Full Transcript

·YouTLDR

Harrisburg City Council - Legislative Session November 26th 2024

2:55:1425,838 words · ~129 min readEnglishTranscribed Jun 15, 2026
0:00

you

0:30

.

0:37

.

0:40

.

0:46

legislative caucus and then we will call our legislative session to order

0:52

following.

0:55

Okay, so I'll call the meeting to order. Mr. Trude's Dale will lead our role

1:01

call this evening. I will deliver the invocation. The pleasure of allegiance will be

1:06

led by Councilwoman Davis. For communications this evening we are joined by

1:11

Mayor Williams who will share a presentation of the 2025 budget proposal. We will

1:19

then open the floor for courtesy of the floor followed by the approval of

1:22

minutes for the legislative session that occurred on November 12th, 2024.

1:28

Then you will hear reports of committees. I will deliver the first report on

1:35

behalf of the administration committee on the work session of November 19th,

1:39

2024. Next you will hear from our community and economic development committee

1:47

chair, Councilwoman Daniels on the work session of November 19th, 2024. Then you

1:54

will hear from our public safety committee chair, Councilman Jones on the work

1:59

session of November 19th, 2024. In the final committee report you will hear

2:05

this evening will be delivered by our public works committee chair, Councilman

2:10

Rodriguez on the work session of November 19th, 2024.

2:16

Ordinances for first reading. We have three bill seven of 2024 will move to the

2:25

budget and finance committee. Bill eight of 2024 will move to the budget and finance

2:31

committee. Bill nine of 2024 will move to the budget and finance committee. We have

2:42

one ordinance for amendment. If there are any bill six of 2024, one ordinance for final

2:50

passage that's bill six of 2024 which we will vote upon. Resolutions resolution 72 of 2024.

3:01

We will vote upon resolution 73 of 2024. We will vote upon resolution 74 of 2024. We will

3:11

vote upon resolution 75 of 2024. We will suspend the rules for discussion. I believe there

3:20

is one amendment that will be offered. And then we will vote upon the resolution as amended.

3:28

Resolution 76 of 2024. We will vote upon resolution 77 of 2024. We will suspend the

3:39

rules for discussion. Then vote upon. Resolution 78 of 2024 will move to the administration

3:48

committee. Resolution 79 of 2024 will move to the public safety committee. Resolution 80 of 2024.

3:58

It's my understanding solicitor Grover. We need to suspend the rules for discussion and

4:04

vote upon this evening. Is that correct? Thank you. Resolution 81 of 2024 will move to the

4:12

community and economic development committee. Resolution 82 of 2024 will move to the community

4:20

and economic development committee. Resolution 83 of 2024 will move to the budget and finance

4:27

committee. Resolution 84 of 2024. We also need to suspend the rules for discussion and vote

4:35

upon. And resolution 85 of 2024. We will suspend the rules and vote upon. Is there any old business

4:45

for discussion council members? Seeing and hearing none any new business? Okay. Seeing and hearing

4:55

none. Then we will adjourn. So the time is now 6.18 pm. I will call our legislative session

5:08

to order. Mr. Trusel, could you please call the role?

5:15

Ms. Daniels. Ms. Davis. Ms. Green. Ms. Jones. Ms. Rose. Ms. Rodriguez. Ms. Bowers.

5:30

President, thank you. I will lead our invocation this evening. I would like to take a few minutes

5:39

to honor the life and legacy of Mr. Jim Thompson, Harrisburg school board director. Jim has served

5:47

his community well. Jim is no stranger to Harrisburg City Council in 2017. Jim served as the Harrisburg

5:56

school district appointee to the Lurda appeals board. Last year, Mr. Thompson was appointed to serve as

6:03

a member of the building and housing code board of appeals of the city of Harrisburg given his

6:09

background as an architect. He offered over 40 years of professional experience managing and designing

6:17

a broad range of projects including schools, low cost housing and community centers.

6:25

Selected projects included the Boys and Girls Club of Harrisburg, John and Hall Clubhouse

6:32

Edition, the Hamilton Health Center, New Head Start and Child Daycare Center, Icare Clinic,

6:39

Campus Planning and Parking Expansion, the Pennsylvania Counseling Services, Shemel Building renovations,

6:47

and the Harrisburg Housing Authority Office renovations. Jim or the Wise Owl as he referred to

6:54

himself was currently serving as a Harrisburg school board director. He previously served as the

7:00

board president. He took a keen interest in the success of the students within the Harrisburg

7:06

school district. He advocated for apprenticeship and mentoring opportunities for students.

7:12

He and his wife, Jane, could often be seen in attendance at Kougar Football Games cheering the

7:17

team on to victory. Jim will be greatly missed. In the same manner as the Harrisburg school board this

7:26

evening, please join me in a moment of silence remembering the life and legacy of Mr. Jim Thompson.

7:40

Thank you. The Pledge of Allegiance will be led by Councilwoman Davis.

7:46

Let's all stand please.

8:08

Thank you, Councilwoman Davis. For communications this evening, we are joined by Mayor

8:15

Wanda R.D. Williams who will share a presentation of the 2025 budget proposal. Mayor Williams.

8:24

Thank you, Councilwoman. Good evening, President Bowers. Vice President Greene and members of Harrisburg City Council.

8:32

As in previous years during my administration, my staff and I would like to thank you again for giving us

8:37

an opportunity to present a preliminary review of our 2020 City of Harrisburg General Fund budget.

8:45

We continue to move forward in the right direction and to focus on a safer and brighter future for

8:52

the City of Harrisburg. As you already know, there has always room for more growth and much

8:59

of that will be accomplished with this current forward thinking administration. I would like to take

9:05

this moment to express my appreciation for the input and support we continue to receive from City

9:12

Controller Charlie Day Bruner, our county manager Brian McCutchen, our budget manager Timothy Brooks,

9:21

and the assistance they have received from their co-workers and colleagues within the finance department.

9:28

This year the administration was presented with numerous challenges.

9:33

Early in the year, we lost our previous business administrator and finance director.

9:38

However, our entire finance team stepped up to the plate to meet these challenges and has

9:45

insured the smooth operations of the finance department. The administration started working on

9:52

the budget in the early spring of this year. The guidance, input, and timeline management initially

9:59

received from the former business administrator, finance director greatly assisted us in being able to

10:06

finalize this proposed budget document and present a balanced budget to you and on time.

10:15

Recently, we hired business administrator Sam Sikowski who brings a wealth of share information

10:21

along with his knowledge of finance experience. We are ready for your review of the budget and looking

10:29

forward to answer any questions you may present. In the meantime, my staff will continue to take

10:36

an in-depth look at the proposed budget to ensure it is completed for City Council and the City of

10:44

Harrisburg residents by December 31. I am happy to showcase some positive areas of this budget,

10:52

which will help support our confidence in moving the city forward. Of course, there are some

10:59

areas of concern that will also be shared. First, the good news is we have a balanced budget.

11:11

There will be no tax increases, no layoffs, and no cuts in any service to the citizens of Harrisburg.

11:20

Our revenues exceed expenditures and there is no need to use the cash fund balance.

11:27

Most of our employees are happy to be employed by the City of Harrisburg and strive to do their best.

11:34

The mayor's office still has and always will have an open door policy. My administration sponsors

11:43

and employee luncheon event every summer and in the fall and winter serve a holiday lunch.

11:50

This year's holiday lunch will take place on Thursday, December 12. We appreciate our staff and we

11:57

would continue to invest in our employees. It is and always will be my top priority to make sure

12:04

the City of Harrisburg is a wonderful place to live and to enjoy festivities, such as the July

12:11

Music Series, Halloween Bash at the Brownstone, the Christmas Tree Lighting event, the holiday parade,

12:19

winter wonderland, and the upcoming New Year's Eve celebration in the Atrium of City Hall.

12:26

Our Public Works Department has been working diligently to keep the city clean and to maintain a

12:32

well-lit up city. The Department has fulfilled its responsibilities and has partnered with other

12:39

departments to assist in getting the needed work done. Public Works also has been working closely

12:47

with the Coates Enforcement Department assisting with the demolition of blighted properties,

12:52

which has saved the city a great deal of money. Continuing to handle large-scale paving projects

13:00

which has been cost-saving because we do not always have to use outside contractors to perform all

13:06

of the work and duties of the paving task. Public Works has continued to fulfill the revenue contracts

13:13

for trash pickup, instillment, tax tank, and pembroke burrows. Our Parks and Recreation Department

13:22

has continued to plan events for the public, which includes children as well as adults.

13:29

We have submitted a revised plan to the State Department of Economic Development requesting to improve

13:35

our public parts. Unfortunately, we had to replace an interim director to replace our former

13:43

director of economic development and building and housing. We did not miss a beat because we were

13:50

able to quickly identify an interim director. I am happy to say that Gloria Martin Roberts has

13:57

making things happen and the Home Repairist Program has been implemented and moving forward successfully.

14:05

Our affordable housing projects are coming to fruition and I'm sure you have seen the new structures

14:10

throughout the city. Next on the agenda for the Economic Development and Building and Housing Office

14:16

will be to address the needs of our Senior Citizen Center, the Hines-Manager Senior Center,

14:23

which is the only Senior Center in the City of Harrisburg. Yes, public safety continues to be a

14:31

major concern for the City of Harrisburg but the Harrisburg Police Department continues to do

14:37

an outstanding job along with county, state, and federal agencies with the reduction

14:44

and suppression of crime within the surrounding areas. The Group Violence Initiative grant

14:51

is now being managed by a project coordinator who has been working closely with gun violence

14:57

victims throughout the City of Harrisburg. Very shortly we have in many labor management meetings

15:05

to address the upcoming police and absentee contracts. But in the meantime as always we will continue

15:12

to protect and serve our community. Since the law bureau bought in a lean specialist in May of 2023,

15:21

the focus has been on accounts with significant past due balances and owing trans bills.

15:28

In that time the city has issued required legal notices and pursued collections again both residential

15:36

and commercial accounts. Managing the unhoused population has been a human services and financial

15:44

challenge for the City of Harrisburg. We had to relocate this population due to road

15:51

and infestation and other issues. We have been participating in meetings with representatives from

15:57

other entities such as Doffin County commissioners, Doffin County Health and Human Services,

16:03

Governor Shapiro's office, downtown Delhi-Bred, Christian Churches United and others.

16:10

The governor's representative has asked us to prepare a report outlining the cost expenditures

16:16

incurred by the City of Harrisburg. President Bowers and council members, please be assured

16:23

as in previous years this budget is physically sound and responsible. Again there are no tax increases

16:32

and this administration continues to invest in the people of Harrisburg. And this was all done without

16:39

three major positions filled in the year 2024. I am looking forward to working through this budget

16:47

process and a joint effort to finalize the 2025 budget. Thank you all.

16:56

Thank you Mayor Williams. We will now move to courtesy of the floor just a few housekeeping notes

17:02

before we begin. If you could please state your name and your address for the meeting record if you

17:07

don't feel comfortable sharing your address please share the vicinity in which you live within the city.

17:13

You will have four minutes to share your comments. Mr. Trude's Dale will serve as our time keeper.

17:20

I will begin to my right. Is there anyone that would like to offer public comment?

17:26

Please come to the microphone.

17:37

My name is Benjamin Hall. I live in Midtown Harrisburg, New York, Calcars Street.

17:44

And will we be presented to the public comment now or at another point?

17:50

You may share your comments now. Okay. So for anyone not familiar with the situation,

17:58

I'd like to present comments about resolution 75 which has to do with the

18:06

10103 South Front Street. As it pertains to the capital area Greenville which is the bike path that

18:16

runs for around 19 miles around the city of Harrisburg, as it stands the buyers of the property,

18:23

Tunnel says Hours has not made any concessions to the general public for how to proceed with an

18:34

alternative route for the Greenbelt. As the Greenbelt runs through with the property and has for

18:41

several decades. So the capital area Greenbelt Association which is a volunteer association

18:54

associated with helping keep the Greenbelt up to par or maintain or expand it

19:01

has said publicly that they don't want to pursue this original route and they want to try to

19:07

pursue a different route at the estimated costs of about $3 million. And it's my opinion that

19:16

changing strategies here is not a wise decision for the association or for and it won't provide,

19:28

it won't, it probably won't be a good solution because the estimated costs are $3 million

19:40

for not pursuing that according to their statement. And if they simply made concessions for

19:56

moving the route a little bit which would cost them a much lower amount then it would save everyone

20:07

a lot of time and time money and you wouldn't have to go through the corridor which is temporary

20:16

right now which goes over the bridge next to the pinned up building and on Cameron Street. So

20:23

that concludes my comment on that matter. Thank you. Thank you.

20:37

Okay. Hi, my name is Brandon Basem. I'm from Uptown, North Third Street. I'm here for two reasons.

20:44

One I was happy to hear that the city and their budget is going to be looking at hopefully getting

20:48

some outside help with the cost of the relocation of the original homeless encampment whether or not

20:52

all of us agree that it was inevitable. However, we do have the issue that we have a current homeless

20:57

encampment and we know that it's going to get swept this next year because of PennDOT. We've known that

21:02

for years. We still haven't seen a tangible plan for what's going to be done and if we keep allowing

21:07

the timeline to get pushed back to when it happens the administration is again I'm going to act like

21:12

they were taken by surprise. We've had no choice if they had to sweep them and send them with nowhere to

21:16

go and we could be preparing with the county with whoever might help with state agencies to get them housing

21:22

to get them relocated to do something besides just having the police or you know PennDOT come in

21:29

and remove them so it'd be great to see some action on that. And then secondly just to speak to

21:36

what Penn did quickly. I agree with what he says. I think we have two issues here. The Greenbelt is not only

21:43

great for recreation for biking. It's a path for people from a parts of Harrisburg like up on the hill

21:47

to get down to needed services without having to be in the streets. Without a car we know that's

21:52

incredibly dangerous. We also know that in past years we fail to do things like the safety

21:57

improvements on the state street or really anywhere else. So now to take away one of the few paths

22:02

between the city really does keep it segregated like during the bad days of white flight when they put

22:08

you know highway thirsty to separate us. My thing is you know the old Greenbelt would be great if

22:13

you can get concession that's preferable. I would also love to see this development not be you know

22:18

approved until there's some concession to allow path behind even fenced off but if there are

22:22

going to be improvements I want to see something solid because we were told state street would happen

22:27

as soon as it was cancelled they're going to get right back on it but we can't keep the city

22:30

engineer. Three years and three million dollars rounding people up on the cabaret street over a bridge

22:35

is entirely too dangerous and again at a certain point I failure to fix a problem that you know

22:41

is dangerous you're no longer you're negligent. It's not an accident anymore you will have those

22:46

people to get hurt so I would like to see something faster on the rear out or possibly keeping the old path

22:54

and again a plan for what to do with the homeless that are going to get swept when they expand

22:57

83 that we knew is coming would be fantastic thank you. Thank you.

23:13

Good evening members of city council my name is Sheila Galford I'm here tonight in my capacity as

23:19

the policy and program liaison for the Heinz senior center I'm speaking about resolution 77

23:27

Mr. Borg the executive director had a prior engagement and asked me to attend in his behalf I am

23:33

joined by Mr. Borg strain who is the Heinz Center Board chair a long time volunteer and who will also

23:41

provide remarks this evening we are here to speak in support of resolution 77 and it's important

23:48

to the ability of the Heinz Center to provide ongoing programs and community outreach to the city of

23:56

Harrisburg the Heinz Center is the only state designated senior center in Harrisburg founded in 1972

24:05

by John Heinz and Min Medaker who served as a president of city council its designation as a state

24:12

certified local senior center carries with this certain expectations but little funding

24:19

indeed the level of funding provided to senior centers has not increased since the year 2000

24:26

although needs and services to be provided have increased immeasurably the local community the city

24:34

the county and the state rely upon Heinz for some of the following meals on wheels in some communities

24:42

meals on wheels is underwritten by churches or supported by volunteers in Harrisburg uptown

24:48

Harrisburg in particular meals on wheels is provided by Heinz today Mr. strain volunteered to

24:56

accompany a paid staffer to develop to deliver about 55 to 60 meals to seniors let's do the math using

25:05

55 Heinz does this five days a week 52 weeks a year 55 times five is 275 we take that 275 and multiply that

25:19

by 52 that comes to 14,300 meals that are delivered each year to the residents of Harrisburg

25:29

Heinz has done this for 20 years that comes out to about 286,000 meals that's a big number right

25:38

in Hershey they have resources trying to write these costs in Harrisburg we do not

25:46

Heinz employs local people who are loyal and deserving we want to continue their practice and we can

25:54

with your help 14,300 visits per year is an extraordinary number in reign and sleep in snow we

26:04

deliver now let's look at those points of contact expressions of caring and concern by Heinz

26:11

and let's look at that data and look at what we do in house we see and or speak to about 30

26:18

persons per day five days a week we provide lunch five days a week and there is over there sometimes

26:25

members of our unhoused communities stop in for a meal anyone who stops in is given a meal some of

26:31

you have stopped in on occasion we've offered you a meal or a program 30 persons per day times five equals

26:39

150 150 times 52 equals 7,800 points of relationship of concern of caring your family our friends

26:52

your constituents our loved ones those in need add 7,800 to 14,300 your total is 22,100 the moment of

27:05

connections with our community members that are initiated by Heinz annually that's a big number I

27:13

submit this is why we advocate for resources sufficient to help I have to thank you I have more

27:24

and I'd be happy to answer any questions thank you thank you

27:34

good evening my name is board strain it used to be a long time resident of Harrisburg and

27:43

from a large Braxton family and also the string of family I currently live in outside Harrisburg but

27:52

much much to the consternation of my mother who's what love the place and so do I but I'm here on behalf of

28:01

the Heinz Center where I've been affiliated with the last 15 years starting primarily as a meals on

28:09

wheels deliver of between the river and seven street and north street up to the city line in Harrisburg

28:20

and the numbers are very you know people new people are added people die it's a senior citizen so

28:29

there's a continual flow and as I said I grew up in Harrisburg my aunt was Harriet Brachkin who was

28:37

a long time former member of city council I'm a retired engineer structural engineer work for 48

28:46

years with the the distinguished firm of Majesque Masters who built many bridges in Harrisburg and

28:54

Philadelphia the Ben Franklin Walt Whitman about 13 bridges over the Mississippi River and so on and I

29:01

had an enjoyable career there and you know I grew up with the idea of civic rent you you have to

29:08

somewhere as a citizen pay back and I guess Heinz and a few other activities on the board of WITF

29:17

school board and subsequent township on the board of the Tripway Central Pennsylvania and continuing

29:24

now in retirement with my main activity in pain civic rent is the Heinz Medical Center and we do need

29:33

your help we were hurt severely by COVID but we stayed open with staff that wasn't paid provide

29:44

on several occasions a platform for COVID vaccination and food distribution we to keep we keep

29:56

to the mission and center of the vision the the chart upon which was established Alex Reiber of Miller

30:06

Dixon and Drake is our accountant and he provides strong oversight of our finances we help and support

30:15

many seniors through various activities as was previously mentioned by Sheila I hope you will give

30:22

consideration and positive affirmation to resolution 77 Heinz serves a broad range of needs within

30:29

Harrisburg and it has demonstrated the necessity for its existence again and again we need resources

30:37

we invite all of you to visit and participate I forget the gentleman's name at the end of the he

30:46

was just up there last week councilman Jones yeah and we appreciate that so we invite all council

30:56

members to come up see what we do see what look at our facility one of the things that being an engineer

31:02

I'm particularly proud of is we have a facility that if a city inspector came in we meet standards on

31:10

cleanliness the roof is perfect the air condition is perfect we spend money to maintain that building

31:18

because we want a proud you want a nice building in Harrisburg there are so many facilities here

31:24

they're dilapidated not well kept but when you come to the Heinz you're going to see a well kept

31:31

building thank you very much thank you is there anyone else to my right that would like to offer public

31:39

comment seeing the hearing no one anyone in the middle section

31:58

I am John Higgy I live in Hampton Township but I'm here on behalf of the Board of Veterans Outreach

32:02

of Pennsylvania which is at 11.05 south front street and we just wanted to express our support for

32:08

the resolution 75 and approving the ton of the towers project that affordable housing will provide

32:15

a place for our graduates to use the you know return for the folks that complete our program

32:21

to have stable housing and not return to homelessness once they've come in and gone through our therapeutic

32:26

model we appreciate the support that we've gotten in the work that we've done with the green belts

32:33

or supported the work with the tunnels towers is done with the Green Belt Association to find a

32:37

workable solution to not have that run through the private property any longer which just really

32:44

does not commensurate with how it's a sober facility it's a small community it just really doesn't

32:51

allow for people walking through it all day and biking through it all day every day so we do appreciate

32:56

the work that they've done and again we wanted to speak in support of the Tonos the Towers Project

33:01

at 11.03 south front street thank you is there anyone else in the middle section that would like to

33:08

offer public comment

33:11

good evening my name is Ken Stambaugh I live at 1696 Britannia Court in Harrisburg I'm currently serving

33:27

as a doff in county commander of the American Legion I represent 14 posts I'm joined by the district

33:34

commander John are also our other John John is the manager of the veterans affairs homeless shelter

33:48

up on second street and commander Steve Holmes out of Pennbrook commands that post I'm here to support

33:56

resolution 75 Harrisburg has a long history of welcoming home our veterans I was born and raised

34:05

here in the city I was born here because my mother was stationed here in World War II it goes all the way

34:12

back Harrisburg's history with our welcoming home our veterans goes all the way back to the Civil War

34:19

with the homeland center not just camp curtain being the basic training site for so much during the

34:26

union war but after the war we welcomed home our veterans Harrisburg is a military city we're surrounded

34:34

by military bases and all of us that serve in the American Legion serve for our veterans and to welcome

34:41

them home this has been a tough war it's been a tough tough 20 years on our young people this facility

34:49

we have to thank everybody that's doing it this growth we appreciate the land Tom Zimmerman my

34:57

buddy that started veterans outreach a PA these are some great people that can turn you that

35:02

tradition of welcoming home veterans to Harrisburg I ask you to continue that by approving 75

35:11

with without the way the green I want to thank the green belt too further the way they're working

35:17

with tunnel the towers to modify the route as appropriate thank you thank you is there anyone

35:26

else in the middle section that would like to offer public comment yes

35:41

I'm Doug Hill and I'm the president of the capillary green belt association with the 709 green street

35:48

here in the city and I'm here actually double dipping tonight I'm here in support of resolution

36:00

resolution on behalf of the towers has been represented we have been working with

36:06

tunnel towers and property owners and others on finding an appropriate accommodation for relocating

36:13

the green belt trail the reroute that we we have under review we discussed with you at the work

36:20

session we're still completing our feasibility study that but we do think it's going to be a workable

36:27

routes going to be safe routes going to be attractive and environmentally sound the other reason I'm

36:33

here tonight is later on your agenda you have a resolution in support of a grand application

36:39

department from the academic development and that is our first salvo at major funding for the relocation

36:47

effort and we will appreciate your favorable consideration for that as well as these two agenda items

36:53

come before you if there are questions you have for me I'd be happy to answer them thank you

36:57

thank you is there anyone else in the middle section that would like to offer public comment

37:05

seeing and hearing no one anyone to my left

37:10

okay seeing and hearing no one we will move forward with our meeting agenda next we have the

37:17

approval of minutes for the legislative session that occurred on November 12th 2024 council members

37:24

are there any revisions to those minutes hey seeing and hearing none the minutes stand approved

37:33

next we have reports of committees I will deliver the first report on behalf of the administration

37:39

committee on the work session of November 19th 2024

37:44

on Tuesday November 19th 2024 the administration committee met to discuss two resolutions resolution 72

38:00

of 2024 which is a resolution confirming the appointment of mr. Jonathan L. Love Jr. S. Guire to serve

38:10

as an assistant city solicitor for the city of Harrisburg and resolution 76 of 2024 which is a

38:19

resolution authorizing the city of Harrisburg to negotiate and enter into a memorandum of

38:25

understanding with the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania relating to certain waterway enhancements to better

38:32

serve the health and safety needs of those of voters mr. Love was present to answer any questions

38:41

council members had he began by introducing himself he received his JD from Drexel University law

38:48

school in Philadelphia he served as a public defender for three years in the city of Philadelphia

38:54

and he also has experience as the sole proprietor of his own practice council members asked the following

39:01

questions what impact do you hope to make any conflicts of interest what drew you here hardest challenges

39:09

how are you liking it so far mr. Love hopes to make hopes to impact the city of Harrisburg by

39:15

changing the structures of law mr. Love has no known conflicts of interest mr. Love was drawn here by

39:22

Love but his mother also works for the Philadelphia city council so he's hopeful to have some

39:32

commonalities and good discussion there there is he says there's no lack of work he enjoys legal

39:40

research and learning new areas of the law finally mr. Love was encouraged to be still and stay

39:46

and give us a chance in reference to resolution 76 chief interline was present on behalf of the

39:55

bureau of fire I'm sharing that the bureau was approached by pendat to

40:07

to place permanent buoys for the safety of voters as we mentioned in the caption

40:15

we reviewed the stakeholders that were all participating in this effort it seems like it is a group effort council

40:24

members asked the following questions what do the buoys do how do they protect residents how are

40:35

you planning on maintaining these buoys navigational charts or sensors how much does it cost

40:44

so some of the responses received where these are removable buoys that are marked up and downstream

40:54

both sides of the river they're 3.2 feet historically low significant rise in buoys washing away

41:02

so the permanency is preferred larger three-feet in diameter one inch chain people could grab onto them

41:14

so there is an anchoring point if someone should need assistance there's a 50 year warranty so there's

41:23

of course a long history of installing these buoys in reference to the question about navigational

41:30

charts or sensors the answer was no in reference to the question related to the cost

41:38

and if there was ongoing maintenance needed a pendat will maintain them for six years so they will

41:46

install and maintain them for six years what if something happens chief interline was pretty confident

41:56

working with the state geologists that the permanent buoys will be secure and will be able to assist

42:05

should someone need assistance I would recommend support of both resolution 72 of 2024 which will

42:15

further enhance our law bureau and offer our solicitor more assistance so welcome and resolution 76

42:25

of 2024 proves to be a great public safety measure so this concludes the report of the administration

42:34

committee the next report you will hear will be delivered by our community and economic development

42:42

committee chair councilwoman Daniels on the work session of November 19th 2024

42:56

2024 the community and economic development committee met the resolution 75 type of 2024 which is

43:03

the preliminary final land development plan for 11 or 3 south french street the applicants were

43:10

tunnel to towers foundation and the plan is to build a property with 64 units on two floors above

43:19

a communal area along with 20 detached comfort homes all of the homes will be affordable to the tenants

43:30

and tenants will be obligated to contribute 30% of their income to those units in addition to the

43:37

applicants presenting we heard from the green belt association and their plans for rerouting the

43:46

green belt however the green belt doesn't have a property interest in the lots that have been that we

43:54

are discussing today and I guess sorry I should discuss the conditions the the planning commission

44:07

when it came to this property had established four conditions redesigning pedestrian access landscape

44:16

screening around parking areas coordinating with the arborist on the city arborist entry retention

44:23

and screening and there was a fourth one the project should accommodate a relocated capital area

44:29

green belt connection along the property southern boundary connecting the railroad bridge to the emergency

44:35

access road based on our conversations we are I am recommending that we remove

44:44

condition number four since we do not have a real legal basis to make that request as the city

44:54

has not does not own the property and the the project itself is completely retained within

45:01

that surrounding property so the bill is introduced today on the agenda has the includes that the

45:08

recommendation that that fourth provision be removed and that's pretty much it you know council members

45:19

had several questions around the green belt project but as I mentioned the green belt doesn't have a

45:25

property interest in in that lot and there doesn't seem to be an interest in securing that lost

45:37

through lawful means so so I would recommend that we go ahead and approve the ordinance the resolution

45:46

with the included amendment would include a change I would like to ask the applicants of their

45:52

presence that they consider taking efforts to remade the land from its previous use and that concludes my

45:59

report for that session thank you the next report you will hear will be shared on behalf of the

46:08

public safety committee our chair councilman Jones on the work session of November 19th 2024 thank you

46:18

president bowards um mr. truce del can you read uh no this is my session on November 19th 2024 the

46:32

public safety committee was held where we discussed bill six of 2024 summary of this session was an

46:39

ordinance amending title three of the codified ordinances of the city of Harrisburg known as public

46:47

safety code at part three general offenses by adding their to section three seventy five entitled

46:55

unlawful manufacturing of firearms to prohibit the use of three-dimensional printers for manufacturing

47:04

of firearms the transfer use or conversion of unfinished firearms and certain equipment

47:14

and prescribing penalties for violations thereof present to discuss was Brandon flood formerly of cease

47:22

fire where we discussed the needs of cities like ours to be proactive in this regard we would also

47:28

like for this ordinance to have more teeth he also stated that this is an opportunity to educate

47:34

the public in our school district as we have a new superintendent that wants to educate around

47:41

done violence and how to implement more safety measures this also helps with the current gbi

47:48

we now have in place in our building upon also york and redding have also acted on this ordinance

47:55

he also referenced on the federal level on october the afe the supreme court had an oral argument

48:02

garland versus vandorck stop where this would also allow us to move forward in this direction some of

48:11

the questions that were answered i mean acts by my colleagues will we be able to amend in areas of

48:17

this ordinance when needed the answer was yes council also acts about the enforcement and mr. flood

48:24

and myself share that we do have the support of our d a does this ordinance cover the devices such as

48:31

switches no um no it does not cover the part that is called a switch how i mean who are the

48:40

prohibited persons anyone who are the prohibited prohibited persons that this will affect and these

48:46

are the people that do not have the proper proper licency to manufacture in or carry or sale and that

48:55

ends my report of the public safety regarding bill six of 2024 and i ask my colleagues to support

49:03

bill six of 2024 thank you thank you the final committee report you will hear will hear

49:10

this evening will be delivered by our public works committee chair councilman rodry yes on the work

49:16

session of november 19th 2024 thank you madam president on november 19th of 2024 the Harrisburg

49:25

city council public works committee met to discuss two resolutions the first was resolution

49:29

73 of 2024 a resolution authorizing the city of Harrisburg to negotiate and enter into a professional

49:36

service contract with christ Dawson architect to provide architectural services for renovation of

49:41

the restaurant facilities at the public works building located at 1820 paxing street the resolution

49:47

was geared towards restoring and making the restaurants and public works building ADA compliant joining us

49:53

was direct the west from the public works department mr. west stated the public comes into use these

49:58

facilities and ensuring they are safe and up to date is mandatory there were no questions from council

50:03

pertaining to resolution 73 of 2024 also discussed was resolution 74 of 2024 a resolution approving the

50:11

disposal of certain personal properties owned by the city of Harrisburg which have exhausted its useful

50:17

life for city operations the resolution was geared towards consolidating and liquid dating are

50:21

outdated and unused equipment in the city of Harrisburg the vast majority of this would be outdated

50:27

vehicle parts and vehicles that have outlived their purpose joining us once again was direct the west

50:32

from the public works department mr. west stated these items can be sold to repurpose those funds in

50:37

much needed areas in the department there were no questions from council pertaining the resolution

50:42

73 of 2024 highly encourage my colleagues to support both resolutions and that concludes the

50:48

report from the public works committee from the work session of november 19th of 2024 thank you

50:53

madam president thank you very much we will now move forward with our meeting agenda we have ordinances

51:00

for first reading the first is bill 7 of 2024 mr. true sale could you please read it into the record

51:08

bill 7 2024 in ordinance establishing the budget for the municipal government of the city of Harrisburg

51:14

for the year 2025 thank you next we have bill 8 of 2024 mr. true sale could you please read it into

51:23

the record bill 8 2024 in ordinance amending decodified ordinances of the city of Harrisburg title 5

51:30

licensing and taxation part 5 real estate taxes chapter 5 501 property tax by establishing for the year

51:39

2025 a tax levy on land and improvements and providing for the distribution of taxes levied

51:45

and assessed and providing for a tax rebate for the difference between the tax due and attributable

51:50

to the year 2025 tax levy over the tax due and attributable to the year 2006 tax levy for qualifying

51:59

senior citizens thank you bill 9 of 2024 can you please read it into the record bill 9 to the

52:08

2024 in ordinance amending chapter 5 503 tax abatement and exemptions of title 5 licensing and taxation

52:16

code to extend the statutory termination date by one year to December 31st 2025 thank you

52:25

we have one ordinance for amendment that's bill 6 of 2024 mr. true sale could you please read it

52:32

into the record bill 6 2024 in ordinance amending title 3 of decodified ordinances of the city of

52:39

Harrisburg known as the public safety code at part 3 general offenses by adding their two section

52:46

375 entitled unlawful manufacturer of firearms to prohibit the use of three-dimensional printers for

52:52

the manufacturer of firearms the transfer use or conversion of unfinished firearms and certain equipment

52:58

and prescribing penalties for the violation thereof thank you we have one ordinance for final

53:06

passage that's bill 6 of 2024 mr. true sale could you please read it one more time

53:11

bill 6 2024 in ordinance amending title 3 of decodified ordinances of the city of Harrisburg known

53:19

as the public safety code at part 3 general offenses by adding their two section 375 entitled unlawful

53:26

manufacturer of firearms to prohibit the use of three-dimensional printers for the manufacturer of

53:31

firearms the transfer use or conversion of unfinished firearms and certain equipment and prescribing penalties

53:37

for the violation thereof thank you council members are there any questions comments or concerns

53:44

related to bill 6 of 2024 seeing and hearing them mr. true sale could you please call the vote

53:52

miss Daniels miss Davis yes miss green yes mr. Jones yay miss rolls yes mr. Rodriguez yes

54:06

miss banners yes bill 6 2024 passes by vote of 7 to 0 thank you

54:14

next we have resolutions the first resolution for consideration this evening is resolution 72 of

54:21

2024 mr. true sale could you please read it into the record

54:27

resolution 72 2024 a resolution confirming the appointment of mr. Jonathan Jonathan

54:33

L. Love Jr. S. Quarer to serve as an assistant city solicitor for the city of Harrisburg

54:39

thank you council members are there any questions comments or concerns related to resolution 72 of 2024

54:48

seeing and hearing none mr. true sale could you please call the vote miss Daniels

54:54

miss Davis yes miss green yes mr. Jones yay miss rolls yes mr. Rodriguez yes miss banners yes

55:06

resolution 72 2024 passes by vote of 7 to 0 thank you next we have resolution 73 of 2024 mr.

55:16

true sale could you please read it into the record resolution 73 2024 a resolution authorizing the city

55:22

of Harrisburg to negotiate and enter into a professional services contract with crystal and architect

55:28

to provide architectural services for renovation of the restroom facilities at the public works building

55:33

located at 18 20 packs in street thank you council members are there any questions comments or

55:40

concerns related to resolution 73 of 2024 seeing and hearing none mr. true sale could you please call

55:48

the vote miss Daniels miss Davis yes miss green yes mr. Jones yay miss rolls yes mr. Rodriguez yes miss banners

56:03

yes resolution 73 2024 passes by vote of 7 to 0 thank you next we have resolution 74 of 2024 Mr.

56:13

true sale could you please read it into the record resolution 74 2024 a resolution approving the

56:20

disposal of certain personal property owned by the city of Harrisburg which has exhausted its useful

56:25

life for city operations thank you council members are there any questions comments or concerns related

56:32

to resolution 74 of 2024 seeing and hearing none mr. true sale could you please call the vote miss Daniels

56:44

miss Davis yes miss green yes mr. Jones yay miss rolls yes mr. Rodriguez yes miss banners yes

56:56

resolution 74 2024 passes by vote of 7 to 0 thank you next we have resolution 75 of 2024

57:07

mr. true sale could you please read it into the record resolution 75 2024 a resolution approving the

57:13

preliminary slash final land development plan for 1103 south front street thank you council woman Daniels

57:22

would you like to offer your amendment at this time the amendment was provided it's simply in the

57:36

conclusion says council approves the resolution the conditions one through three only that's that

57:42

was that was the amendment okay thank you for clarifying what is anyone interested in suspending the

57:47

rules for any final discussion I will entertain a motion to suspend the rules a move second thank you

57:54

councilman Jones yes is tunnels for towers in yes kaga rainbow have a couple questions for you

58:06

gentlemen if you can could even on Bruce Roseman from called well and current I represent the tunnel

58:21

to towers foundation on join by mr. Louise Medendez construction director for the tunnels to

58:30

towers foundation right here to answer your questions sir can everyone introduce yourselves please

58:36

louis minnes 70 oakwood avenue upperbunk claire new jersey handed director of construction for the

58:42

homeless veterans program at tunnels towers also joining me is mr. Hill he can do that

58:53

Douglas Hill president of the capillary green bell association thank you so I submitted you guys

59:00

asked that we have any questions our concerns and I did submit a question and again it was two

59:04

some of the residents that you may have heard this evening and wanted to be able to speak to some of

59:09

that some of the concerns is are about the rerouting of the green bell of course we told we discussed

59:16

earlier about widening which would be narrowing sicklemore street which you know I was pretty much

59:24

against but just to give them some type of concrete insurance that this that this rerouting would

59:34

and be harmful to them because against some of the concerns where it's a safer route for them

59:39

rather riding in in the public spaces and I know you know because of the the ownership of this

59:45

and it just want to be able to give comfort to them to make sure that this will be addressed and not

59:51

just push to the side so if anyone wants to speak to that since it's not our project sir

1:00:00

since it's not a problem part of the tunnels to towers project I'm going to let mr.

1:00:08

Hells speak we have no knowledge of that thank you thank you as we indicated at the

1:00:15

council meeting last week we're completing the engineering review feasibility of rerouting as

1:00:19

you described onto sicklemore street and then through private properties and reconnecting to the

1:00:24

green bell in the air of chenoise street the engineering review is still incomplete but we are awaiting

1:00:33

the written report for the traffic and traffic study that is necessary as a part of that and

1:00:39

it's something that we've discussed previously with the city engineer and others verbally we have

1:00:45

assurance that the widening of the sidewalk and as you say the concurrent narrowing of sicklemore

1:00:52

street is well within the tolerances that pentat has for a street of that nature that use that design

1:00:59

that speed limit and that traffic volume and so when we have the written report I think you will be

1:01:04

satisfied that it can be done in a way that accommodates the trail and does not in any way impede or

1:01:12

caused problems for the traffic primarily that uses the pen dot building okay so pretty much

1:01:20

I don't know how we can communicate this with you know our physician which our residents to again

1:01:26

I don't know if there's a way for them to be in contact with you as well just you know just want

1:01:31

to put some secure I mean because again we are and a grants of this project personally let me say that

1:01:37

but you know when it comes to residents in our safety that's just something that I cannot ignore because

1:01:42

you know that's what I work for absolutely and you can take our assurances that we are working on a

1:01:49

public campaign to have our users and the residents of the city understand what the design criteria is

1:01:58

going to be what they can expect from the green belt ultimately when the work is complete and for

1:02:04

that matter some additional safety improvements that we've been working with the engineering department

1:02:09

on in the interim until the work can be done because we recognize that the current detour

1:02:16

is not the best and that people have expressed problems and issues with it and so we are going

1:02:20

to do some things to improve its safety in its current condition as well. I thank you for that

1:02:25

consideration um the other thing that I would just ask is like the timeline for this so that you

1:02:32

they do have time to discuss with you and you may be able to share that information as you guys come

1:02:36

up with your final design plans. And we are accessible on both our website and Facebook if people want

1:02:43

to submit comments we will respond to those and we do intend to proactively keep people apprised

1:02:54

of what the timeline is going to be. We have to hedge that just a little bit now because as you know

1:03:01

this property is that we're working with is also impacted by the construction on I-83 so both

1:03:08

at the front street portion of the trail where the south bridge is going to be widened and then at

1:03:13

the upper end of the Pancy property where that's going to be a staging area for I-83 both of those

1:03:20

parts of the project are going to impact Sycamore Street as well and so that will create a little bit

1:03:25

of a delay and so it could be about a three-year tale until we get the trail completed.

1:03:31

Okay thank you man I think no have no further questions unless my colleagues do.

1:03:37

Any other questions? Yeah absolutely. As Councilman Jones stated definitely in support of the

1:03:43

project we see how substantial this could be for the community but my only confusion is it was

1:03:49

initially pitched kind of together and once we found out of the three million dollar additional

1:03:54

price tag that may be on the burden of the taxpayers it's like oh no no no we're completely separate right

1:04:00

I understand that also the project is called tunnels to towers geared towards the veterans no

1:04:06

first responders are included in the project which is misleading also there's no guarantee that Harris

1:04:11

Burke citizens will work or Harrisburg veterans will be able to stay it although they're allowed

1:04:17

there's no guarantee of like a priority beings though it's in Harrisburg I know it's your saying

1:04:21

coming from New Jersey but I was elected by the resident of the city of Harrisburg I have to defend

1:04:26

first and foremost I'm just conflicted because this price tag shouldn't be left on the capital

1:04:33

green belt to fend for themselves I think the project should come together in totality and be

1:04:38

presented in totality then to boot the way your solicitor or end or attorney had kind of

1:04:45

ratified the document at the end and then pitched it to us I just kind of think was an insult to

1:04:49

council that's just my take on it I know everyone feels differently but that's my take on it no further

1:04:56

statements thank you any further discussion I just wanted to point something out really quick I

1:05:03

think so after our meeting last Tuesday a few residents came to me and then we had two residents come

1:05:08

tonight and I think some confusion is well if that's the green belt which is owned by the city

1:05:16

along with Kaga why is it so easily being removed and rerouted and what I was trying to explain was

1:05:23

that we did not own that section of the green belt it was owned privately by somebody else and out

1:05:29

of the kindness of their heart they allowed the green belt to run through that section but now if when

1:05:35

they sell their property that means they sell that part of the green belt and now it has to be taken

1:05:40

out and rerouted so I just want to make sure that I was correct when I gave them the information and for

1:05:46

anybody else who has that concerned it is this I don't want to say disheartening but it does this place

1:05:52

a lot of our residents as they ride and walk through those sections so I think they're very upset because

1:05:58

they're not understanding clearly why this is being done and maybe not enough communication was given

1:06:05

through the process and then the way that the project is split up it is as though it's just saying okay

1:06:12

we brought this no so what no one cares we're rerouting it so I think that's where a lot of the

1:06:17

feelings and disruption are coming from so I just wanted to point that out and I just make one more

1:06:22

state and quickly Madam President yes and and I know you guys may not be aware of the unhoused

1:06:28

population in the area although you say you were familiar when I asked at least maybe a shower on

1:06:34

the off part west or east of the building just to show you know maybe some love and neighboring you

1:06:40

was like no no we're just going to put a wall up that was kind of or gate I'm sorry I don't want to

1:06:44

miss quote that was just kind of unsettling because you know it's an issue that we all would have to

1:06:49

face and you come in into the community would make us family right so help us with some of the issues

1:06:54

that we face every day here in the city thank you this one thing Mr. Grover is there time

1:07:02

constraint for this this has a deemed approved date of November the 30th for and otherwise it

1:07:09

becomes a deemed approved if this council didn't act on it and it would be deemed approved with

1:07:14

none of the conditions that's how that works under the municipal plan and cook right so the

1:07:23

the and I will note the councilman brought roles you are correct it's private property and there are

1:07:28

other parts of the green belt that are not on public property as well it's always been sort of a

1:07:33

negotiated graceful collective of many people making this happen over many many decades

1:07:40

the but but it is private property and there was much discussion before it got to council whether

1:07:47

the city would engage in a taking if it if we tried to mandate it and and that

1:07:53

yeah well you could but but but yeah it's called just compensation for riverfront land which is a pretty

1:08:03

big number so any further questions comments or concerns okay I will entertain a motion to resume our

1:08:17

legislative session so move is there a second second thank you so before us we have resolution 75

1:08:24

of 2024 just wanted to make sure because I was having some technical difficulties earlier so I missed

1:08:31

the amended version so we do have the amended version and on page three it notes that the resolution

1:08:41

is here by approved subject to only conditions one through three recommended by the Harrisburg

1:08:46

Planning Commission as set forth here and so I wanted to note that's where it's noted and bold

1:08:52

if anyone was following along there okay mr. Trousdale could you please read the resolution just one

1:09:01

more time before we vote resolution 75 2024 a resolution approving the preliminary slash final land

1:09:10

development plan for 1103 south front street thank you any final questions comments or concerns council members

1:09:24

no it's included and it's a meant we have the amended version so we're good so no further discussion mr.

1:09:30

Trousdale could you please call the vote Miss Daniels Miss Davis yes miss green yes

1:09:40

mr. Jones yay miss roles yes mr. Rodriguez yes miss banners yes resolution 75 2024 passes as amended

1:09:54

by about a seven to zero thank you next we have resolution 76 of 2024 mr. Trousdale could you please

1:10:03

read it into the record resolution 76 2024 a resolution authorizing the city of Harrisburg to

1:10:13

negotiate and enter into a memorandum of understanding with the commonwealth of Pennsylvania relating to

1:10:18

certain waterway enhancements to better serve the health and safety needs of those of voters thank you

1:10:25

council members are there any questions comments or concerns related to resolution 76 of 2024

1:10:33

seeing and hearing now mr. Trousdale could you please call the vote

1:10:38

Miss Daniels yes miss Davis yes miss green yes mr. Jones yay miss roles yes

1:10:50

mr. Rodriguez yes miss banners yes resolution 76 2024 passes by about a seven to zero

1:10:59

thank you next we have resolution 77 of 2024 mr. Trousdale could you please read it into the record

1:11:08

resolution 77 2024 a resolution approving the seventh proposed 2024 budget reallocation in the form

1:11:16

of technical corrections and confirming the award of certain available general fund program dollars

1:11:22

to senior programming thank you i will entertain a motion to suspend the rules for discussion

1:11:28

the move thank you i will defer to our budget and finance committee chair vice president green thank you

1:11:37

very much looks like we have someone from the budget and finance office as well as from parks and

1:11:42

erect to come and it's explained this a little bit so i'll give them some time to get up here

1:11:57

and just a kind of um clarify a little bit although uh it talks about programming funds for the

1:12:05

senior citizen center it also includes the funding for the parks and wrecks department that was pulled

1:12:11

out of the six proposed budget reallocation so it's kind of going two separate things here uh one is to

1:12:18

appropriate the $250,000 that we put towards senior programming for the high and senior center

1:12:26

a month or so ago it's officially appropriated and then we're also going to discuss um the

1:12:32

information that we requested from the six proposed budget reallocation where we pulled out the line

1:12:37

items for the parks and wrecks department so we'll discuss two things at one time we'll start with

1:12:41

the parks and wrecks side and then uh discuss the seniors center side as well so if you could

1:12:49

introduce yourself and then get it started i'm Sasha Rose that be director for parks and recreation

1:12:55

Kevin's in it's the parks and recreation manager

1:12:58

you have questions yes i think um and summary uh we had some questions about the money that was being

1:13:09

moved from various positions including a playground and pool supplies money uh what it was being

1:13:16

moved for as well as what improvements were done to the Jackson Lake pool i know we had originally

1:13:22

allocated i believe $55,000 it was a big discussion about it um towards the the summertime uh it

1:13:28

looks like all of that money wasn't used looks like um 30,000 could have already been moved somewhere else

1:13:34

throughout the year and then now it's looking for more to be moved so we're just looking to get an

1:13:39

explanation as so what was done for the Jackson Lake pool uh how much that cost and then i guess why

1:13:45

the rest wasn't used um and then i'll open it up after that for more questions so we did a lot of uh

1:13:50

work in house um the roof was done i believe that was they've did a lot of the uh the work but we did a

1:13:58

lot of park maintenance did a lot of the work internally so we bought the uh we bought all the paint so the

1:14:04

paint in the bathroom the paint in a swimming pool um some plumbing was done um shower heads

1:14:12

uh

1:14:23

uh there epoxy the floor

1:14:31

i got the bad mic can you guys hear me

1:14:33

uh you probably think that might be a good idea

1:14:41

can you hear me now uh so we replaced all the mixing valves within the plumbing systems and both

1:14:47

the men and women's restrooms re-apoxied all the floors uh in both locker rooms and re-apoxied the

1:14:55

entire pool shell itself we added new expansion joints within the pool which is always a big area

1:15:01

of issue for us as far as water loss every year and erosion in the ground

1:15:05

we put shower heads we added some toilet dividers were needed uh repaired plumbing areas within the

1:15:13

sinks uh we looked at patching the enamel within the sinks and painted the walls replaced most of the

1:15:22

ballast and lights within the locker rooms that were all in need of doing so and uh did a general

1:15:31

pressure washing of the exterior of the building repainted outside where the paint was peeling on the

1:15:37

locker rooms and uh pressure wash the concrete area itself to take any sort of mildew stains off of that

1:15:48

all right i guess um just a general question for me did we do everything we said we were going to do

1:15:52

that and more all right and um why do we come so far under budget so part of the funds uh came out of

1:16:00

the facilities department budget because we do budget for the poor repairs just minor poor repairs and

1:16:06

the other portion of the funds came out of the partial wreck budget and it was allocated to do

1:16:10

what we did um so that the normal things that we would pay for on an annual basis we paid for those

1:16:16

the things that were outside of that scope we didn't pay for those and that came out of the

1:16:22

the pot of money that you guys allocated in the parts of the wreck budget okay so essentially

1:16:27

we would have double allocated we allocated out of your budget and then when we did the reallocation

1:16:32

we still reallocate it for that money as well so essentially we accounted for it twice and spent it once

1:16:40

somewhat yeah i mean we we spent it from all the same pot of money it just came out of the budget

1:16:45

that it normally comes out of for normal repairs and then the abnormal repairs or the larger capital

1:16:50

improvement cost all came out of where they were supposed to from parts and wreck all right um that's

1:16:56

all i have i'm going to open up to my colleague starting to my far left with counterman Jones any questions

1:17:00

yes thank you vice president green so um as i'm looking at the budgets um i'm going to go on a

1:17:09

temporary line that there was an overspindage of $91,000 $566 dollars in 85 cents can someone explain

1:17:22

why this happened so this year the school district allowed out earlier um and started later so our

1:17:31

program usually runs seven and a half weeks it went like nine weeks and also what the swimming pool

1:17:37

the swimming pool usually ends up before um labor day but we went all the way into labor day

1:17:45

and then our after school program we pay for that and then we added a summer um the kids helped out

1:17:51

with our summer series of the the movies in the park and then they also helped out with like

1:18:00

our muggers day events every all our events that we have internally which is our first year having

1:18:05

all of these events we never had these events that the kids can participate in and work so there

1:18:12

was no calculation to see that this was going to be over the budget that you guys had

1:18:20

so there are calculations but um with the increase in salaries and just some significant changes

1:18:27

and trying to keep things fluid things kind of went up and that's the that's the problem for me because

1:18:34

first of all we get into the 12 hour to 24 hour I don't know if you guys caught this in the beginning

1:18:40

I don't know when you caught it but and under the time constraint that we are in right now we have

1:18:45

the vote on this tonight or somebody won't be getting paid and we'll be in trouble for this and I don't

1:18:50

think it's fair for us our our residents to have to make a decision in the 24th hour if you guys

1:18:58

already budgeted and planted this thing out so can someone explain that

1:19:05

you say budgeted if you if you knew that you were budgeting you had the summer programs the movies

1:19:11

in the park all of the things that you said that's a budget if you knew that you were going to spend

1:19:16

as you should have had a number or around about number but for us to get this again at the last minute

1:19:23

is not fair to us so I'm just wondering who is responsible for not seeing this and that's

1:19:29

91,566 dollars and 85 cents

1:19:37

so you know in the last two years we had some transition uh one of our department split

1:19:44

how things were funded the previous year and how things were budgeted out and how we got some of

1:19:49

the final numbers some things were not necessarily all in the same budget line so there might have

1:19:54

been some miscalculations uh if again if you add that this past season we had more individuals making

1:20:01

a little bit more money on their salaries than what was actually traditionally put down on paper

1:20:08

and as were some of these costs jump and in order to maintain safety and provide services at an adequate

1:20:16

level these were things that happened and this you know I apologize but this is not an intentional

1:20:23

oversight we did when we realized there was no oversight we reeled in some other costs we didn't do

1:20:32

some things we focused on safety which was keeping making sure we had staff out there to provide the

1:20:40

safety and that is paramount or number one goal so that means some things being done in some of the

1:20:45

parks we will take we can ask what Sasha stated about having more internal stuff being done park

1:20:52

maintenance so that's where we pulled it up and that's where we pulled it tight.

1:21:01

I have no further questions. Thank you um I guess just kind of to piggyback off of that um

1:21:08

leave it was last year we overspent on our temporary funding for our employees because we overhired

1:21:15

and no one noticed that we had overhired by 2030 people until it was like oh we won't be able to pay

1:21:23

the kids if you guys don't increase the budget so it kind of just seems like the same thing.

1:21:28

Yeah that was before us but we did cut that amount of kids by 50 this year so we cut them on the kids

1:21:35

increased them on a program increased the pay and all the pays already at set is that it's between

1:21:41

15 and 18 but each year they come back they have to get a raise so we have more returners this year than

1:21:47

usual so then they get they get that jump every year all right so we decreased the number of employees

1:21:56

and still overspent the increasing number of employees increased the amount that they were getting paid

1:22:03

because they were returners I think I believe 80% of them is returners.

1:22:09

Okay um and when was it caught that we were overspending?

1:22:23

September all right I'm going to continue to um open up for questions from my colleagues

1:22:31

councilmember Rodriguez thank you madam chair thank you parks and rec crew deputy Ross had

1:22:38

had a conversation with me on the phone so I'm kind of privy to a little bit but my main question

1:22:43

uh director Sanders you had said individuals or entities I'm not sure we're making more than what

1:22:50

was actually on paper could you elaborate on that sorry I'm not sure you had just made a statement

1:22:57

that it turned out to be individuals started making more than what was actually on paper you said

1:23:02

that verbatile. I'm sorry if I'm a spoke I'm saying that we have more individuals making 18 dollars an

1:23:08

hour this year than we ever have and we didn't calculate for that okay I'm just sorry let's

1:23:14

say that's right sorry if that's what came out we had eight more individuals made a statement from

1:23:18

17 and 18 dollars than normal okay okay years of fact we did not have the somehow we have a lot of

1:23:26

returning lifeguards um with lifeguard managers with some individuals who didn't move on but we have a

1:23:33

lot more people on a 17 and 18 dollar an hour you figure if they're making if they're working 35

1:23:39

to 40 hours to maintain safety not not not to cut you off it did it just alluded it gave as if

1:23:46

you were meaning like an administrator or a top tier employee the way you the way the conversation

1:23:52

was it alluded to that so I just wanted to clarify that that was all thank you. Councilwoman Rose thank

1:24:00

you vice president green I'm in good evening thank you everybody for being here tonight to answer

1:24:04

our questions so we can better understand this reallocation um what I want I know deputy Ross and

1:24:12

I also spoke on the phone about this reallocation because a few questions came up last time especially

1:24:18

about I think money was being taken out of the 170 thousand dollars to help reallocate for the

1:24:26

temporary positions but then um Brian had also brought up that another payment was coming out so we

1:24:34

weren't sure how much was going to be left and anybody correct me if I'm wrong but um so that was a

1:24:41

concern which is why we tabled it and then the second thing I know um you and I spoke on the phone

1:24:46

deputy Ross and you had explained that because we were on the risk on council if if we take from that

1:24:54

170 thousand which we always need pool improvements because right now in the city we have no pool out

1:25:00

the self because that needs to be figured out if we can even build one there and then we're trying to

1:25:06

keep Jackson like a float until we're able to use the grant money to renovate it um so our question

1:25:15

was well if we're taking that away from that 170 thousand won't we have less of course but we even

1:25:23

have enough to do what we need to do because there's always always come for a reallocation to do

1:25:28

pool improvements so can you speak to a little bit more about that what you and I spoke to on the phone

1:25:32

about somehow I think you said uh that 170 thousand gets replenished somehow I don't want to say

1:25:39

it incorrectly so can you speak more to that so we can understand please so we get the 170 every year

1:25:44

if you look in the budget for a 2025 it will be there so that 170 includes any emergency so

1:25:50

when the um shoes on that is open someone threw a brick on a slide that costed $6,000 so that comes out

1:25:58

of there so that happens with that that is for like emergencies like anything that breaks um a fence

1:26:06

that might been cut cut down at a box then or something like that so we use that funding for that

1:26:13

and also with our program and anything we need for the kids our program is not free we don't well it's

1:26:19

free for the community but we have to pay for those things and order for us to keep on doing this for

1:26:23

the community we need those funds to allow us to bring the children together so that's where that

1:26:30

money comes from as well okay thank you um was that fine council because I know that was a question of

1:26:38

ours with that 170 is that okay my second thing was um correct this is the second time we've

1:26:46

gone over budget and parks and rack especially with the temporary position so either deputy Ross

1:26:52

or finance department can you explain what have we put in place for this year to make sure that

1:26:58

we're not going to go over budget what kind of proactive um things that we put in place in the

1:27:04

budget this year for parks and rack

1:27:11

so are we looking at it closely um also I'm sorry would you I'm sorry say that again that

1:27:17

it I'll be looking at it closely so the the issue that we have is how much we're paying the children

1:27:24

and the amount of children that's coming back so when we cut the the budget we have kids and parents

1:27:30

come and parents is sick so it's like all right we'll be since the application was a little later we've

1:27:37

been taking all the applications that come first but the parents is coming in they're sick and they're

1:27:41

crying for their kids to come so it's like we have to add the ones that's returning because we feel bad

1:27:47

so and then they get a jump up and pay so it's like how can we get everybody in without going

1:27:54

over budget so it's we you just can and I think that's what and I and I know we and I don't I'm not trying

1:28:00

to say that and I'm not being heartless when I say that there's something we got to put in that we

1:28:06

have to be able to say and I love your heart for that and you know what I mean that's that's calling

1:28:11

but it's like if we keep doing it we're gonna go over budget I but I don't understand what you're saying

1:28:16

right so this year on March 28th we had already 200 I'm sorry 370 applications

1:28:25

we've never had that amount ever okay did I interview over 150 individuals this year we had a

1:28:34

substantial amount of rehires the substantial amount of individuals who've worked three four

1:28:41

years some eight nine years so this year was that year where the scale got tipped while we reduced

1:28:50

the number down to about 107 from the previous year we were about 135 years we were taking maybe a

1:28:54

little bit more when you all shake it all out but at the end of the day we went nine whole weeks

1:29:01

summer program nine full weeks we also had the pool open a lot longer than we did in the years past

1:29:10

where school started later these are substantial things and you know it's one pool we had 24

1:29:15

plus staffers we're staffing 16-18 lifeguards at the pool on the face we had we can't count we we're

1:29:24

at we're at capacity all through June all through July half of July we're at capacity we got

1:29:29

it we have to we have to provide safety and coverage the pool was packed every day this year

1:29:35

you know I'm sorry I just get that but I'm just saying again it get hard everything is good but there

1:29:43

has to be you have to be able to stop the bleeding at some point if there's too many people coming in

1:29:49

we don't have the money to give them we're over and then if you call it in September we're just now

1:29:56

getting it now tonight it's not good and then also in my just just to add I think I advocate for that

1:30:06

program because I love to keep the kids off the street but is there no other corner or no

1:30:10

Ukrainian where we can trim the fat to compensate I don't think the youth or the juvenile have to

1:30:16

suffer at all there's some other way we can come up with the money by just cutting some of the

1:30:21

things we necessarily don't need we did maybe through other departments we're saying that's just

1:30:27

a part of the the budgeting process right that's what we should be talking about now absolutely not

1:30:31

like literally now we shouldn't be talking about 2024's budget we should be talking about 2025's budget

1:30:37

and where we can pull from to increase this program funding to begin with and I think that's more

1:30:42

you know to begin with it's an administrative job right when they present the budget to make for sure

1:30:48

that it's that all that is calculated personally I would think that you'd automatically calculate

1:30:53

at the highest amount right automatically calculate that every position will be paid $18 an hour

1:30:58

because that that is your cap and if you underpay then maybe you can hire more people or expand

1:31:03

the programming I would say you budget at your max and hope to understand some but you don't budget

1:31:10

underspending and then have to overspend because then we find ourselves in that position and that's

1:31:16

just not the best fiscal management right and I'd like to add in the last two years

1:31:21

rather we're part is double on a day-to-day basis we're we're seeing 120 children out there

1:31:29

there's a need for that service and I want to make sure everybody understands why we we hold a line

1:31:35

we got to put you know probably you know for one adult child to maybe three or four you know three

1:31:43

or four kids so we do need to have that staff out there using reservoir as a key because that is

1:31:50

our our biggest park and that is the one that we were really we're navigating we had 370 individual

1:31:56

signed up last year we stopped we did what you did seven so amount we stopped at 228 we stopped I had

1:32:04

people sneaking putting their names on other parks and coming to reservoir and these are the things

1:32:09

that we're dealing with on a day-to-day basis we're trying to provide services at a high level

1:32:14

is that a quality control issue yeah I mean we're we're moving staff around left and right we did it all

1:32:19

year and we're trying to do these things to provide what we can we can cut we can stop but it comes

1:32:26

out of price and to me we have to practice what we're preaching if we're here if we're going to do it

1:32:33

for the children we got to do it for the children and that's our motto we do thank you

1:32:37

we're saying we're not going to price too no no if we're budgeting tight I mean this is a tight

1:32:41

budget I want to make sure everybody understands that but I realize we went over but again a lot of

1:32:48

that's around safety issues we have to staff and I don't think it's just about budgeting tight I think

1:32:54

it's about budgeting realistically right and knowing that if if we know that the need is there we know

1:33:00

that we're I mean it's a great thing that we're signing more kids up it's a great thing that we're

1:33:04

offering more programs it's a great thing that there's more opportunity that the pools open longer

1:33:09

although I believe it did open later than originally scheduled but you know it's a great thing that

1:33:14

it's open later it's a great thing that we've got after school programs it's a great thing that we've

1:33:17

got senior programming I don't think anyone here is saying cut the programs I don't think anyone here

1:33:22

is saying take the opportunities away from our children I think what we're saying is this is

1:33:26

something and maybe it's a training thing maybe it's a learning thing maybe it's working closer

1:33:32

with the finance department to better budget so that we don't run into these problems I don't think anyone

1:33:36

here saying we don't want you to have 91,566 dollars and 85 cents we're saying that this isn't the time

1:33:43

to becoming a asking for it it should have been asked for November of 2024 or excuse me 2023 not

1:33:50

that November 26 of 2024 we're having this discussion while we're also being presented with the budget

1:33:56

for 2025 because at the end of the day it's like as it was explained if this doesn't get done people don't

1:34:05

get paid from what I understand the finance department said we are at the point of running the risk that

1:34:12

if this is not passed in a reasonable amount of time as in today that we do run the risk of not being

1:34:19

able to to pay some of those positions so there's a city ordinance that prevents

1:34:26

the controller from signing a paycheck if there's not funding through the end of the budget year and they

1:34:32

are now approaching that in parks and rec we don't but we don't have any kids we have any no temporary staff

1:34:39

working right now so yeah but the the the issue is they they use the 91,000 out of your regular pay

1:34:45

roll to cover this and so the regular pay roll is what's coming up short the people that are actually

1:34:52

still working full time for us are now at risk of being laid off or not being paid I mean that's the

1:34:58

budgeting question because the controller literally is prohibited by law from signing a check without money in it

1:35:05

so that's why it's that's why there's some urgency to it you know and uh

1:35:11

right and so when it's looked at is like oh there's no one working right now so it's not really that big of a

1:35:16

deal we're cleaning it up after the fact if you pay check don't come tomorrow I don't think you'd be happy

1:35:21

about you know like it's just because the way the budget works although the money was already spent

1:35:26

it wasn't there to be spent so it was pulled from another park because it's technically one large

1:35:31

budget of personnel and so you could pay it out of the personnel budget but at some point it has to

1:35:36

be replenished um so when it comes to us it's to the point of if it doesn't get passed people don't get paid

1:35:41

and it puts the onus on count to not take the responsibility of asking these hard questions and

1:35:47

either standing online and saying okay well we don't agree with the way it was budgeted um but then

1:35:53

that's the the workers that are all punished for it and this is above their pay grade um you know they

1:35:58

didn't make the choice to have people work extra hours or do more programming um and so that's why it's

1:36:04

really important to us as count to members to really drive this point across because we're in budgeting

1:36:08

season and um like I said maybe it's a training thing but we have to take this serious along the year

1:36:14

that um I know we originally implemented quarterly reports uh we don't get all of our quarterly

1:36:19

reports now that they aren't coming down in person but part of it was to pay attention to some of

1:36:23

these things so that during your first second third quarter you can look and go okay we're looked

1:36:29

like we're about over budget in our temporary line item this is something we can address not that

1:36:34

we're waiting until we're over budget by $91,000 and saying if we don't do it someone doesn't get paid

1:36:40

because that's unfair to count to um but it meant you're just just try to be fair to everybody I think

1:36:47

because the people that normally would have brought this to the attention of the department and the

1:36:51

depension of the mayor and the attention of the council those two positions were vacant right still we

1:36:57

still had in place quarterly reports we could have been ahead of that I have any more questions

1:37:04

because I have comments where we are able to come down in front of us and compensate like this

1:37:09

that's been taken away not by you it's been taken away by administration

1:37:16

um she still has questions I just had a comment I just wanted to say just to wrap it back around that

1:37:22

I agreed like um deputy Ross and mr. Saunders you all have had amazing programs throughout this year

1:37:31

there's always something going on um I have been to many of the parks with my kids um the staffing is great

1:37:38

they're respectful I mean of course you always have a few who do what they want but that's that's

1:37:42

normal teenagers but they're easily redirected um you have managers the pool with staff the life

1:37:48

guards were wonderful every time I went to Jackson Lake it was packed um there were a lot of people there

1:37:53

I saw the difference in the locker rooms and the pool house all of those things so you know thank you

1:37:59

for a job well done I would just only say as we continue like we have a new budget here I just hope

1:38:05

that we budgeted higher up so then we're ready just in case we have extra staff because I don't want to

1:38:13

turn the kids away either but we do have to have a point where we have to say okay listen I'm sorry

1:38:18

all the jobs are filled that's reality that's life um and as big as we want and as much as we want to

1:38:25

make sure we do everything for this community if someone doesn't come and fill out an application

1:38:29

on time then they're unable to get a position especially if we know we don't have it budgeted for

1:38:35

so I just want to end with saying like I hope that in the budget we have in front of us and if not

1:38:41

please correct it and give us a sheet before we go to vote on anything or have to amend anything

1:38:46

just let's be proactive about it let's make sure we have budgeted for extra positions this summer knowing

1:38:53

hey we only budgeted for 50 but we know we probably gonna get about 60 kids or 50 of those kids are

1:38:59

going to get higher pay so please give that a look before we look at it have to vote on it amended let's

1:39:05

just be proactive about it so that would be my end comment thank you again for coming tonight and

1:39:10

explaining this thank you president Bowers I have three points I'd like to make and then we'll move on

1:39:17

the first is following up on quarterly reports I just wanted to share the purpose of the quarterly

1:39:23

reports they are twofold they are a budgeting tool so that when we get to this budget hearing season

1:39:32

we already know what to expect within each of the departments and bureaus we want we will not be

1:39:40

blindsided by shouldn't be by blindsided by anything we should have a clear understanding of what's

1:39:46

going on on a daily basis throughout the year so that's one thing the other thing is just it's

1:39:53

a matter of transparency right just being transparent so not only do council members have a better idea

1:40:01

of what goes on in a on a daily basis within these departments and bureaus but residents have a

1:40:08

better understanding as well I can tell you that residents are disappointed that they have to go

1:40:15

to the website and see a portion of quarterly reports received each quarter so I wanted to know that

1:40:23

second this issue was identified in September and I find that it to be an excuse that the people that

1:40:31

were in place that could inform the mayor and everyone else of this issue that's that's merely an

1:40:37

excuse because we still have a budget manager and mr. Brooks you couldn't speak to this last week so

1:40:43

that's why we're here now so I think that's an excuse and it's unacceptable September and it's almost

1:40:49

December three is there an evaluation or has some evaluation been done maybe internally or with the

1:41:01

temporary staffers or residents and children that participated in all of the extra programming I'm

1:41:08

just wondering if if all the programming was necessary did you have a good turnout just little things

1:41:19

and then to speak to the capacity of staff needed for all of these extra events and activities

1:41:28

I can see the numbers over we keep documents at that okay just curious they're not working every event

1:41:35

but they are working a summer program as far as the um the movies in the parks so that's every Friday okay

1:41:42

but you mentioned Mother's Day and something else too that occurred during that time a couple of

1:41:46

them they show up but not everyone okay I would like to see those numbers I'm a fan of evaluating and

1:41:53

determining if something is impactful um and if there were five people sometimes people think that's

1:42:00

a success but I don't consider that to be successful also this year this is the first year for everything

1:42:08

so you're we're not going to really see if it's impactful or not because this is the first year

1:42:11

for everything um for a tree-dying event someone came up um getting called hot chocolate and he said oh

1:42:18

my um my wife would love the mother of the event it might have been only 10 people there but it's

1:42:22

our very first one so we can give you the numbers for this year that's when it's when everything started

1:42:32

okay well hopefully next year I guess if you plan to do it maybe 20 people will come to the Mother's Day

1:42:39

event um but we have to budget for it that's correct so I don't have anything else to say but

1:42:46

to learn that this occurred in September and we're just now learning about it and then you could

1:42:51

answer any questions last week I just really have an issue with that thank you oh I have a question

1:42:58

is there any um particular questions you might need for um quarterly reports because I can always add

1:43:04

more information I believe we had a format for we have a format so I always follow that that's fine

1:43:11

but if it's any extra things just let me know okay thank you um any questions count to woman Davis

1:43:18

no um vice president green everyone has answered ask the questions and um offer the solution

1:43:28

being proactive measure proactive measures so I don't have any other questions thank you council

1:43:36

woman Daniels any questions we can hear you now yes okay um I was just saying that every year

1:43:53

part of the budgeting process the department chairs are tested the finance director that the

1:43:58

budget that they're requesting is sufficient to meet the the functions of the department so um you

1:44:04

know so this this is reflective of just the processing terms of the entire department because it seems

1:44:12

like there's a lot of miscommunication um but the department also needs some management and you know

1:44:19

not you know exceeding a budget by that much money um is a management issue um it means someone

1:44:27

doesn't pay attention to the funds and it is problematic because when you're spending money that you

1:44:31

want authorize to spend um and then we have to fix it on the other side um you know it makes us have

1:44:40

to make cuts in other places right um because then here's when you pass a budget at the beginning of

1:44:46

the year you're passing a budget with the idea that you're meeting all of the goals within that budget so

1:44:52

this is just poor management and I hope that you won't take the time to go back and maybe do some

1:44:57

training and um I have a better understanding of how your entire department functions

1:45:05

thank you um I do have two two other questions and I will try to wrap it up so we can move to the

1:45:11

senior citizens center part um the first question is for the finance department are all

1:45:17

incumbrances from these line items paid for 2024 I know um Mr. McCutcheon last week said that there was

1:45:24

an incumbrance that came in after this was done and I don't think there have been any adjustments to

1:45:28

these numbers so uh let's be told it was the belly landscape and yes that's the paint but is it included

1:45:36

in this schedule yeah like are the numbers the proposed available budget after these amendments are

1:45:43

they correct because I don't think there have been changes since last week

1:45:53

the schedule is still effective to October 31st 2024 if we were to make the schedule to

1:46:02

the current date then it would be in comfort you know it would be within the schedule but because the

1:46:08

schedule is only through October 31st those those transactions occurred beyond that time before

1:46:15

I do understand that I'm asking what's the number is of today we we make this change we pay it today

1:46:19

are we going to be negative somewhere else that's that's my that's my you know like that's my question

1:46:22

I think Mr. McCutcheon might have the updated numbers that's that's kind of what I'm looking for just

1:46:27

to update the numbers so that we don't

1:46:40

next day yes that that concern about pulling that amount from that line the 43,000

1:46:49

from the the supplies line there is an existing incumbrance that's already

1:46:54

encumbering budget correct so any any invoices that come in between now and the end of the year

1:47:01

I can't tell you how many POs or encumbrances that that that is included in that

1:47:07

the total encumbrance right now is just short of $4,000,000 so that budget has already been

1:47:13

encumbered so we won't lose anything further based based on those current encumbrances so there

1:47:20

there is sufficient budget currently to address the requested 43,000 dollar reallocation

1:47:28

all right so the 61,000 that is showing here is minus 46,000 as of today

1:47:35

no it's not because the 46,000 is already if you look at column F the the the incumbrance I mentioned

1:47:44

which is 3,000,000 it's included in that 65,000 okay I thought you said last week the one came

1:47:52

in after October 31st there was activity like an actual expenditure activity it could very well I

1:48:00

don't know as a fact but it could very well have been charged against that incumbrance

1:48:05

in other words if we do a check run and we make a payments we're not further reducing budget because

1:48:09

it's being applied against the existing incumbrance which is already taking up available budget

1:48:15

okay so you're saying it was already accounted for on the 65,000 dollars

1:48:20

yes that incumbrance that was subsequent activity in early November

1:48:25

okay last week you made it seem like it wasn't included so I think that was at least from

1:48:30

council's perspective we thought that wasn't included and so that was a concern of taking

1:48:36

43,000 out leaving 61 will we knew we still had incumbrances to be paid right and I obviously

1:48:42

I didn't make that clear enough then but that that that again the incumbrance that's out there it's

1:48:47

already fed by the budget so there won't be any further reduction because that that incumbrance

1:48:52

is already being supported by budget so that's in other words that's 61,000

1:48:58

is for the most part still intact as far as availability so that even with the effect of the

1:49:06

43,000 dollar reallocation okay that wasn't the impression we got last week but if that's correct

1:49:16

then I wouldn't have an issue with that if it's not correct then I do have an issue with it yes understood

1:49:24

I said are you able to and maybe you can email it to us but you able to change the date

1:49:32

so that it shows tomorrow's date I guess if you do tomorrow and yes and then please send it to us

1:49:38

so we can see and compare because yes last week I thought you had said there was still money to come

1:49:45

out so we're not reflecting the true amount and that's why we tabled it that was the whole reason

1:49:51

and still to come meaning that I don't know you know can't predict the future just give me tomorrow's

1:49:58

date on there okay just okay let me see everything starting with tomorrow so I can look at it so we

1:50:03

all can look at and compare because I'm a little confused now okay all right um and then my other

1:50:12

question would go to the parks and rec department we budgeted for $35,000 in consulting what was

1:50:20

the original thought behind that and why was it no consulting the change in direction happened so

1:50:28

we ended up not doing it there were some changes with the side of the projects we were supposed to

1:50:34

pick up a project but we had to put it off okay so will that be budgeted in this next year's budget

1:50:42

or we're just gonna yes okay all right any other questions or comments concerning this exhibit a

1:50:51

in the parks and rec department in these lines all right uh sing now and I appreciate you guys being

1:50:58

here tonight um I do want to let you know we appreciate all the work you do we love all the extra

1:51:03

events um the opportunities for the residents and the kids we just gotta make sure we budget better

1:51:08

and I'm sure the finance department will in the work with you uh throughout this budget season to

1:51:13

make sure that everything's where it's supposed to be uh so that everything can go on next year and we

1:51:17

can have our our controls in place so thank you now on to the second part of this resolution which is

1:51:31

the $250,000 dollars for senior program funding to the Heinz Minnick-Rosinger Center who will

1:51:36

continually provide services to Harrisburg senior population um Mr. Grove if you could just explain why

1:51:42

this is in here and the effect of it certainly and and frankly this is my handy work right trying to

1:51:48

figure out how to get something voted on it came out of the arper projects that were approved when

1:51:55

when the council provides a blanket number without a specific award and you gotta remember we're not in

1:52:01

the business of running programs like this uh there has to be a way for council to come back and vote

1:52:06

on it like because you you put money for senior program but not to a senior program and if we did

1:52:12

the similar thing in an earlier um reallocation for the for the um bridge program for the homeless

1:52:20

it was just a mecket a tool we could figure out how to get it in front of you so there's not

1:52:24

13 reallocations right like like how do you put this stuff together they're both about how to

1:52:29

money gets spent um so the mayor determined to award the senior program to the Heinz Center

1:52:36

you know we are in the middle of putting together it's a contract that's different than one we've had

1:52:40

because it's not we don't do these um and we're pretty far along with that but then there wasn't

1:52:45

authority to go forward with the contract because the council had not voted so that's how we put it here

1:52:51

when I sent it down I really thought I didn't realize you even have another one just later session before

1:52:56

the budget vote so it seemed like if this doesn't come down you know it's not coming uh so that's

1:53:02

how we put it in there um so and uh I didn't realize till I was talking with Jared there was another

1:53:07

legislative session to come in the December the 9th um so that's that's how we put these two together

1:53:15

this would have come down by itself as the seventh if you hadn't pulled the other one when we took

1:53:22

it out last week to get better explanations on the park so what either way it was coming down to

1:53:26

you as as the council have been to approve it so that's how it's here um you know that that and

1:53:32

and that is just simply the mechanism to get it here thank you does anyone have any questions regarding

1:53:38

this portion um I I have some comments I guess um so we've invited um she was noted as interim director

1:53:57

but by my calculation she's been here more than 120 days um so director Gloria Martin Roberts to our

1:54:06

council meetings um twice to discuss these particular funds on September 10th of 2024 and

1:54:16

October 1st of 2024 um both meetings she was initially eager to participate but then when we arrived

1:54:28

she was nowhere to be found um so we haven't had a public dialogue about this it was mentioned earlier

1:54:35

that the Hines Center is the only senior center in the city of Harrisburg um there are actually 11

1:54:44

senior centers in Dauphin County for are located in the city of Harrisburg uh Benay Brith they offer

1:54:52

congregant hot lunch meals opportunities to socialize and uh a variety of programs lick towers

1:55:00

senior center also offers a congregant hot lunch meal opportunities to socialize a variety of

1:55:08

programs the Jewish Federation of Greater Harrisburg they have a senior adult program offering

1:55:14

kosher meals um and opportunities to socialize as well and a variety of other activities then we have

1:55:21

the Hines Manaker senior center and all of their um work in programming was discussed earlier um my

1:55:30

question remains how did we arrive at Hines Manaker when there are other organizations and other

1:55:39

centers um that potentially could be eligible for this funding

1:55:44

well as I can tell you is the mayor rated determination um maybe there's well so can speak to that

1:55:53

question but uh in the budget but no in the budget when there's not a specific thing you leave it to

1:55:59

the executive branch to make a decision you don't have to agree with the decision that's why it comes

1:56:03

back to you right that's why that's the process it's the executive and legislative together and

1:56:09

that's how it comes back to um the uh but I can't speak to the how I mean that's just you know

1:56:17

that was the award that was made well can anybody speak to it I mean yes how did we arrive here

1:56:24

I can I can speak to it um just a smidgen of it um you know at one point we got to remember that

1:56:33

um the school year mara robert was a part of the Hines Center's board or something like that she was

1:56:38

on their board at one point yes you can you can step step to the mic do we have to

1:56:51

spend the rules we are the rules are suspended no the rules have been suspended yeah this is still the

1:56:57

same resolution come on yes if I mean it would be helpful if somebody from the administration could

1:57:08

answer these questions but since you're here I do have another question where can we find a list

1:57:15

of current board members because I tried to look online but there's no website

1:57:27

if I don't think that microphone is working if you wouldn't mind using the microphone you initially

1:57:35

spoken to please if I may um members of city council I think that the president alluded to a statement

1:57:44

that I've made about the number of senior centers in the city let me um clarify that there is uh

1:57:50

perhaps some question of some debate around what qualifies as a senior center um when you look at

1:57:58

what is what we use is the local area on aging and what they designate but they also have other

1:58:06

distinctions because um some centers provide um you're right some provide some organizations

1:58:16

provide congregant meals under though it's my understanding and this is from the secretary

1:58:22

of agents mouth because we work with the secretary on aging and we can even invite him here that

1:58:28

might not be a bad idea actually because we are the center of the universe uh you know it only has

1:58:35

to do is walk down the street and um we've done that before and he's come to our meetings at time

1:58:40

senior center because we provide a full service uh program you talked about the programs and activities

1:58:48

uh that we provide we are considered under the state statute um that actually developed in the

1:58:56

early 80s I believe it was late 70s early 80s senior centers we are considered a full service

1:59:02

senior center so to the extent that um my language should have been clearer my offer my apologies

1:59:09

there are entities that offer congregant meals I would also suggest that of the four that you mentioned

1:59:17

I believe that one um no longer does so but it is um a shifting um um process because the

1:59:26

department of aging is shifting its focus um it is um in it is in flux it is having a um a transition

1:59:35

in terms of the way it provides allocations in terms of funding in terms of services and what it

1:59:42

provides through area agencies on aging of that to at the county level and that is the entity to whom

1:59:50

essentially we report I'm familiar this information is coming directly from doff in counties

1:59:57

I understand we have a copy of what what you are referring to well thank you I don't have any

2:00:03

other questions really for you I I would love to hear from uh miss martin robert and the administration

2:00:11

because we've been trying to have this dialogue and then here comes the allocations let me let me

2:00:18

suggest to you that um the hind senior center does its work without fear or favor okay we welcome

2:00:26

everyone everybody here is welcome to come to the hind senior center you don't even have to be a

2:00:31

senior you can just come on in and a lot of people have done that we have provided many programs um one

2:00:38

of the things that we have done over the years one of the activities is around um it's something

2:00:43

that is said but around repasts you know there are folks in this community who cannot afford in many

2:00:50

instances to have a repast um that cost a lot of money and the senior center has been kind of the

2:00:57

place where you can go and um you can um we will provide that service to you and you will play a

2:01:05

minimal or no cost and that's the kind of um activity in which we engage now I'm thinking I am mindful

2:01:15

let me say this I am mindful of what I just heard around budgeting um you know and the um

2:01:22

appropriateness of um anti-chim ones budget effectively so there were lessons for everyone in this room

2:01:29

in the previous session um and um and the lessons are important but it um having said that um the

2:01:37

hind center has the challenge this goes directly to um what I I can I'm serving as an advocate for

2:01:46

the hind center this goes directly to the challenge we have around budget and um and this goes

2:01:54

beyond providing congregant meals this goes to the programs and services the full service components

2:02:03

of uh we have been providing to this community over the course of the life of the hind senior center

2:02:12

we have done that um no matter who has set in those seats and our hope and our um in our prayer

2:02:20

and our expectation is that we will continue to do so I can tell you that um there are people who

2:02:26

advocate for us one day and then they don't the next that's okay we're still going to open up

2:02:32

and we're still going to provide the services if we have the resources that's the way we have to

2:02:37

operate um I want to say one other thing and that is I talked about uh the department of aging shifting

2:02:45

its focus two weeks ago I actually saw you if I may um um Mr Jones I saw you in the Hilton as I was

2:02:53

leaving a program provided um on the department of aging shifting focus because they are moving away

2:03:02

from the kinds of senior centers that we have to a different um a different philosophical um construct

2:03:12

that will not benefit in my view the citizens of cities like Harrisburg and I was there as the

2:03:21

representative of Hines to tell them to advocate on behalf of the city of Harrisburg the residents here

2:03:29

the seniors to say to them we need to really be cognizant of what the senior members of our community

2:03:39

needs and um the secretary of aging and I had a uh what I would call a robust discussion

2:03:47

that carried over into the hallway but I want you to know that's something that we need to be aware of

2:03:54

and it's also something that the Hines Center is if I may um equipped to do and it goes beyond I would

2:04:04

suggest what um a um a smaller entity might be able to do and I think that's the expectation um that

2:04:15

others have of us that is why when there is a need such as when there is a family that has COVID

2:04:24

and they call around and they can't find anyone they call the Hines Senior Center and we get the meals

2:04:31

to the seniors so I don't have any other questions thank you okay um my thing is uh you know when I

2:04:41

originally came across this and and the language in it which stated let me no I'm listening I'm just

2:04:48

I I didn't say anything I just I said nothing I just I mean the language the language that was stated

2:04:56

in this original and I felt that someone added a line I'm not sure who did that um but it was just

2:05:03

to allocate $250,000 to programming senior programming not a specific place so I'm going to make a

2:05:13

motion to strike this portion resolution 17 of 2024 inside of resolution 77 at some point and

2:05:23

put this on its own to give us an opportunity for our next legislative session to do something

2:05:29

if you know to have my colleagues look at this and see about the allocation of these funds so that's

2:05:34

something that I plan to do I see you looking at me so I will respond because that's what I'm trained to do

2:05:41

that's my training everyone knows that so I will respond I um understand and appreciate the job

2:05:47

that you have to do I am here as the advocate for the Hines Medical Senior Center and for senior

2:05:54

and and there's a reason why and I think I've explained that to you I understand again and appreciate

2:06:01

what it is that you must do um I'd be happy to answer any questions that you might have about

2:06:07

the Hines Medical Senior Center in uptown Harrisburg and the work that we perform what I cannot do

2:06:15

is delve into the political nuances of any of that and I don't know what they are and I don't have

2:06:23

any information and I think that's appropriate thank you that's why we we have no further questions

2:06:31

for you thank you I think sorry vice president both councilwoman Rawls and councilwoman Davis have

2:06:40

I'm sorry I was just wondering um solicitor Grover would you be able to let me see my question here

2:06:47

more of a common question but um of course support senior citizen centers getting they're just doing

2:06:56

what they need to run smoothly provide for you know the residents which is why we had to that with

2:07:02

the ARPA money with the $250,000 knowing that there's more than just one senior sitting senior

2:07:08

citizen yes okay it was like a tongue-tister in the city it was for any center that was doing programming

2:07:17

is there any way for the administration to provide us with some type of reasoning on why the $250,000

2:07:28

all of it was just going to the Hines senior I will absolutely pass on that request I don't think

2:07:34

that's going to be meant with hostility I don't think so I think I think there's a rationale I just

2:07:40

am not the person who can give it to you you know the there in the business manager isn't still here

2:07:48

is he Mr. well this was done before he was true I didn't know they brought him up to speed you know

2:07:54

that line underneath for there that was added don't know who did it there was a line underneath for

2:08:00

there would you originally look at it did remember this I don't know if you remember but this this

2:08:04

resolution was changed a couple times you mean the one that was voted on before not this one in front of you

2:08:09

absolutely so so there was a line again where the $250,000 was for senior programming not specifically

2:08:20

the Hines or Bernat Briff or anyone else but there was a line added underneath for there so I think

2:08:27

that's actually the next thing the question is what does the executive branch do with with that

2:08:31

request I mean it's always that as you've seen other grant sometimes we have the same award every year

2:08:38

but they input the name of the grantee and the budget and it comes back this one here specifically is one

2:08:43

that is like a one-shot deal right because this is coming from this is there's not going to be this

2:08:49

money ever again that's what the reality is and but the mechanics if I may you can do exactly what

2:08:57

you did with the last reallocation you can take a piece out and because there is a meeting again on the

2:09:03

ninth a new resolution singular to this and I will take it back to the mayor's office and to GBHD

2:09:11

and I'm sure you'll get a response you know and and you know I think everyone it wants something to be

2:09:18

done for senior I don't think anyone's a degree of that it's just you guys have process questions and

2:09:23

I understand them and you know and how decisions were made correct yes so so I will I will

2:09:29

communicate that back and you know or I'm sure the staff and you know would be able to do that for you

2:09:34

okay right like was there an application process if there was what was on the application what

2:09:40

requirements did I have to meet in order to say they get the whole 250 thousand dollars and if there

2:09:47

was an application process what what were the dates that it went out that other senior programming

2:09:53

entities are able to apply for it it just there's there's so many questions on I don't mean to bombard you

2:10:00

with all of them but I think that's what the application process that I'm aware and I think this is the

2:10:05

part this is alluded to back when you were doing this with all the things because we there wasn't a

2:10:10

whole group of people came to work for the city to help administer all of these additional things right

2:10:17

I thought we were they just the auditing portion because we did hire two project managers were there

2:10:22

they were the project manager yeah but it's an extra it's an extra 30 million dollars of projects not

2:10:28

counting the other 20 that went towards parks and erect and I'm just saying that personnel issue

2:10:36

is how can you effectively administer and sometimes it's you got to delegate correctly no but you've

2:10:43

also have to have if you don't know people you have to find a way that ministers the simplest so

2:10:47

you can actually account for the money on the other side so I was pointing out earlier to Mr. Jones

2:10:52

our office back in 2007 when I bought that 38 numbered contracts for the city of Harris but we're

2:10:59

up to like 240 contracts for the year of 2024 that means the difference of that every one of those is

2:11:07

managed by a manager in the department right and so their responsibilities as the city is expanded

2:11:13

what it does that and it's not just us it's the way government became with technology more and more

2:11:18

and more things come and there's a lot of things that get done in the city that didn't used to get done

2:11:24

in the city and I just wanted to say something about once again about the spirit of the

2:11:36

Heinz senior center and doing service work this is not for us a gacha moment for any in any way

2:11:45

shape or form this is about finding no I'm just this is me telling you what I have to say about

2:11:53

how we operate we are in the business of providing services to seniors and I hope that you understand

2:12:03

that that is what we want to do and that's all seniors in the city of Harrisburg you need to hear

2:12:11

this okay this comes from a place when you provide services it comes from a place of love and

2:12:15

compassion it is and that's what we do and so you know we put aside the other kinds of issues that

2:12:25

might exist a and b we will be able to provide any information that you ask for around programs

2:12:35

and services because our job is to be as transparent and open as possible we want to see

2:12:44

this city improve absolutely we're in agreement so again that's why I was going to make a motion to

2:12:52

separate this from first of all from this that it's involved in right now and we will absolutely have

2:12:58

an opportunity to do that's fine thank you very much thank you and I just want to make note that

2:13:05

um this isn't questions that we're asking particular just at the high senior center we've asked

2:13:11

these process questions as far as the ARP money about every program including the bridge housing

2:13:16

program uh Christian churches united um and back in september we asked this process question

2:13:24

and then line we got about the high senior center is the high and smithor senior center is the only

2:13:28

senior center in the city of Harrisburg providing social cultural and health related services to those

2:13:34

60 plus the center has not been fully rehab since his inception the facility is in critical need

2:13:40

of full renovation they will receive $250,000 so it's not that we haven't asked these questions before

2:13:47

just we haven't got the full answer to them as the president of ours has noted we have invited

2:13:53

at michael oory robber tear several times so we can have this full discussion uh those conversations

2:13:58

were not had um in front of council and so um now that it's time for the stand in front of us

2:14:04

without the questions being asked I don't think we feel confident in just um making that decision um

2:14:09

I think the the residents deserve a full discussion and public about it so I think I think that

2:14:14

Kano is going to wrap that up unless anyone has any questions or comments I do all right thank you

2:14:20

guys president green and I just want to chime in here as an advocate for the hot senior high and center

2:14:30

you know um I work out in the community I work as a nurse I work with seniors throughout the entire

2:14:37

community and over the years and particularly um during the covid season the high and senior center

2:14:48

was open and serving food serving the seniors I remember uh there was uh oven the oven there wasn't

2:14:56

working but they were still there serving the seniors um the ones that came to the facility um so

2:15:07

I just know that whenever the seniors are going out the ones that I work with and I'm around seniors

2:15:16

all the time because that's what I do um outside of here I work with the senior citizen population

2:15:24

and they're going to the high and center uh the other senior center councilwoman just

2:15:31

appointed information during covid the high and senior center was passing out males and

2:15:35

collaboration with the police department the senior center so wasn't open the doors were unopened

2:15:40

it was an outside on pickup initiative I went there personally um during that time councilman

2:15:48

Rodriguez I went there personally myself no I mean I worked there with them I was

2:15:53

Blake Lynch I was in charge of the solar all the time because again I am I have a home care

2:15:59

thank you great um seniors and I want to just advocate to say that they were open the entire time they

2:16:09

had thank you for clarifying both of you we need to move on okay thank you president bours for letting

2:16:16

me speak but I want to emphasize that they had food there okay thank you we have to move on council

2:16:23

they've been always serving the community why did you just want you to know that they are there I don't

2:16:28

know about we do know that okay but we need to move on right now thank you we have two other things we

2:16:34

have to discuss tonight so we we need to keep moving thank you I suppose this is the part where I make

2:16:42

a motion to move back in a session so move thank you we're resuming our legislative session before us we

2:16:51

have resolution 77 of 2024 Mr. Truesdale because you please read it into the record again resolution 77

2:17:00

2024 a resolution approving the seventh proposed 2024 budget reallocation in the form of technical

2:17:06

corrections and confirming the award of certain available general fund program dollars to senior

2:17:11

programming thank you council members are there any questions comments amendments

2:17:16

yeah I want to make a motion to amend bill 77 striking I don't know how to say this because it's yes I'm

2:17:29

striking and here in this resolution I'm reading it as resolution 17 is that how I'm just trying to

2:17:36

make sure I get that language correct so I think it's it's I'm set to accomplish what you would ask

2:17:42

councilman I think you just move to strike the last two warehouses on page one of the resolution

2:17:47

okay I I didn't know the language and that the conclusion be amended so I was strike to

2:17:57

um I will make a motion to strike the last two warehouses and removing the allocation

2:18:06

for senior programming from resolution 77 goodness this is a lot is there second second thank you

2:18:19

there's a motion on the table to strike the result clause removing the senior programming funding allocation

2:18:36

ready no I'm just repeating it before we vote is there any discussion on the amendment I'll simply say that

2:18:45

from my perspective I don't think this is something personally against high and senior center I don't

2:18:49

think anyone here doubts the work that they do and the asset they are to this community it's about

2:18:54

having a discussion with the department as we've been requesting for a while just so we know the

2:19:00

process of how things worked and ensure that the the funding was fairly um the opportunity was

2:19:08

fairly given to all organizations in the city that provide senior programming because when we made

2:19:13

this resolution this allocation when we were doing the ARPA funds we wanted to make for sure we

2:19:18

didn't specifically name organizations so that it opened it up to other senior serving organizations

2:19:24

that might not often get funding because as we know the city has given funding to hide senior center

2:19:29

plenty times before and so we just want to open it up to all senior programs so that's just my only

2:19:34

comment thank you any other comments or discussion oh yes madam president I agree with madam vice

2:19:41

president it's the same thing we act with downtown daily bread when we allocated with ccu that

2:19:46

million dollars just acts of clarity and how they came to that decision no no no no my nothing against

2:19:54

what they do and we are positive with the service they provide for the seniors we just are aware

2:20:00

that there are other senior you know divisions that can also assist so instead of just putting all

2:20:06

of our eggs in one basket we're just trying to ensure that we can reach as many senior citizens

2:20:10

possible that's all thank you any further comments thank you president bower's I was just curious

2:20:18

as to where are the other senior citizens I mean I know they're out there but I have yet to see them

2:20:25

come in front of council over the last few years I haven't seen anyone except

2:20:32

Heinz Center so I don't know what very I miss on that.

2:20:37

Pleading of senior citizens around in the city of Harrisburg if you're speaking to other centers or

2:20:44

other senior serving organizations I don't know but this would have been their opportunity yeah exactly

2:20:52

right I did share this okay well is there any further discussion any questions okay

2:20:59

mr. Truzel can you please call the vote on the amendment.

2:21:03

Miss Daniels

2:21:05

miss

2:21:07

green or misdavis yes miss green yes mr. Jones yay miss rolls yes mr. Rodriguez yes on the amendment

2:21:20

miss bower's yes the amendment passes by vote is 7 to 0 thank you

2:21:27

so we have to vote on the amended version you know it's a resolution that your 10 is plain

2:21:37

on the record. Got it thanks so resolution 78 of 2024 mr. Truzel could you please read it into the record

2:21:50

resolution 78 2024 a resolution authorizing the city of Harrisburg to negotiate and

2:21:55

enter into a professional services contract with Steve Zimmerman to provide access and service of

2:22:00

the city's historical mainframe programming operations and related services in the bureau of

2:22:05

information technology. Thank you resolution 78 of 2024 will move to the administration committee

2:22:13

resolution 79 of 2024 mr. Truzel could you please read it into the record.

2:22:18

Resolution 79 2024 a resolution authorizing the city of Harrisburg to negotiate and enter into a

2:22:24

domestic animal protective services agreement with the Humane Society of Harrisburg area to

2:22:29

provide services to the city of Harrisburg's animal control program. Thank you resolution 79 of 2024

2:22:36

will move to the public safety committee. Resolution 81 of 2024 mr. Truzel could you please read it

2:22:44

into the record. Resolution 81 resolution 80 81 I want to move the rest before we suspend the rules and

2:22:54

further our discussion. My apologies resolution 81 2024 a resolution approving the preliminary

2:23:00

slash final land consolidation and land development plan submitted by Amber Brelle representing

2:23:06

Latino connection foundation to consolidate three parcels 1001 north 18th street 1800 bowestreet

2:23:13

and an unaddressed parcel and develop a four-story 48 unit residential building with associated site

2:23:19

and access improvements. Thank you resolution 81 of 2024 will move to the community and economic

2:23:25

development committee resolution 82 of 2024 mr. Truzel could you please read it into the record.

2:23:32

Resolution 82 2024 a resolution approving the preliminary slash final land development plan for

2:23:38

three 15 north front streets submitted by Vernon Jones of front street loft LLC to convert the

2:23:44

existing office building into an eight unit apartment building featuring six one bedroom units and two

2:23:50

two bedroom units with two units designated as affordable units along with associated improvements.

2:23:56

Thank you resolution 82 of 2024 will move to the community and economic development committee.

2:24:02

Resolution 83 of 2024 mr. Truzel could you please read it into the record. Resolution 83 2024

2:24:10

a resolution authorizing the city of Harrisburg to negotiate and enter into a collection agreement

2:24:15

with the Harrisburg school district for the collection of the business privilege and mercantile tax

2:24:20

and then amusement tax for the 2025 tax year. Thank you resolution 83 of 2024 will move to the

2:24:27

budget and finance committee. Going back to resolution 80 of 2024 mr. Truzel could you please read it

2:24:36

into the record. Resolution 80 2024 a resolution authorizing the submission of a Pennsylvania local

2:24:43

share assessment grant application with the acceptance of any resulting award of up to $1 million from

2:24:49

the Commonwealth financing authority to fund renovations of the Martin Luther King Jr. City

2:24:54

government center at 10 north second street Harrisburg PA 17101. Thank you I'll entertain a motion

2:25:03

to suspend the rules for discussion. Is there a second? Second. Thank you. Is there anyone from the

2:25:11

administration to discuss this resolution?

2:25:33

Good evening city council. Good evening. Again yeah. So we're here to discuss the resolution 82 I believe

2:25:54

this is no this is resolution 80. 80 that's what I meant to say 80. Okay there is an 82. All right I'm

2:26:01

sorry. Okay so this would be for the I guess it would be the the finality that wouldn't be this is

2:26:13

I'm good one second. Thank you mr. Palmer. Hey guys sorry sorry so it took good evening and

2:26:23

happy pre Thanksgiving for everybody. So we're applying for a local share grant. It's the statewide

2:26:33

local share grant Pennsylvania statewide. I'm sorry sorry sorry. Is that better? Okay yes sorry. So you

2:26:44

guys know that we apply for Doffin County local share grants all the time. The statewide local grant

2:26:51

um local share grant has only been in business for two years this is the third year so we're going in

2:27:00

for the third year. We went in last year for money to renovate the first floor of the MLK building

2:27:10

including this built this these chambers um and the bathrooms and all the ADA stuff the the ceiling

2:27:20

that we were allowed to apply for was million dollars so we applied for that and they gave us 400

2:27:26

so now we're going back for the next 600 and we've been we've been told sorry. I'm not sure.

2:27:36

We've been told our best chance of getting the rest of the funding that we really need up to the

2:27:42

hundred million dollar sorry wow wouldn't that be great. Up to the million dollars threshold would be

2:27:48

just go ahead and ask for the next 600 million. I know next time I speak raw humility and mentions

2:27:58

so that's what we're doing um so we have the seam scoop we have the same cost estimate we have the same

2:28:09

engineering you know drawings so that's what this says. Okay thank you I have two questions before I

2:28:18

open the floor to my colleagues this this particular grant is offered through DCD is that correct?

2:28:25

Okay and what is the deadline for this application? Saturday. Oh Saturday okay thank you. I'll now

2:28:34

open the floor to my colleagues who may have some additional questions I'll begin with councilwoman

2:28:38

Davis any questions? No questions at this time. Okay Vice President Green any questions? I don't have

2:28:44

any questions for you but the the millions and hundreds of millions sound like a better number.

2:28:50

Thank you councilwoman Rawls any questions? Good evening thank you for being here both of you happy

2:28:56

early Thanksgiving festivities. Not don't have any questions. Thank you councilman Rodriguez any questions?

2:29:03

Just wanted to know was there probably not but was there any way to get this in front of us a little bit

2:29:08

earlier um just saying hey Saturday that's a little stringent? No 100% usually right so so we applied for

2:29:16

this first round for us for the first round we applied last summer and in July we got a response

2:29:27

like hey we might give you guys money but we need to answer all the other different questions and I was

2:29:33

actually like that was that that was the weekend that for the thing went out with the internet went out

2:29:40

did you guys remember that? Yeah so that and I was supposed to be on vacation whatever uh so we spent we

2:29:48

Dave Debbie we heard and myself that whole week answering their questions and we only got the response

2:29:58

and the award agreement and announcement um about four weeks ago and then the new uh the new

2:30:09

application opened I don't know if it's always going to be that way but again because it's such a new

2:30:15

application and look at such a new program it may be that way they just kind of be like you know we'll

2:30:23

hear about last year's award three or four weeks before we hear about this year's award. When did

2:30:30

DCED announce this round? Yeah um I can get you the I can send you the award letter that would that

2:30:37

would be great um and of course everything you do for the cities appreciated and you know

2:30:41

when you brought in is also you know much needed for the city it's just we were already in just

2:30:46

a stress stage you know to have to disseminate this and decide like we need it now just you know it's

2:30:52

a bit difficult and as you're aware it's always going to look bad on council because the media is

2:30:56

always going to read council fails to act right so just trying to be a straight shooter here that's all I

2:31:01

have thank you thank you councilman Jones any questions thank you no questions okay thank you uh thank you

2:31:09

uh I'll entertain a motion to resume our legislative session so move um this is like thank you so

2:31:16

before us we have resolution 80 of 2024 Mr. Truzele could you please read it one final time

2:31:22

resolution 80 2024 a resolution authorizing the submission of a Pennsylvania local share assessment

2:31:28

grant application and the acceptance of any resulting award of up to one million dollars from the

2:31:32

Commonwealth financing authority to fund renovations of the Martin Luther King Jr. City Government Center

2:31:38

at 10 North Second Street Harrisburg P.A. 17101 thank you council members are there any final questions

2:31:45

comments or concerns related to resolution 80 of 2024 just for clarity Madam President

2:31:53

and this is totally different than what was already done to the lobby area correct

2:31:59

yes uh so that this is uh I guess it'd be a large drop in the bucket for the total project for the first floor

2:32:06

okay thank you can you just also can you could not you could not can you speak into the microphone please

2:32:13

thank you we were not able to apply for this round until we knew what we got in the last round

2:32:22

because they the program specifically does not allow us to start work on certain programs certain

2:32:30

parts of the project so we actually we actually couldn't do anything until we knew we were getting from

2:32:37

the last round I don't understand that I understand that what I mean is there was already work done

2:32:43

I'm just trying to find out is this yep yep yeah but to answer your question yeah absolutely this

2:32:52

this is not the same work as well as something previously thank you okay any other questions comments

2:32:58

or concerns okay seeing and hearing no Mr. Truzele could you please call the vote Miss Davis

2:33:05

yes miss Green yes Mr. Jones yeah Miss Rose yes Mr. Rodriguez yes Miss Bowers yes resolution 80 2024 passes by

2:33:18

about a 6-0 thank you next we have resolution 84 of 2024 Mr. Truzele could you please call or excuse me

2:33:28

could you please read the resolution into the record resolution 84 2024 a resolution authorizing the

2:33:36

submission of a Pennsylvania local share assessment grant application of up to one million dollars on

2:33:41

behalf of an in conjunction with the Capito area Greenbell Association to fund the reallocation

2:33:47

or the relocation of the Greenbell in South Harrisburg thank you I will entertain a motion to

2:33:53

suspend the rules for discussion is there a second second thank you miss Valmer and

2:34:04

I believe Mr. Hill's okay did not he was participating

2:34:24

hello again if you wouldn't mind providing an overview from your perspective of the resolution yes thank

2:34:34

you and we do appreciate council bringing it up and and we appreciate and understand the tight

2:34:39

timeline as you are aware our tight timeline is because we've only recently begun to get a clear

2:34:47

engineering view of what our costs were going to be at the work session meeting we indicated that

2:34:54

estimate estimated cost for the relocation in the configurations that we're studying is going to be

2:35:01

somewhere between 250 and and yeah 2.5 and 3 million dollars and so what we've done with our engineers

2:35:10

when we found that this grant funding round was available was to retool the work they

2:35:17

were doing so we can phase the project and then parse out the the initial piece into about a million

2:35:23

dollar project it's actually about closer to 1.2 but we would be raising the additional funds to

2:35:30

meet that total cost city's been very cooperative with us in helping facilitate putting the grant

2:35:37

application together we have folks who are part of our board and part of our volunteer crew who have

2:35:44

a significant expertise and experience in state grants and that's dcdpenn.dcdcnr and others and so

2:35:52

we've been working with the city staff over the last week and a half two weeks to get this prepared

2:35:57

in front of you tonight. Okay thank you. I'd same question as bomber this is through dcd and the

2:36:06

deadline is Saturday as well. Yep that's correct. Okay thank you I'll open the floor against my

2:36:11

colleagues who may have questions for either of you. I'll begin with councilman Jones any questions.

2:36:17

Thank you president. No questions. Okay councilman Rodriguez any questions. No questions thank you.

2:36:23

Councilwoman Ross any questions. I don't have any questions just going for it you know making sure

2:36:28

the community's involved in the reconstruction of this so it is done safely is done with their

2:36:36

thoughts and with them in mind that that would be my only comment but no questions thank you. Thank you

2:36:43

Vice President Green any questions. I don't have any questions for you thank you. Councilwoman Davis any

2:36:49

questions. No questions. Thank you. I will entertain a motion to resume our legislative session

2:36:57

is there a second? Thank you. So before us we have resolution 84 of 2024. Mr. Truzel could you please

2:37:05

read it one final time. Resolution 84 2024 resolution authorizing the submission of a Pennsylvania

2:37:12

local share assessment grant application of up to one million dollars on behalf of an

2:37:16

conjunction with the capillary Greenbell Association to fund the relocation of the Greenbell in south

2:37:23

Harrisburg. Thank you councilmembers are there any final questions comments or concerns.

2:37:29

I just want to say I wish best of luck on the project and you know sky's the limit thank you. Okay any further

2:37:38

questions comments or concerns. Seeing and hearing them Mr. Truzel could you please call the vote.

2:37:43

Miss Davis. Yes. Miss Green. Yes. Mr. Jones. Yeah. Miss Rose. Yes. Mr. Rodriguez. Yes. Miss Bowers. Yes.

2:37:56

Resolution 84 2024 passes by voted 6 to 0. Thank you. Our final resolution this evening is

2:38:04

resolution 85 of 2024. Mr. Truzel could you please read it into the record. Resolution 85 2024.

2:38:12

Resolution authorizing the city of Harrisburg submission of a revision request to the department of

2:38:18

community and economic development to reallocate certain funds between previously approved activities

2:38:24

under a grant program contract. Thank you all entertain a motion to suspend the rules for discussion.

2:38:30

No move. Is there second? Second. Thank you. Miss Volmer if you wouldn't mind sharing the revision

2:38:40

request does need it for this? Yes. And I would ask Kevin Sanders.

2:39:10

The play around.

2:39:37

Okay are we ready?

2:39:40

And, Madam President, my chair, frame this a little bit on the legal side.

2:39:44

Okay.

2:39:45

So, in the many federal programs that came out of COVID, there was one that was a CDBG

2:39:53

program to the state who was giving out statewide money.

2:39:56

We don't normally are not eligible for that because we are a direct recipient of CDBG

2:40:01

money.

2:40:02

But they had a pot that they were on a timeline to expand and they opened it up to people

2:40:08

that aren't normally eligible.

2:40:10

I think we applied for something like 18 million, got 13 million in the grant.

2:40:16

But in this particular program, because they're restricted by the federal government,

2:40:21

there were five awards made and connected to each other in this application.

2:40:26

The only things eligible for this money to be used on are those five programs.

2:40:31

So why this is a revision award, which is a process, DCD has for other normal sub-recipients

2:40:38

they give to, is it has to somehow stay in the program.

2:40:41

Since we have four other programs, that is where the legally, we are allowed to ask to move

2:40:46

it to, not into a brand new project.

2:40:51

So that's just the legal framework.

2:40:53

And the risk is, and they insist that these ED, they cannot change the December 31, 2025 deadline

2:41:00

to spend the money.

2:41:03

So that's what they have insisted upon.

2:41:05

So we either, we either forfeit the million, five million for the Jackson Lake pool because

2:41:12

of dispute over legal title to the land or we make an effort to move it.

2:41:18

So it's really, it's not a great set of options, but that's the legal place because our options

2:41:22

are forfeit or move it into a program they've already approved.

2:41:27

And so that is the mechanism they've made available legally to the city to apply for.

2:41:31

We've never done it before.

2:41:33

So just to note, the activities approved for grant funding under the program included

2:41:38

improvements to the Jackson Lake pool, the seventh and red nurse sports park, Wilson Park,

2:41:44

Gorgas playground and reservoir park.

2:41:50

Any further discussion or commentary from the administration?

2:41:55

Okay, guess not.

2:41:59

I'll open the floor to questions from my colleagues.

2:42:03

I'll begin with Councilman Jones.

2:42:05

Any questions?

2:42:06

Yes, thank you, President Bowers.

2:42:08

So my question is, and as it regards to Jackson Lake, from understanding you guys want to take

2:42:19

five million dollars and move it over to the pool and equipment area where there's already

2:42:26

a project that's an existence where there's money already sitting at.

2:42:30

Am I saying I'm not clear on that right now?

2:42:35

Go ahead.

2:42:36

I don't, if I heard you correct and I was getting late, I heard you say that there's going

2:42:40

to put it where there's already the pool.

2:42:41

They're taking away from the pool.

2:42:43

Right, that's what I'm talking about, red.

2:42:46

But we're moving the five million where you're asking to move the five million.

2:42:49

There's already a existing project with money already there.

2:42:54

Correct, not a pool.

2:42:55

I apologize.

2:42:58

But that, so I don't know if it's going to be Ms. Ross or Mr. Baker or Mr. Sanders that

2:43:06

can answer this question.

2:43:08

Being that this money is going to be moved over there and there's more existing money already

2:43:13

there for a project already.

2:43:15

What do you plan to do with this money?

2:43:18

Or do you plan to use it for the existing project, which I don't think you should because

2:43:23

there's money already there for that?

2:43:25

I just want to know what are you guys plan to do with this money?

2:43:29

Okay, to maybe clarify one big thing.

2:43:34

Based on the timeline, we will not be able to complete Jackson Lake.

2:43:40

Hence why we are here today.

2:43:42

We're here to take that money that was allocated for Jackson Lake and make sure we don't give

2:43:50

it all back.

2:43:51

We're going to try to put it into our existing projects, which Neil just provided that.

2:43:55

That's what I just asked.

2:43:57

There's already money in the place where we're taking this money to move it to.

2:44:01

So I'm saying, how do you and do you intend to use it?

2:44:04

Okay, how?

2:44:05

All right, so the seventh and the red there, just some of these are summary.

2:44:10

We're going to potentially expand the lighting or the stadium lights.

2:44:15

Because we'll be getting a better set of stadium lights than what may come in on bid.

2:44:21

The pervillion, we're going to get a second pervillion at seventh and red.

2:44:25

We may increase the restrooms.

2:44:28

We will have a more functional dug out structure at seventh and red.

2:44:34

The possibility of larger bleachers, increasing trees around the site, increasing netting around

2:44:42

the baseball softball field, potentially additional restrooms, additional fitness equipment,

2:44:49

enhance the press box and the sound system.

2:44:52

The sound system was not part of the original scope.

2:44:57

Wilson Park, maybe more fitness equipment.

2:45:00

Excuse me, Mrs. Simon, just before you go on, this specific allocation, and I just want to

2:45:07

make sure that I'm clear and that we are.

2:45:10

Whether it's being asked to be moved to, what are those projects?

2:45:16

So those projects are seventh and red in the ball field.

2:45:19

Wilson Park, Reservoir Park, Splashpad, Previllion, Restroom, Walkway, and Menonies, and Gorgas

2:45:26

playground.

2:45:29

So now, there's already money there for those projects, correct?

2:45:33

Yes.

2:45:34

Okay, now when you take this five million and move it over there, what are you going to do

2:45:40

with that money?

2:45:41

I was just explaining that.

2:45:45

So I thought you could.

2:45:46

I thought you could.

2:45:47

I'm not explaining that.

2:45:48

Okay, because so one of the things that Mr. Grover said is that you can't do anything new

2:45:53

has to be existing.

2:45:54

You just added some new things inside of there.

2:45:56

Something that wasn't there.

2:45:57

These are enhancements to our scope of work.

2:46:02

We're not trying to change the footprint.

2:46:05

We were actually changing some of the things that came in.

2:46:09

We would change the Previllion type.

2:46:11

We would go with a more expensive Previllion.

2:46:13

We would add things to it that we weren't currently going to.

2:46:17

That's where I got.

2:46:18

Okay.

2:46:19

That's why I'm asking you because when he said that you can't use it for anything new and then

2:46:23

you were saying there was something new.

2:46:25

Right.

2:46:26

So continue.

2:46:27

So at Reservoir Park in particular, we are behind schedule on that project.

2:46:32

One of the new tasks is going to be to potentially enhance the slash pad of many.

2:46:39

We are currently going to get.

2:46:41

We have not gone out to do the equipment RFP as of yet.

2:46:45

We haven't done the Previllion aspects as well in the rest room.

2:46:49

So some of these things are going to incur more costs.

2:46:53

We already had a change order and triggered at Reservoir Park as it pertains to keeping

2:46:58

the Previllion.

2:46:59

We don't know all the costs for that.

2:47:01

That was not part of the original numbers.

2:47:05

So back to Wilson Park, we are actually more or less just checking to see if we can get a

2:47:11

larger place structure.

2:47:12

We may not actually be able to do that.

2:47:14

We may not actually be able to spend all $5 million.

2:47:17

That is a reality.

2:47:18

We're probably not going to spend that $5 million.

2:47:21

We have not taken any other projects out to bid so we don't actually know how much certain

2:47:26

things are going to really cost.

2:47:29

Whereas at 7th of around, or gorgeous, Wilson Park, we did recently receive the equipment

2:47:34

bids.

2:47:35

Some of them are lower than what were originally budgeted.

2:47:39

But with this change, we are in the process of doing some of the stuff that I've suggested.

2:47:44

We're looking into these things to enhance things.

2:47:48

We haven't bought anything.

2:47:49

All right, so thank you for the clarity.

2:47:52

This is the reason why I get to ask questions.

2:47:54

So I'm clear and we're clear on it.

2:47:56

So the other thing is, what took so long to get that we have to move this money over

2:48:02

here now before it gets clawed back?

2:48:05

What took it so long for it to, why are we at this point?

2:48:09

I've having to move it somewhere else before we lose it.

2:48:14

We was hoping that, we was hoping that the school district would come up in the city of

2:48:22

Harrisburg, we'll come up with a collaboration agreement.

2:48:26

Okay, all right.

2:48:27

Thank you.

2:48:28

That's what we wanted.

2:48:29

I think I know we're at.

2:48:36

Councilman Rodriguez, any questions?

2:48:40

No, I understand.

2:48:41

Thank you.

2:48:42

Thank you.

2:48:43

Councilwoman Rawls, any questions?

2:48:45

Thank you.

2:48:46

Good evening, again, to everybody.

2:48:47

Thank you for bearing with us.

2:48:48

I just wanted to point out a few things, especially with what we've been doing.

2:48:51

I'm actually with Wilson Park in this extra $5 million that could possibly go over into

2:49:00

helping with the four parks that are on the list to be renovated.

2:49:04

One of the things a resident has said to me, and I think maybe I could have spoke to you

2:49:08

about it, Deputy Rawls on the phone, but there when there were the meetings about the parks

2:49:14

and what residents wanted a huge thing that at least four residents reached out to me too.

2:49:20

And I hope that we can get it with this extra $5 million as a kitchen at Wilson Park, which

2:49:28

they said that was something they really wanted, so they could go down there, they could have

2:49:32

picnics and cookouts, and they saw it at other parks, and they wanted that third part, which

2:49:38

I don't think is unfair statements, so I just want to say it again.

2:49:43

I don't remember what else was on that list that they had, but that was a big thing in exercise

2:49:48

equipment, which you did mention, so I know that's going there, but a small kitchen

2:49:52

that was something that they really said they were pushing for at Wilson Park.

2:49:58

Another thing for me that I'm always going to say, because I always push for it, I probably

2:50:02

said it to Director Baker a thousand times, and I said it to you, Deputy Rawls a thousand

2:50:07

times, is some type of sprinkler system at the parks.

2:50:11

I know we're talking about the splash pad at Reservoir Park, but then we have these other

2:50:14

two parks that are far from Reservoir.

2:50:18

To have some type of themed, I don't care if it's one sprinkler that looks like an octopus

2:50:23

with water coming out of it, I mean, it would enhance our playgrounds immensely, and for

2:50:31

people who can't make it to the pool, this is a way for them to have a cool down system,

2:50:35

a way for them to have family time, and I see them doing it in other cities, and I know

2:50:41

we can do it in our city.

2:50:43

I know there's a thing with recyclable water or tapping, and there's all these things, but

2:50:47

I know that they're doing it at other cities where they are doing recyclable water.

2:50:51

They're helping with, I think it's called a water basin, and I could be incorrect when

2:50:56

I say that word, but I just think that when we have this type of money, being able to put

2:51:04

it somewhere that is lasting and that we can keep up with is just a great idea.

2:51:09

So I'm going to say the sprinklers again, I'm going to say every time I get a chance,

2:51:13

and I hope that the residents at Wilson Park, that gave you their suggestions and showed

2:51:18

up to every meeting, at least a compromise and get at least one thing on their list that

2:51:23

they would like.

2:51:24

I'm going for the kitchenette, but that's just my two cents.

2:51:28

Thank you.

2:51:29

Thank you.

2:51:30

Vice President Green, any questions?

2:51:32

Thank you very much.

2:51:33

Thank you guys for sticking around.

2:51:34

I don't have any questions for you.

2:51:37

If you could just provide us the list of upgrades that you were reading off, if you could just

2:51:40

email them to us, I'd appreciate that.

2:51:44

Thank you, Councilwoman Davis, any questions?

2:51:47

Thank you, President Bowers.

2:51:48

No questions for me.

2:51:50

Okay, thank you.

2:51:51

I will entertain a motion to resume our legislative session.

2:51:56

Is there a second?

2:51:58

Second.

2:51:59

Thank you.

2:52:00

So we have before us, Resolution 85 of 2024, Mr. Trusdale, could you read it one final

2:52:06

time please?

2:52:07

Resolution 85, 2024.

2:52:10

A resolution authorizing the City of Harrisburg's submission of a revision request to the Department

2:52:15

of Community and Economic Development to reallocate certain funds between previously approved activities

2:52:21

under a grant program contract.

2:52:24

Thank you, Councilmembers.

2:52:25

Are there any final questions, comments or concerns?

2:52:29

Seeing and hearing them, Mr. Trusdale, could you please call the vote?

2:52:32

Ms. Davis?

2:52:33

Yes.

2:52:34

Ms. Green?

2:52:35

Yes.

2:52:36

Mr. Jones?

2:52:37

Yay.

2:52:38

Ms. Rose?

2:52:39

Yes.

2:52:40

Mr. Rodriguez?

2:52:41

Yes.

2:52:42

Ms. Bowers?

2:52:43

Yes.

2:52:44

Resolution 85, 2024, passes by vote of 6-0.

2:52:51

Thank you.

2:52:53

Is there any old business council members?

2:52:56

I realize I failed to mention we were delayed in beginning our meeting this evening because

2:53:01

we had an executive session to discuss personnel matters.

2:53:08

Any new business?

2:53:10

I know I have scheduling and so does vice president greens.

2:53:15

I'll start on Monday, December 2, 2024.

2:53:19

A work session will be held beginning at 5.30 pm on Monday, December 9, 2019.

2:53:26

A legislative session will be held beginning at 6 pm.

2:53:35

Thank you.

2:53:36

As far as the 2025 proposed budget hearings, the hearings will be held December 3, December

2:53:43

4, December 10, and December 11.

2:53:47

Each meeting will be held here in Council chambers and will begin at 5.30.

2:53:51

The budget agendas are already online so you can see the different departments and when

2:53:55

they present to our council members.

2:53:58

I know it's a short turnaround with the holiday being Thursday, but if we could try to get

2:54:02

most of our questions submitted by Friday close of business.

2:54:06

If not Sunday and then Monday, if we can just keep rolling in so that the department heads

2:54:11

have time to get their answers together and get them back to us.

2:54:16

If you have any generic questions, I hate to call them generic questions but you know

2:54:19

the questions that we tend to ask every year such as how are you doing your 2024 goals

2:54:25

or your 2025 goals, which are staffing rates, those things, if we can get those to them

2:54:30

right away that way they can start working on those that will be appreciated, especially

2:54:34

with the holiday falling right in the middle of the beginning of things.

2:54:38

That's everything.

2:54:39

Thank you.

2:54:40

Thank you.

2:54:41

Any other new business council members?

2:54:43

Yes, Madam President, I just wanted to wish everyone a happy Thanksgiving and if you're

2:54:48

going away, have safe travels and just remember we're one city or moving towards one dream.

2:54:53

I want to enjoy your holidays.

2:54:54

Thank you.

2:54:55

Thank you.

2:54:56

Any other comments?

2:54:57

New business?

2:54:58

Okay.

2:54:59

Seeing and hearing none, everyone have a very safe and happy Thanksgiving.

2:55:06

The time is 908 pm.

2:55:08

I will entertain the person to adjourn.

2:55:11

Okay.

2:55:12

Thank you.

More transcripts

Explore other videos transcribed with YouTLDR.

Get the TLDR of any YouTube video

Transcribe, summarize, and repurpose videos in 125+ languages — free, no signup required.

Try YouTLDR Free