

1:23:01

picture, bigger when we're evacuating

1:23:04

communities, the entireties of

1:23:05

communities and that planning uh then

1:23:09

falling back to the plan, we start to

1:23:12

look at our uh different resources that

1:23:14

we have. So, we're looking at busing.

1:23:16

We're looking at uh you know, how do we

1:23:19

convert uh you know in in looking at 3M

1:23:24

Island, right? We take Cameron Street

1:23:26

and make it one way uh so there's no

1:23:28

coming into the city. It's only one way

1:23:30

out. Uh and things like that. So, that's

1:23:32

what this plan's looking at. big big

1:23:34

picture big uh incidents uh in a smaller

1:23:38

smaller scale. While it's not small to

1:23:40

the resident that that fire and other

1:23:42

emergencies in the building are dealt

1:23:44

with under the fire code and and uh you

1:23:46

know are or fire codes, if you will, as

1:23:50

opposed to the disaster mitigation plan.

1:23:53

>> Thank you, Chief Ederline. Um, I just

1:23:55

wanted to uh note that I still think

1:23:58

that it's very important even though it

1:24:00

doesn't fall under this um plan on a

1:24:04

large scale, it does on a small scale

1:24:07

and it's very important that that you

1:24:10

know be addressed as well. So you guys

1:24:13

are already on top. Agreed. Thank you so

1:24:15

much Chief Interline. Thank you for

1:24:17

being here.

1:24:22

Good.

1:24:25

Councilwoman Daniels,

1:24:27

>> no question.

1:24:29

>> All right. Thank you again, Chief

1:24:31

Innerline. You got any last last remarks

1:24:33

you want to

1:24:34

>> say?

1:24:35

>> That's it. I'm good.

1:24:36

>> That's it. So,

1:24:37

>> I got to go finish reading the plan.

1:24:38

It's 800 pages.

1:24:39

>> Yes, it is huge. Again, let me put that

1:24:41

back out there. I'm glad you said

1:24:42

>> there will be a test at the legislative

1:24:44

session uh when you go to vote on it. I

1:24:46

will have questions for you.

1:24:47

>> All right. Um, again for the uh

1:24:50

residents out there, you can look at

1:24:52

this plan and go check it out. It is

1:24:54

huge. Um, hazard

1:24:57

hyphen mitigation

1:25:00

plan.pdf.

1:25:03

And I would I would move to add uh

1:25:06

resolution 65 to our next legisl

1:25:09

legislative session for a vote. I know

1:25:13

it's a lot of stuff.

1:25:15

All right. All right.

1:25:17

>> And that con No, that doesn't conclude.

1:25:21

>> Oh, I'm still done. I'm waiting for her.

1:25:23

I keep doing that. Um, so, uh, Mr.

1:25:25

Trudeell, can you read resolution 66 and

1:25:28

67 into the record?

1:25:31

>> Resolution 66, 2025, a resolution

1:25:34

confirming the appointment of Robert

1:25:36

Jennings III to serve on the Citizens

1:25:39

Law Enforcement Advisory Committee. and

1:25:41

resolution 672025,

1:25:44

a resolution confirming the appointment

1:25:45

of Dominique Commodore to serve on the

1:25:48

Citizens Law Enforcement Advisory

1:25:50

Committee.

1:25:51

>> Thank you. I do see Mr. Commodore and

1:25:53

Mr. Jennings III in the building. If you

1:25:55

guys can come up,

1:26:00

uh Mr. Jennings, you could you can sit

1:26:01

there. Mr. Trudell is going to help you

1:26:03

out with a microphone. You can come on

1:26:04

up.

1:26:11

make sure you speak directly into the

1:26:13

mic so everyone at home can hear you

1:26:16

>> and uh

1:26:19

>> you know I want to thank both of you

1:26:20

gentlemen um again for willing your

1:26:23

willingness to serve on this committee

1:26:25

um as you know it's a very important

1:26:27

committee um a great opportunity for our

1:26:30

city um to kind of you know bridge the

1:26:33

gap between uh community and police um

1:26:36

and bring forth some new ideas and

1:26:37

direction. So, uh, just tell us a little

1:26:41

bit about why you want to serve and you

1:26:43

both can answer. Um, it doesn't go into

1:26:45

I'll go with Mr. Commodore first.

1:26:48

>> Good evening everyone. My name is

1:26:49

Dominique Commodore and one of the main

1:26:52

reasons why I wanted to serve on this

1:26:54

committee is that um, I work um, in

1:26:56

Harrisburg school district as an

1:26:58

assistant principal dealing with the

1:26:59

ninth grade and I just see the influx

1:27:02

and of crime in the city. Um I do

1:27:04

believe my position um being from

1:27:05

Harrisburg and alumni of the district

1:27:07

and just in the community in different

1:27:09

capacities whether from coach and

1:27:11

wrestling um it would be a good um point

1:27:13

to be like a bridge where I can bring

1:27:16

new ideas. Um we see a lot of you know

1:27:18

different things throughout the day

1:27:19

whether it be from the students um

1:27:21

bringing different crimes or just other

1:27:22

situations that happen throughout the

1:27:24

day. It's a good opportunity for me to

1:27:25

just, hey, I have eyes right there on

1:27:28

the ground telling you what I'm seeing.

1:27:29

Also bring, you know, new viewpoints.

1:27:31

Um, you know, share what maybe some of

1:27:33

the students or even the parents are um

1:27:35

expressing just different concerns and

1:27:37

even what, you know, my neighbors might

1:27:38

be sharing just throughout the streets

1:27:39

of Harrisburg. Um, I also think that,

1:27:41

like I said, as me being from here, um,

1:27:43

from uptown, I do think it is a good

1:27:45

opportunity to be a bridge bidder and a

1:27:47

piece in the community to connect the

1:27:48

dots.

1:27:50

>> Thank you. Uh, Mr. Jennings.

1:27:53

>> Yes. I uh one of the main reasons I

1:27:55

wanted to serve on the advisory board is

1:27:58

because I live here and I see what's

1:28:00

going on. Uh many of you know the jobs

1:28:03

that I did in the past. Um I don't think

1:28:08

the police are our enemy. Uh I think

1:28:10

they make mistakes and those who do need

1:28:13

to be corrected, but they're human too.

1:28:17

And I think we have to like Mr. common.

1:28:20

So, we have to bridge that gap and we

1:28:23

have to I understand it's some it's some

1:28:25

nasty police officers, don't get me

1:28:27

wrong, and I think they should be dealt

1:28:30

with. No doubt about it. I think the

1:28:32

advisory board should make a

1:28:34

recommendations and do whatever they got

1:28:36

to do. But we got to have peace in our

1:28:38

streets. Our streets are out of hand.

1:28:40

And one of the ways that you can

1:28:42

sometime you need somebody in the

1:28:43

middle, you know, sometimes I don't know

1:28:46

how you guys came up, but I came up with

1:28:48

three parents. And sometime I didn't

1:28:50

like what my mom and dad said, but then

1:28:53

my grandmama would sit me down and take

1:28:55

her time and break it down to me. That

1:28:57

makes it a whole lot better, a whole lot

1:28:59

more understandable. So, I think that's

1:29:01

the I think that's the way with the

1:29:03

police advisory board. You need somebody

1:29:05

that that can sit down and relate to

1:29:07

people. Um, I was a constable, for those

1:29:11

of you who don't know me up there, I was

1:29:12

a constable for 17 years. I was district

1:29:14

judge for 12 years. I coached

1:29:17

football for 22 years. I've been in and

1:29:20

out of John Harris talking to those kids

1:29:22

when I was on the bench and most of them

1:29:24

need just a little love. But you got to

1:29:26

show them another side. They don't see

1:29:29

that. Some of them only see the rough

1:29:30

side. So I think if we all work together

1:29:33

on this board, I think it'll be a

1:29:35

beautiful thing. Harrisburg might even

1:29:36

be a a city that other people want to

1:29:41

come and see how we did it because we

1:29:43

can do it. This ain't Philly. This ain't

1:29:45

Baltimore,

1:29:47

you know. We We can do this here,

1:29:49

>> right? All right. Can I Can I get an

1:29:52

amen?

1:29:54

>> All right. Now, don't don't have me

1:29:55

preaching up here now cuz I don't mind I

1:29:58

bringing a word.

1:30:00

No, but seriously,

1:30:03

seriously, it's a needed effort. It

1:30:05

really is.

1:30:06

>> I thank you. I thank you, man. Again, I

1:30:09

want to thank all of the um Cleak

1:30:11

members that came out and um put their

1:30:13

hat in this ring. Um again, just what

1:30:16

how I see it from a a public safety

1:30:18

standpoint is that um in 2025 or any

1:30:22

other year, the police shouldn't be

1:30:24

policing our communities. I think that's

1:30:26

a US thing. And this is where I think

1:30:28

this can really kick off to to uh Mr.

1:30:31

Jennings's point. um we do have a great

1:30:34

opportunity to do something and be

1:30:36

actually a trailblazer in this regard um

1:30:39

and hopefully uh be a model for other

1:30:41

peoples to come look at. So I don't have

1:30:43

any questions. I'm very impressed with

1:30:44

you guys and I'm I'm sat sat with you

1:30:46

through a lot of this process. Uh so

1:30:49

I'll open the floor up and I'll start

1:30:51

with President Hill this time.

1:30:53

>> Oh, I get to start. Thank you. Um so I

1:30:56

just wanted to provide an overview of

1:30:58

the cle board and share the general

1:31:00

function. Uh so the Citizens Law

1:31:03

Enforcement Advisory Committee or CLEAC

1:31:05

as we've been referring to it was

1:31:07

established to promote public

1:31:09

accountability and community trust in

1:31:12

Harrisburg's law enforcement. CLEAC

1:31:14

functions as an advisory body of

1:31:17

residents providing oversight, policy

1:31:19

recommendations, and a forum for

1:31:22

dialogue between the public and the

1:31:24

Harrisburg Bureau of Police. It is

1:31:27

designed to improve transparency,

1:31:29

protect community rights, and foster

1:31:32

stronger

1:31:33

uh police community relations.

1:31:36

In reference to general function,

1:31:39

uh reviews law enforcement policies,

1:31:42

practices, and data to improve

1:31:45

transparency and public accessibility.

1:31:48

Provides residents a forum to voice

1:31:50

concerns about police interactions and

1:31:53

community safety issues. Identify

1:31:56

systematic or recurring problems and

1:31:59

help recommend changes in local law

1:32:02

enforcement practices. Promotes fair,

1:32:05

just and dignified treatment of all

1:32:09

persons in Harrisburg, fosters trust and

1:32:12

positive relationships between law

1:32:14

enforcement and community members.

1:32:16

Encourages open communication and

1:32:19

dialogue between residents, businesses,

1:32:21

and law enforcement. and facilitates

1:32:24

public participation in shaping law

1:32:26

enforcement approaches and community

1:32:28

crime prevention. Um, I don't really

1:32:32

have any questions. I was at the CLEAC

1:32:35

meeting when both of you were

1:32:37

interviewed, so I got to hear um some of

1:32:40

the dialogue between the current members

1:32:42

and both of you as prospective members.

1:32:45

Um,

1:32:47

>> yeah, I don't I don't have any

1:32:48

questions. Thank you for your interest

1:32:50

in serving.

1:32:52

All right, Vice President Green.

1:32:56

>> Thank you, Councilman Jones.

1:32:58

Thank you, um,

1:33:00

Judge Jennings, for being here. Uh, I

1:33:02

appreciate you continuing to be willing

1:33:04

to serve the residents of Harrisburg in

1:33:06

every capacity. I don't really have any

1:33:08

questions for you. Um, I know the work

1:33:09

that you've done. I know your

1:33:10

background. I think you'd be a great fit

1:33:12

to the board, kind of offering a

1:33:13

different perspective, uh, and giving

1:33:15

that whole approach. So, I appreciate

1:33:16

it. Um, Mr. Commander, I appreciate you

1:33:19

being here tonight and for your

1:33:20

willingness to serve. I think being able

1:33:22

to bring an approach um that represents

1:33:25

education perspective um and kind of

1:33:26

seeing some of those struggles that our

1:33:28

youth uh face in the schools and also in

1:33:30

the communities I think that's a very

1:33:32

important perspective uh because a lot

1:33:34

of the violence that we're dealing with

1:33:35

um in our streets also has to do with

1:33:37

our youth and unfortunately as much as

1:33:39

we talk about them and all the programs

1:33:41

that are needed it's a voice that al

1:33:43

often gets unheard and a lot of these

1:33:45

important meetings so I appreciate you

1:33:47

being willing to represent them and take

1:33:49

a stand for that. So, thank you.

1:33:51

>> Thank you.

1:33:52

>> Thank you, uh, Vice President Green,

1:33:55

Councilwoman Davis.

1:33:57

>> Thank you, Councilman Jones, and thank

1:33:58

you, Judge Jennings, and Mr. Commodore,

1:34:01

for being here this evening and for uh

1:34:04

being willing to serve our youth in the

1:34:07

city. I think that this is much needed

1:34:11

and I'm happy to hear when President

1:34:15

Hill was reading all of the uh the

1:34:18

requirements and would go on.

1:34:21

Um, yes, our children just need a little

1:34:24

love. And I think that the outlet that

1:34:28

they can have to express their feelings

1:34:31

and their thoughts and ideas or whatever

1:34:33

is going on in their head, it's

1:34:34

important that they have an outlet to be

1:34:37

able to do that. Um, otherwise their

1:34:40

outlets are sometimes violence and

1:34:45

council with different things that Okay.

1:34:48

speaking to your mic.

1:34:50

>> I think this is a good initiative, so

1:34:53

I'm behind it 100%.

1:34:56

Thank you.

1:34:57

>> Thank you. And I also want to note too

1:34:58

that um the commissioner um Carter and

1:35:01

Deputy Chief Young also attended these

1:35:03

meetings and I think they got off to a

1:35:05

really good start. Um it wasn't

1:35:07

contentious. Um I think this is

1:35:09

something again huge for our community.

1:35:11

So, I also wanted to thank uh

1:35:13

Commissioner Carter and Deputy Chief

1:35:15

Young for showing up and um their

1:35:17

willingness to work with this committee.

1:35:19

Um I'll move right along to Councilwoman

1:35:22

Ross.

1:35:26

>> Okay. Sorry. Um there me being

1:35:29

controlling. Sorry. So, um thank you

1:35:33

both um to Mr. J Jennings and Mr.

1:35:35

Commodore for coming. Um, I know you

1:35:37

both very well and you are leaders in

1:35:40

our community and I think having you on

1:35:44

this board with the other leaders in our

1:35:46

community that are on there now shows

1:35:48

people that it's okay to be friends with

1:35:51

the police officers. It's okay to have a

1:35:53

conversation. Um, and I think that's

1:35:56

what we have to see cuz for you, for us

1:35:59

in our community, you all are cool,

1:36:01

right? You're the cool guys. You're the

1:36:03

people that people are looking up to. So

1:36:06

to see you interacting with them and

1:36:08

saying, "Yes, I am on this board and all

1:36:10

cops are not bad and yes, things happen,

1:36:13

but this is how we can deal with them."

1:36:15

It shows a line of respect. And so um I

1:36:19

just thank you for being willing to

1:36:20

serve on this board, being as though um

1:36:22

you already do so much for the

1:36:24

community, but being on here, it it

1:36:26

brings it up another level and shows

1:36:28

people something different. Um so I

1:36:30

don't have any questions. I just really

1:36:32

wanted to give you your flowers and also

1:36:34

make a comment and to say thank you.

1:36:36

>> Thank you.

1:36:37

>> Thank you, Councilwoman Ross. And last

1:36:39

but not least, coming in at 5 foot.

1:36:41

>> Oh my gosh.

1:36:44

>> Council Councilman Rodriguez.

1:36:46

>> Ah, thank you, Chair Jones. I'm six foot

1:36:48

though, by the way.

1:36:51

>> Uh, Principal Commodore, your honor. It

1:36:54

is a pleasure um to be in your presence.

1:36:58

Really good friends with Mr. Dominic um

1:37:00

for a long time. Actually, I can attest

1:37:03

to the great work he's done in the

1:37:04

community because he's done an amazing

1:37:05

job with my oldest son um taking him

1:37:08

from an antisocial young man in junior

1:37:10

high to now flourishing as an

1:37:12

all-American athlete and now at Cheney

1:37:15

University on a full ride. And I'd be

1:37:17

lying if I didn't say Mr. Commodore

1:37:19

didn't have a part, a huge part in that,

1:37:22

him achieving and becoming a man. So,

1:37:24

thank you for that. Um absolutely. And

1:37:26

Judge Jennings, I've been in front of

1:37:28

you a few times back in the day now.

1:37:31

But it's just amazing that we continue

1:37:33

to, you know, cultivate a culture of

1:37:36

just great individuals. Um there's a

1:37:38

great council body here that knows who's

1:37:40

doing the work. So it's amazing to be

1:37:42

able to reach out to those individuals

1:37:43

and, you know, get you guys to play a

1:37:45

role. So I'm honored. I'm privileged and

1:37:47

I can't wait to see what the Cleak has

1:37:49

in store for the future. So Coach Dom,

1:37:51

as I always tell you, love you. Thank

1:37:52

you and your honor. I look forward to

1:37:54

working. But there is one question. I

1:37:56

think Mr. Ciders may be able to ask. I'd

1:37:58

love to see your honor sitting on a deis

1:38:00

with the rest of the team. So, how can

1:38:02

we make this space more ADA compliant so

1:38:05

Judge Jennings can join us? How can we

1:38:07

make that possible?

1:38:08

>> Well, let let me say this. I can walk. I

1:38:11

just can't walk far.

1:38:12

>> Still like to accommodate. Still would

1:38:14

like to accommodate if possible.

1:38:16

>> I got you, sir.

1:38:17

>> Okay. All right. All right. But still,

1:38:19

just out of respect, I think it's

1:38:20

important for us to even ask the notion

1:38:22

to accommodate.

1:38:24

>> Thank you. Go ahead.

1:38:25

>> We It's my understanding that there'll

1:38:28

be so with the appointment of these two

1:38:31

gentlemen, there'll be a total of nine

1:38:33

people. Is that correct? So, seven

1:38:35

districts and then two alternates

1:38:39

>> or

1:38:40

general at large members. Okay. Thank

1:38:43

you. So, I think the meeting location

1:38:46

will not be the council chambers. So, I

1:38:49

I believe the room will be accessible

1:38:52

for everyone.

1:38:53

>> Perfect. Thank you. Thank you, President

1:38:55

uh Hill and Council and Councilman

1:38:58

Rodriguez. And I also before I go back

1:39:00

to Councilwoman Ross, I also want to

1:39:02

give acknowledge that uh Councilman

1:39:04

Rodriguez when he was in this committee,

1:39:06

he was actually the one to go out and

1:39:08

select the first five members of this uh

1:39:11

uh potential committee of this

1:39:13

committee. Um you know, and and those pe

1:39:16

those individuals really hung on for

1:39:18

about

1:39:19

>> three four years before we got this

1:39:21

started. and um picking up the last leg.

1:39:24

Um so I want to thank you for the for

1:39:26

the work that you put in um to to to

1:39:28

help get this uh board started. I mean

1:39:30

committee started and um I'm glad that

1:39:32

we're at this space right now. Uh

1:39:34

Councilwoman Ross

1:39:35

>> Green. Vice President Green.

1:39:37

>> Oh,

1:39:38

>> Vice President Green. No, it was me. I'm

1:39:40

just saying Vice President Green started

1:39:42

>> started to work and I went ahead and got

1:39:44

him.

1:39:44

>> I apologize. Hold on. Let me let them

1:39:46

talk. Yeah.

1:39:48

U no and it's just a quick question and

1:39:50

um I don't know it might be more for

1:39:53

legal I feel like um sometimes uh

1:39:56

committees come in front of us we make

1:39:58

motions people get on boards and this

1:40:00

not against anybody it's just a question

1:40:02

but the communication then goes away and

1:40:04

we don't always hear like what's

1:40:06

happening or um what's going on that's

1:40:08

new but I know um with um cleak you all

1:40:11

have a meeting so they have that

1:40:13

communication piece but like HHA or um

1:40:17

the audit committee, things like that.

1:40:18

Like are the committees allows anything

1:40:21

and I didn't I couldn't find anything.

1:40:23

Is there anything in a rule that I'm

1:40:24

missing that they can't come and

1:40:26

communicate with us and say, "Hey, this

1:40:28

is what's happening on our committee."

1:40:32

>> I don't think so. I think they just have

1:40:34

to be asked.

1:40:35

>> Okay. All right. I'm just wondering

1:40:37

because I feel like it always get after

1:40:38

we vote on something gets lost, it goes

1:40:40

away. It's like fairy dust. But just

1:40:42

that that transparent communication. So,

1:40:44

I was just wondering.

1:40:45

>> Yeah. You can have them as, you know,

1:40:47

how you usually have communications

1:40:51

>> quarterly. You can have them have

1:40:53

reports month. You know, you can ask for

1:40:55

pretty much how you want them to come in

1:40:57

and communicate with you.

1:40:59

>> There are formal reports and advice that

1:41:02

uh CLEAC as well as some of the other

1:41:05

boards that you mentioned provide.

1:41:07

Specifically, CLEACK U. They are to

1:41:09

share an annual report submitted to the

1:41:12

mayor and city council summarizing

1:41:14

CLAK's activities, findings, and

1:41:16

recommendations.

1:41:18

Policy and practice recommendations

1:41:20

issued to the Harrisburg Bureau of

1:41:22

Police, Mayor, and City Council on

1:41:25

policing practices, community concerns,

1:41:27

and legislative or administrative

1:41:29

reforms. Investigatory findings. Cleak

1:41:33

may issue reports on law enforcement

1:41:35

practices supported by its ability to

1:41:38

request records and in some cases issue

1:41:41

administrative subpoenas during

1:41:43

misconduct investigations. Finally,

1:41:46

community engagement reports provides

1:41:49

updates to the public on crime

1:41:50

prevention activities, neighborhood

1:41:52

participation, and police community

1:41:55

partnership initiatives.

1:41:58

>> Thank you.

1:41:59

>> Thank you.

1:41:59

>> Yeah. And and um the last question

1:42:02

actually I forgot um just for residents

1:42:04

when's the next meeting? That's it.

1:42:09

>> Third Wednesday of the month. It's third

1:42:11

Wednesday of every month. No, he would

1:42:13

know.

1:42:14

>> Third Wednesday of every month at

1:42:16

>> 5:30.

1:42:17

>> Uh what time do we start? 5 6:30.

1:42:19

>> 6 5 I think it's 5:30 at 6 o'clock. And

1:42:23

and it's welcome for community. We

1:42:24

anyone they will be building out

1:42:27

subcommittees as well. So, this we we're

1:42:29

looking to make sure that this gets a

1:42:31

lot bigger. So, we just want people to

1:42:34

come down, listen to what's going on,

1:42:36

and see where they can fit in. Um,

1:42:38

under, you know,

1:42:41

uh um

1:42:43

>> Okay.

1:42:43

>> Yeah. I think this the public um this is

1:42:45

something open for them to come in and

1:42:47

learn as well and and hopefully be an

1:42:50

extension to this uh committee as a

1:42:52

whole. the cleak the meeting agendas are

1:42:56

on the city's website so that you will

1:42:58

know the new location since it won't be

1:43:01

the council chambers you can access them

1:43:04

there

1:43:08

>> I thank I thank my colleagues for you

1:43:10

know keeping me on point as well you

1:43:12

know um thank you for uh making sure

1:43:15

that the public has accurate information

1:43:17

and again I would u move to have

1:43:20

resolution uh 66 and 67 move to our next

1:43:24

legislative session for a vote. Thank

1:43:27

you again, gentlemen.

1:43:31

>> Thank you. We will move forward with our

1:43:34

meeting agenda. Next, we have public

1:43:36

comment. Just a few housekeeping notes

1:43:38

before we begin. Um, if you'd like to

1:43:41

offer public comment, please state your

1:43:43

name and your address for the meeting

1:43:44

record. If you don't feel comfortable

1:43:46

sharing your address, please share the

1:43:48

vicinity in which you live within the

1:43:50

city. You will have four minutes to

1:43:52

share your comments. Mr. Trudale has

1:43:54

added a timer to the screen for your

1:43:57

reference and I'll begin to my right. Is

1:43:59

there anyone that would like to offer

1:44:01

public comment?

1:44:03

>> I would.

1:44:04

>> Okay.

1:44:06

>> I'd like to It's a problem festering

1:44:08

that's that's going to get out of hand

1:44:10

or something bad is going to happen. And

1:44:12

this handicap parking, the handicap

1:44:15

parking, I have one. My daughter has

1:44:18

one. It's a sticker that goes on the

1:44:21

back of your mirror of your car. And

1:44:24

from what I understand, I could be

1:44:26

wrong, correct me. From what I

1:44:27

understand, nobody's supposed to park in

1:44:30

that spot. Anybody can park at the

1:44:32

grocery store. Anybody can can park at

1:44:35

the health and welfare. Any, you

1:44:38

understand? Anybody but in front of your

1:44:40

door. That's why they give you a

1:44:42

sticker. And people are just park in

1:44:44

there. They have handicap that they

1:44:47

found or stole a barrel. you borrow. You

1:44:50

can tell there's nothing wrong with them

1:44:51

by the way they walk. But what they're

1:44:53

doing is they're parking in there and

1:44:55

then the people that are in bad shape

1:44:57

like my daughter who had a knee

1:44:59

replacement, she couldn't get in there.

1:45:01

So that means she somebody have to pick

1:45:03

her up. It it's it's a mess, you know,

1:45:06

and it it needs to be addressed. It

1:45:10

needs to be addressed. Either it is or

1:45:12

it isn't. Well, if if if that's not the

1:45:14

case, then why do we have them stickers?

1:45:16

When you get your handicap here at the

1:45:18

city, you get a sticker for the back of

1:45:20

your mayor with a number on it, and it's

1:45:23

supposed the number is supposed to match

1:45:25

you. Even though I got a handicap

1:45:27

sticker, I can't park in your I can't

1:45:29

even park in hers. I shouldn't at the

1:45:32

house.

1:45:34

>> Many people are eager to respond to your

1:45:36

comments and answer your questions. I'll

1:45:39

defer.

1:45:40

Who would like to respond first? Yeah.

1:45:42

Um just just um so and I'm glad you

1:45:45

asked this on so everybody's watching.

1:45:47

We have legal hair as well so they can

1:45:50

understand. Um even though you may go

1:45:52

down and get a um

1:45:54

>> handicap sign for your for for you to

1:45:57

utilize and for you to utilize. It's

1:45:59

still public parking. If someone has a

1:46:02

sticker, they allowed to park on there.

1:46:04

And I get a lot of these phone calls so

1:46:06

people can understand that. Um nobody

1:46:08

owns the we don't own the streets. um

1:46:11

you know the parking we can't control it

1:46:13

but I I think I don't know it's just

1:46:15

looking at this I mean parking is an

1:46:17

issue everywhere but specifically for

1:46:20

>> the handicap parking um long as someone

1:46:22

has a placard for that they're able to

1:46:25

park there and I'll let legal go from

1:46:27

there.

1:46:28

>> Yeah I I I think that has to be

1:46:29

researched uh councilman uh I I don't

1:46:33

believe that's true

1:46:34

>> that is accurate. Any handicapped person

1:46:36

can park in a handicap space. I

1:46:39

understand there's several different but

1:46:41

why do we get the sticker miss with the

1:46:43

number on it? There's

1:46:44

>> I mean it's it's a waste of money.

1:46:45

>> That's your number is just to identify

1:46:48

you to the city of Harrisburg and what

1:46:50

your placard is. Um there's several

1:46:52

different categories that people can be

1:46:54

categorized in. So we should remember

1:46:57

that not all handicaps are visible. So

1:47:00

there may be many reasons why people

1:47:02

have a placard. But yes, you do not own

1:47:05

the space. anyone handicapped can

1:47:08

utilize the handicap spaces.

1:47:10

>> I'm I'm going to research that because

1:47:13

it's supposed to be not the number on

1:47:14

your mirror that they give you for your

1:47:16

mirror that you're talking about. It's

1:47:18

supposed to be on the sign as well.

1:47:22

>> I will, Mr. Jennings, I will answer to

1:47:24

because I just was trying to help a

1:47:26

resident with this a couple months ago

1:47:28

and that is exactly how it did used to

1:47:30

be. Your number had to match you and you

1:47:32

were supposed to be able to park there.

1:47:34

However, when I called down to Pin Dot,

1:47:36

when I talked to the police department,

1:47:38

they said it changed somewhere and it's

1:47:41

no longer like that and whoever has a

1:47:42

handicap sticker can park and handicap.

1:47:45

Now, can the law be changed? Of course,

1:47:47

it's a fight, but they did change it and

1:47:50

I can understand your frustration with

1:47:52

it. I do.

1:47:53

>> Mr. Rolls, let me ask you a question. Is

1:47:55

that something the city council can

1:47:56

change or is the state legislature have

1:47:58

to do?

1:47:59

>> They said it was state legislator. I

1:48:00

asked I did. I researched like you too

1:48:02

cuz I was irritated with the answer.

1:48:04

>> Okay.

1:48:05

>> So, yes, I apologize for that and I'm

1:48:07

sorry for the frustration it caused.

1:48:09

>> You know, it is what it is. It's it's

1:48:12

>> but it is state legislation and if if

1:48:14

you need help to fight, I can help you

1:48:16

fight, but I can't change it without

1:48:18

help. And and you know, we need people

1:48:21

to rally behind us. That's how we change

1:48:22

laws. So, if it's a way that I can help

1:48:25

in the community, we can all get behind

1:48:26

and do that. That's how we change Well,

1:48:28

we might need to get a hold of state rep

1:48:29

state senator and tell them our problem.

1:48:31

>> I I think we should we need to start

1:48:33

writing them some letters.

1:48:34

>> You are in the 103rd. So Nate Davidson

1:48:37

will be your state representative.

1:48:38

>> Right. Right.

1:48:40

>> And Patty Kim's a state senator, right?

1:48:42

>> Yes, that's correct.

1:48:46

>> Are there any other

1:48:49

>> Thank you. Thank you.

1:48:50

>> Thank you. Okay. Thank you very much.

1:48:52

>> Oh, you're welcome. Is there anyone else

1:48:54

to my right that would like to offer

1:48:56

public comment?

1:48:58

Okay, seeing hearing no one. Anyone in

1:49:00

the middle section? Okay.

1:49:04

>> Oh, I'm sorry. If you wouldn't mind

1:49:06

coming to the microphone.

1:49:09

Thank you. It's still there.

1:49:20

>> If you could please state your name and

1:49:22

your address. If you don't feel

1:49:23

comfortable sharing your address, please

1:49:25

share the vicinity in which you live.

1:49:26

Thank you.

1:49:27

>> My name is Joyce Munz and I live on

1:49:30

Fourth Street, Uptown Harrisburg. Um, I

1:49:34

live near a playground. Everybody knows

1:49:36

Fourth and Emerald. Just might as well

1:49:39

say that. I live between Emerald and

1:49:41

Woodbine. It's a throwway with the

1:49:44

four-wheelers, um, the double parking,

1:49:50

the drug deals. I've been stopped at

1:49:53

before I can get to my home. Um, drug

1:49:56

transactions right in front of me and

1:49:58

you know I'm kind of bold be you know

1:50:01

get out of my way which I was told don't

1:50:03

do that but you know you're handing off

1:50:06

drugs right in front of me. I can't get

1:50:08

home. Um I have reported it. I have said

1:50:12

something and I was told we know about

1:50:15

it.

1:50:17

Um, I had a neighbor who just passed

1:50:19

away a couple weeks ago um near Emerald

1:50:24

Street.

1:50:26

There's a drug house and I said

1:50:30

there's a drug house. The transaction

1:50:32

was happening right there while the

1:50:34

police fired engines and everything. We

1:50:38

know about it. The man couldn't get they

1:50:41

couldn't get the man out of his house

1:50:42

for it. Sorry. He was a good neighbor,

1:50:47

but he died there and they're stepping

1:50:49

over him.

1:50:52

But we know about it. What do you do?

1:50:55

I've lived in my neighborhood for years.

1:50:57

I love my neighborhood. I love my people

1:51:00

there.

1:51:02

There's children. The four-wheelers are

1:51:04

going so crazy there. The kids I'm so

1:51:07

afraid children are going to get hit. We

1:51:10

need the speed bumps. those terrible

1:51:12

speed bumps I hate so much that I have

1:51:14

to slow down. I don't speed anyway, but

1:51:17

they need to be there at the playground

1:51:20

to keep the kids from getting hit.

1:51:23

What do we do?

1:51:26

I just watch out for the kids. I love

1:51:28

the kids.

1:51:30

What do we do? We need help. And I keep

1:51:32

saying every time I see a police

1:51:34

officer, I need help, you know. And I

1:51:38

have nothing against the police officer.

1:51:40

I had I lost a son and it was an officer

1:51:43

that came to my house and delivered the

1:51:45

message.

1:51:47

He was a good officer

1:51:49

and his offer to me was, "Can I pray for

1:51:52

you?" That was the best thing he could

1:51:54

have ever done.

1:51:56

And yes, he did do that for me.

1:52:00

So, I have nothing against the police

1:52:02

officer. But what do we do when we want

1:52:04

to keep our neighborhood? We want to

1:52:06

watch out for our kids, but yet this is

1:52:08

happening on both sides of me. I've been

1:52:11

everywhere. What do we do?

1:52:15

>> Do you mind, you raised some public

1:52:17

safety concerns. Do you mind waiting

1:52:19

after the meeting to speak to uh

1:52:21

Councilman Jones?

1:52:22

>> Sure.

1:52:23

>> Thank you.

1:52:23

>> And one other thing, I've been this in

1:52:26

this town all my life. I was an orphan

1:52:29

here. My mother raised 70 foster kids.

1:52:32

my mom and dad. They had seven kids of

1:52:35

their own. I've seen all kinds of

1:52:38

children. I help raise them. So, it's

1:52:40

nothing. This isn't new to me. So, I've

1:52:44

always been around kids all my life. I

1:52:46

love them. So, I just want to keep them

1:52:49

safe. So,

1:52:52

>> thank you.

1:52:54

Is there anyone else in the middle

1:52:55

section that would like to offer public

1:52:57

comment?

1:53:01

Good evening, council.

1:53:05

Um,

1:53:07

heard you guys thank everyone for the

1:53:09

ability and um to serve. I want to thank

1:53:14

you guys, you too, for um showing up.

1:53:19

Now, one of the things that I observed

1:53:22

was, you know, the HHA.

1:53:24

I'm not from Harrisburg,

1:53:26

but I had the pleasure of living in five

1:53:28

out of the seven continents. So, my

1:53:31

perspective sometimes is not from the

1:53:34

inside. It's more global perspective.

1:53:37

And I've had the u opportunity of taking

1:53:39

the Elsa at least a couple of times and

1:53:41

that time clock makes me nervous.

1:53:46

Nevertheless, I beat the clock because I

1:53:48

show up. I look at it and I still voice

1:53:52

my opinion. And I would say to the

1:53:53

community, anything you have like these

1:53:56

ladies and gentlemen that show up, bring

1:53:59

it and let someone know that you are

1:54:01

beating whatever it is that is uh facing

1:54:05

you. As far as HHA, I think ending

1:54:09

longevity is important. uh generation of

1:54:13

individuals relying on public help

1:54:17

is a curse, right? And we need to break

1:54:20

that curse by any means necessary.

1:54:22

Malcolm X. Now um

1:54:26

I heard words of man man-made disaster

1:54:30

and milligating

1:54:34

you know

1:54:37

these uh things that we often come

1:54:41

across whether it's flooding and fire

1:54:43

and such.

1:54:46

Now the federal government have all

1:54:48

these plans already there. All people

1:54:50

are doing is copy and pasting and

1:54:52

they're coming to you with, you know, we

1:54:54

need this money, we need this. The truth

1:54:56

is whether you're speaking legal ease or

1:55:00

you're speaking finance or in my case

1:55:04

business,

1:55:05

we understand everything is business,

1:55:08

politics, spiritual, economical,

1:55:10

everything is business. And the fact

1:55:13

that they sometimes think that you're

1:55:15

not

1:55:17

smart enough to tell

1:55:20

when a person is using one word, whether

1:55:22

they're saying the white man or another

1:55:24

word, Caucasian,

1:55:27

that you're not able to tell the

1:55:28

difference because you don't speak legal

1:55:31

ease or you don't have a CPA

1:55:36

is insulting.

1:55:38

And I want you to know that I can tell

1:55:40

that you understand all the languages

1:55:43

that are being spoke in front of you.

1:55:45

The one thing that I don't think you

1:55:47

clearly understand is the deception and

1:55:50

whether those deception filter from

1:55:54

Reed Popping Fools whoever

1:55:57

if they're still advising council.

1:56:03

Someone said to me the other day that um

1:56:05

a monkey will be a monkey and a gorilla

1:56:08

will be a gorilla. Just keep a clear eye

1:56:12

of who is saying what to you when you

1:56:17

are trying to move this city forward.

1:56:19

And I can only give you, like I say, a

1:56:21

global perspective from the outside

1:56:24

looking in.

1:56:26

You are on the right track. Defunding

1:56:28

the police is definitely what the people

1:56:31

wants and need. We know that we are in

1:56:35

charge. We know that we're the boss. But

1:56:37

like every great leader who advise us

1:56:42

is the ones that are pulling the string.

1:56:46

So now uh the puppeteers and the

1:56:48

puppets, you know, we know who they are.

1:56:52

Some is in this room, some is in the

1:56:54

administration,

1:56:57

but um I want to thank you guys like you

1:57:01

say for showing up and for serving.

1:57:05

Thank you. Good night.

1:57:07

>> Did you state your name and your You

1:57:10

didn't I know your name, but if you

1:57:11

could please state your name and your

1:57:13

address or the vicinity in which you

1:57:15

live for the meeting record, we would

1:57:17

appreciate it.

1:57:18

>> Thank you. My name is Libby Profit.

1:57:21

Profit from the experience and I live at

1:57:25

2025

1:57:26

Chestnut Street in Harrisburg. Thank

1:57:29

you.

1:57:30

>> Thank you.

1:57:32

Is there anyone else in the middle

1:57:34

section that would like to offer public

1:57:35

comment? Seeing and hearing no one,

1:57:37

anyone to my left? Seeing and hearing no

1:57:40

one, the time is 7:31 p.m. I will

1:57:44

entertain a motion to adjurnn.

1:57:46

>> So moved.

1:57:47

>> Is there a second?

1:57:48

>> Second.

1:57:49

>> Thank you. We stand.

More transcripts

Explore other videos transcribed with YouTLDR.

Get the TLDR of any YouTube video

Transcribe, summarize, and repurpose videos in 125+ languages — free, no signup required.

Try YouTLDR Free