0:00
Now, the whole thing about, okay, what
0:01
about the eternal destiny of
0:04
the stillborn, the miscarriage, the
0:06
aborted baby, and and we can we can add
0:08
as well, you know, babies that are born
0:10
with with severe mental incapacitation,
0:14
that they'll never actually be able to
0:16
believe, you know, that that sort of
0:18
thing. I put them all in in one, you
0:24
therefore just as sin came into the
0:25
world through one man and death through
0:29
and so death spread to all men because
0:32
all sinned or all sinned, you know, some
0:35
translations will have.
0:37
There you go. Well, this verse has been
0:39
taken for not centuries, but millennia
0:42
in the history of the Christian church,
0:43
and this goes back to the church
0:46
So I'm going to lay this at their feet.
0:49
This verse is used to teach the idea
0:52
all every human being after Adam
0:54
inherited Adam's guilt.
0:59
the the typical articulation of the
1:01
doctrine of original sin.
1:03
>> The question of whether or not babies or
1:05
children who pass away before
1:07
understanding [music] and believing the
1:08
gospel actually go to heaven is a
1:10
longstanding debate within the church
1:11
and [music] between scholars as well.
1:14
And this primarily stems from the
1:15
concept of inherited [music] sin or
1:17
original sin, which links back to Romans
1:19
5:12. We'll touch more deeply on that in
1:22
just a moment. [snorts] The most common
1:24
modern view cites the age of
1:25
accountability. This stems from the
1:27
words of Moses to the rebellious
1:29
generation of Israelites who escaped
1:30
Egypt, [music] that their children would
1:32
inherit the promised land because they
1:34
didn't yet understand good from evil.
1:36
This is found in Deuteronomy 1:39, which
1:38
reads, and as for your little ones who
1:40
you said would become a prey, and your
1:42
children who today have no knowledge of
1:44
good or evil, they shall go in there,
1:46
and to them I will give it, and they
1:50
And this is further reinforced by King
1:51
David's confidence that he'd see his
1:52
deceased infant son again in 2 Samuel
1:56
But now he is dead. Why should I fast?
1:59
Can I bring back again? I shall go to
2:01
him, but he will not return to me.
2:04
However, the traditional Augustinian and
2:06
Calvinist view of total depravity
2:08
surmises that the transgressions of Adam
2:10
and Eve have been subsequently credited
2:12
to all humans and that we're born in an
2:14
immediate state of guilt and sin. This
2:16
view relies on Psalm 51:5 where David
2:19
says, "Behold, I was brought forth in
2:21
iniquity, and in sin did my mother
2:25
The Calvinist view reconciles this by
2:27
what's called regeneration from within.
2:29
This concept states that while infants
2:31
aren't capable of a rational profession
2:33
of faith, the Holy Spirit can work
2:34
invisibly to regenerate and sanctify
2:38
Later reformed theologians like Charles
2:40
Spurgeon argued that all infants who
2:41
pass away are saved and enter heaven
2:43
through Christ's redemptive work.
2:45
Obviously, when we look at this topic
2:47
through the lens of this traditional
2:48
view, something just doesn't add up.
2:50
[snorts] Either the doctrine of total
2:52
depravity breaks down under the weight
2:53
of this exception, or babies are
2:55
carelessly destined for hell.
2:58
So with all this in mind, I want you to
2:59
hear this fascinating clip of Dr.
3:00
Michael Heiser addressing this issue
3:02
because he has a simple but profound
3:04
explanation for it. Let's check it out.
3:07
>> The doctrine of original sin has become
3:09
sort of transformed into the doctrine of
3:12
the transmission of Adam's guilt to all
3:17
The verse never says that Adam's sin,
3:22
the guilt was transferred to other human
3:25
beings. It never says that. Let me read
3:28
Therefore, just as sin came into the
3:31
world through one man, okay, we know who
3:34
that one man is. It's it's Adam, okay,
3:37
and death through sin. So when there was
3:40
sin, then we have, you know, now now
3:42
death is part of the picture.
3:44
And I would say it's human death because
3:46
the rest of the verse is about humans,
3:48
not animals or microbes, okay? Therefore
3:51
or so death spread to all men. Did you
3:56
is what spread to all men, all humans,
4:06
Romans 5:12 is about the transmission of
4:12
Because once Adam and Eve sinned,
4:13
they're driven from the garden. They're
4:15
cut off from the source of life, the
4:17
presence of God, Eden, all that stuff.
4:20
Again, they are now going to die.
4:24
Okay? That that's what God told them.
4:26
It's about death. It's not about the
4:28
transmission of guilt, moral guilt
4:33
Now that makes a huge difference
4:35
you know, if you believe that every
4:37
human being inherits guilt because of
4:40
Adam, well then a baby that gets aborted
4:45
that, you know, isn't in the body of
4:47
Christ or is cut off from Christ, from
4:50
believing in Christ, either because of
4:52
death or again their mental
4:54
incapacitation, they're going to go to
4:57
Now, you know, pastors, you know, people
4:59
who are sensitive to this will will
5:06
not say that. They'll say, oh well, God
5:11
Well, there's no verse for that.
5:13
God loves cute babies, so therefore
5:14
they're in heaven. You know, it it's
5:16
it's bluster. It's contrived. It's made
5:19
up. Or they'll say, well,
5:21
God will make sure that that you don't
5:24
you know, the the death of your
5:26
stillborn child and and and you won't
5:28
remember that it's in hell now.
5:31
Well, again, there's no verse for that.
5:33
But there are lots of verses that talk
5:37
evidence for the fact that we will
5:40
you know, our lives and relationships
5:42
here in this life, in the next life.
5:44
Again, these are contrived answers
5:46
because people are trapped
5:49
by a flawed view of Romans 5:12. I've
5:52
also talked on the blog about how
5:54
this really impacts Jesus. Jesus is a
6:00
He is the son of Adam.
6:02
He's the son of David, you know, who
6:05
So, where does Jesus get off in not
6:08
inheriting Adam's guilt? And everybody,
6:10
oh, the virgin birth, the virgin birth.
6:12
Well, I got news for you. Mary was
6:16
Okay? She was a descendant from Adam,
6:19
Where is the verse that says the sin
6:23
or Adamic guilt flows through
6:29
There is no such verse. These are
6:31
theological inventions.
6:34
Okay? It It also doesn't work to say,
6:35
well, you know, Jesus, you know, was
6:37
just kind of put into the womb by God,
6:40
plopped in there. Well, that's nice.
6:42
Then Paul gets to be wrong in Romans 1:3
6:45
where he says that Christ
6:47
is descended from David according to the
6:51
Okay? Jesus is either human, a
6:54
descendant of Adam, or he's not. Either
6:56
the genealogies are correct or they're
7:01
Okay, they're not lies. They are real.
7:05
But if you're going to take the
7:06
traditional view of Romans 5:12, Jesus
7:09
inherited Adam guilt. Now, the Catholic
7:10
Church saw this problem very clearly.
7:13
And so this is why they invented the
7:15
doctrine that Mary was sinless.
7:19
There's no verse that says that.
7:21
But that gets Mary off the hook and
7:23
therefore it gets Jesus off the hook in
7:25
that thinking, that that theological
7:27
approach. Again, these these are
7:29
contrivances because of the way the
7:32
church fathers specifically, you know, I
7:34
guess Augustine, but he's I mean, he's
7:37
But because of the way they influenced
7:39
the history of the church to think about
7:41
Romans 5:12, and what I'm saying is look
7:43
at the verse. It never refers to guilt
7:48
It's a mortality problem. Now, again, my
7:50
view, and you can go read read the the
7:52
the I'd say read the whole series of
7:55
you know, if if I'm getting if I'm going
7:56
to get emails now that, well, Mike, what
7:58
about where it says that all have sinned
8:00
and come short of the glory of God? And
8:01
well, all those things are true.
8:05
Okay? The biblical view is that guilt
8:08
isn't transmitted to people
8:11
by what someone else does, including
8:14
Okay, we become guilty before God when
8:17
we sin. And every human being is going
8:20
to sin. There is no avoidance of
8:26
will sin. The only exception of this was
8:29
Jesus because he also happened to be
8:32
Okay, not no other human being can say
8:34
that. So all humans, if they're allowed
8:38
will sin against God and will become
8:41
guilty before God. That's why every
8:43
human being needs Christ.
8:46
Now, again, if we think about this a
8:48
little bit more, we have situations, you
8:50
know, you have to define, okay, well,
8:52
what what is sin? You know, does it
8:53
involved, you know, the the act of the
8:55
human will? You know, do you do you, you
8:58
know, have to knowingly rebel against
9:00
God? I would say, yeah, you do.
9:02
You know, and people would would bring
9:03
up sin language in the Old Testament
9:04
like in Leviticus. Hey, go listen to our
9:06
Leviticus series on podcast. The quote
9:08
unquote sins there are about moral, you
9:12
know, not moral impurity, but ritual
9:16
It just people get confused by the
9:18
language of a of a lot of Old Testament
9:20
verses that really don't apply to moral
9:22
transgressions at all.
9:23
To have a moral transgression, you have
9:25
to have an act of the will.
9:27
And an infant that's two days old is not
9:30
is not morally, willfully rebelling
9:33
against the revelation of God in some
9:36
It's just not doing that. So there there
9:40
you know, a biblical theological
9:42
argument to be made for innocence.
9:46
the aborted fetus never sinned.
9:49
Again, the child that's one or two days
9:51
old and and then dies doesn't sin.
9:54
You know, the the the the the the child
9:56
again who is severely, you know,
9:58
mentally incapacitated
10:00
can't exercise, you know,
10:02
the will to to rebel knowingly against
10:06
I'm saying they're innocent. There is
10:09
Now, they don' go to heaven
10:13
they're sinless or innocent as though
10:15
they're good enough. Okay? That is no
10:19
on the basis of any merit of their own
10:22
at all. Period. Zero.
10:26
So what about the fate of the unborn?
10:28
Well, we have to ask ourselves, why do
10:30
people go to hell? Why do they not have
10:32
everlasting life? And the answer to that
10:34
is, well, they've become guilty before
10:38
nothing has, you know, they weren't able
10:40
to participate in the means by which
10:43
that they are forgiven and and and
10:45
you know, joined to Christ. Okay? Well,
10:48
why do people need Christ? Well, again,
10:50
the answer is because they're guilty
10:52
before God and and we know that Christ
10:54
is the only way of salvation.
10:56
Well, how do people again become guilty
10:59
before God? The answer is we sin.
11:04
okay, those who die never having sinned,
11:08
they're in a different category. I think
11:10
with me here. Again, I'm just
11:11
summarizing a very long series of posts
11:15
Everyone at the last day will be raised,
11:19
both the saved and the unsaved. But and
11:22
you read the end of the book of
11:23
Revelation, other passages, this is this
11:25
is crystal clear. Everybody gets raised.
11:27
Some, you know, to eternal life, some to
11:32
Everybody gets raised. Well, of those
11:34
that get get raised, why do
11:37
certain, again, experience damnation?
11:40
They don't have everlasting life. The
11:42
reason is because they were guilty
11:45
They've committed some offense against
11:46
God and that hasn't been taken care of.
11:50
We understand that clearly.
11:52
But if that isn't the case,
11:55
if you're raised at the last day
11:58
and you are not guilty before God, by
12:03
using biblical language here,
12:05
you do not suffer the second death,
12:13
with the presence of God, not because
12:15
you were good, not because you earned
12:19
You have eternal life because of
12:21
Christ's resurrection. That is the only
12:23
reason anyone is raised at all.
12:28
Again, these are I'm just throwing
12:29
together a bunch of biblical statements
12:32
It's because of the resurrection. So,
12:36
I I have met people.
12:38
I have met people who have people in
12:41
where a pastor told them the child you
12:43
lost in stillbirth is in hell.
12:46
And it destroyed their faith.
12:48
I think that's abominable.
12:51
You know, I can honestly look somebody
12:52
in the eye and say, look, your baby
12:55
we you had an abortion, whatever you
12:57
did, your baby is with the Lord, not
13:00
because God makes exceptions,
13:02
not because they're good enough, not
13:04
because they're cute, not even because
13:07
they never had the opportunity to sin.
13:09
They are there because, yeah, they're
13:11
not guilty before God, but they are
13:13
raised with Christ like everyone else.
13:16
It's just that when some are raised, you
13:18
know, then they get, you know,
13:20
Revelation put in the lake of fire and
13:21
others go to be with the Lord. The only
13:23
reason anybody's going to wind up in the
13:25
lake of fire is because their guilt has
13:26
not been taken care of.
13:29
Okay, the innocent don't have guilt.
13:33
Therefore, by definition, they are
13:35
raised with Christ to eternal life.
13:38
Okay, that's what happens to them. That
13:39
is that's the fate of the unborn.
13:42
So, yeah, there is this idea of
13:45
We aren't given a number, and I don't
13:47
think we can be given a number as far as
13:51
You know, you you have to examine what
13:53
what does God view as rebellion against
13:55
him that would incur guilt before him.
13:59
Again, there there's no silver bullet
14:01
answer to that. All that I'm saying is
14:03
that Romans 5:12, which is the reason
14:05
the question even comes up,
14:08
you know, that that that this whole idea
14:12
guilt being transmitted
14:16
to human being on the basis of Romans
14:19
5:12. That that is the proof text for
14:21
the doctrine. Then there are other
14:24
don't you not don't think you're going
14:25
to surprise me with them an email. I
14:28
know all of them. I've commented on all
14:30
of them in this series on Romans 5:12,
14:33
either in the posts or comments to the
14:35
posts. I I'm not missing something here.
14:38
Okay, this is this is something that I
14:41
again, it sounds crazy,
14:43
I think the church has fundamentally
14:49
some tragic consequences for
14:52
people's life circumstances. And not
14:54
only that, it gets you into real
14:55
theological trouble with Jesus,
14:57
you know, being a descendant of Adam.
15:00
You know, other than those things, it's
15:01
it's okay. You know, the traditionally
15:06
you know, it's it's really it's not
15:08
okay. It's a misunderstanding
15:10
that that produces this this question.
15:13
And what I'm saying is
15:16
you don't need to worry about Romans
15:17
5:12 putting aborted babies in danger of
15:21
damnation in hell. They are not guilty
15:24
before God. The verse never says they
15:26
are. Psalm 51, in sin my mother you
15:30
know, conceived me. Well, yeah, we we
15:32
know that the act of intercourse isn't a
15:34
sin. But how about we we we do the just
15:37
like we do in Genesis 1:26, the bet of
15:40
predication and we'll have a grammar
15:43
How about we take the
15:45
predicatory view of the preposition bet
15:48
Okay, as sin or better, you could
15:51
translate the same word in the in the
15:55
My mother conceived me. That's
15:56
absolutely true. Every human being
15:59
will sin. If they if they're allowed to
16:01
live, they will sin.
16:05
Invariably, inevitably, they will sin.
16:09
>> This is a prime example of how doctrines
16:11
can influence the way we read Scripture,
16:13
but it honestly should be the other way
16:15
around. But I also want to read you an
16:17
excerpt from Heiser's article on Romans
16:18
5:12 because he extrapolates these ideas
16:21
even further. Here's the excerpt.
16:23
My view of Romans 5:12 means that
16:25
babies, aborted fetuses, the mentally
16:27
handicapped, and the infant or young
16:29
child unable to believe are not under
16:31
the wrath of God since A, they have not
16:33
inherited guilt from Adam, and B, they
16:36
have not sinned nor can they sin in the
16:39
sense of a moral violation, not a
16:40
violation of ritual purity.
16:43
Despite their moral innocence before God
16:45
though, they will, as will all humans
16:47
unless there is a rapture, suffer death.
16:49
Their moral innocence is also not
16:51
sufficient for eternal life. They need
16:53
something else. They need to be raised
16:54
from the dead, and they will be because
16:56
of Jesus. What do I mean? Let's see what
16:59
Paul says in 1 Corinthians 15:12-28.
17:02
Now if Christ is proclaimed as raised
17:03
from the dead, how can some of you say
17:05
that there is no resurrection of the
17:06
dead? But if there is no resurrection of
17:08
the dead, then not even Christ has been
17:10
raised. And if Christ has not been
17:11
raised, then our preaching is in vain
17:13
and your faith is in vain. We are even
17:15
found to be misrepresenting God because
17:17
we testified about God that he raised
17:19
Christ whom he did not raise if it is
17:21
true that the dead are not raised. For
17:22
if the dead are not raised, not even
17:24
Christ has been raised. And if Christ
17:26
has not been raised, your faith is
17:27
futile and you are still in your sins.
17:30
Then those also who have fallen asleep
17:32
in Christ have perished. If in Christ we
17:34
have hope in this life only, we are of
17:36
all people most to be pitied. But in
17:38
fact, Christ has been raised from the
17:40
dead, the first fruits of those who have
17:41
fallen asleep. For as by a man came
17:43
death, by a man has also come the
17:45
resurrection of the dead. For as in Adam
17:48
all die, so also in Christ shall all be
17:51
made alive. But each in his own order.
17:53
Christ the first fruits, then at his
17:55
coming those who belong to Christ. Then
17:57
comes the end when he delivers the
17:59
kingdom to God the Father after
18:00
destroying every rule and every
18:02
authority and power. For he must reign
18:03
until he has put all his enemies under
18:05
his feet. The last enemy to be destroyed
18:07
is death. For God has put all things in
18:10
subjection under his feet. But when it
18:12
says all things are put in subjection,
18:14
it is plain that he is excepted who put
18:16
all things in subjection under him. When
18:18
all things are subjected to him, then
18:19
the Son himself will also be subjected
18:22
to him who put all things in subjection
18:23
under him, that God may be all in all.
18:26
Let's look first at verse 22. Adam's sin
18:29
resulted in death, just like Romans 5:12
18:32
says. It doesn't say it resulted in
18:34
guilt. And in parallel thought, because
18:36
of Christ's resurrection, all shall be
18:38
raised. Death was conquered by Christ,
18:40
and Christ is the first fruits of the
18:41
resurrection. But what of the other
18:43
language, the eschatological talk of
18:45
resurrection and death? That's
18:47
important, too. The rest of the passage
18:49
summarizes day of the Lord themes found
18:51
in a number of other passages,
18:53
resurrection, judgment, the kingdom,
18:56
We need to unravel this a bit. And be
18:58
warned, what you read here might
18:59
conflict with some popular system of
19:01
eschatology that you've been taught,
19:03
especially if it's a popular
19:04
dispensational variety. Oh well.
19:07
If we turn to Revelation 20, great white
19:09
throne passage, we read of two
19:10
resurrections. Revelation 20 5 and 6.
19:13
Then I saw thrones, and seated on them
19:15
were those to whom the authority to
19:17
judge was committed. Also, I saw the
19:19
souls of those who had been beheaded for
19:20
the testimony of Jesus and for the word
19:22
of God, and those who had not worshipped
19:23
the beast or its image and had not
19:25
received its mark on their foreheads or
19:27
their hands. They came to life and
19:29
reigned with Christ for a thousand
19:30
years. Kaiser interjects here, there's
19:33
resurrection number one.
19:34
The rest of the dead did not come to
19:36
life until the thousand years were
19:37
ended. Now he interjects again, there's
19:39
resurrection number two. This is the
19:41
first resurrection. Another
19:43
interjection. The this refers back to
19:45
the primary focus of the passage, the
19:47
resurrection of the martyr believers.
19:49
Blessed and holy is the one who shares
19:51
in the first resurrection. Over such the
19:53
second death has no power, but they will
19:55
be priests of God and of Christ, and
19:57
they will reign with him for a thousand
20:00
What do we make of this? Well, the first
20:01
resurrection regards martyr believers,
20:03
martyred prior to the end of the
20:05
millennial kingdom. This resurrection is
20:07
only believers. As such, the second
20:09
death, an explanation of which is coming
20:11
in the passage, has no effect on them.
20:13
That's why they are blessed. The second
20:15
resurrection is general, including both
20:17
unbelievers and believers. Revelation 20
20:20
11 through 15 reads, Then I saw a great
20:23
white throne and him who was seated on
20:24
it. From his presence, earth and sky
20:26
fled away and no place was found for
20:28
them. And I saw the dead, great and
20:30
small, standing before the throne, and
20:32
books were opened. Then another book was
20:34
opened, which is the book of life. And
20:36
the dead were judged by what was written
20:38
in the books according to what they had
20:39
done. And the sea gave up the dead who
20:41
were in it. Death and Hades gave up the
20:43
dead who were in them, and they were
20:44
judged, each one of them, according to
20:46
what they had done. Then death and Hades
20:49
were thrown into the lake of fire. This
20:51
is the second death, the lake of fire.
20:53
And if anyone's name was not found
20:54
written in the book of life, he was
20:56
thrown into the lake of fire.
20:58
At this second resurrection, the reason
20:59
that some suffer the second death, the
21:01
lake of fire, is because of the sins
21:03
they committed. This takes place,
21:04
according to the text, after the
21:06
millennial kingdom. The rest of the dead
21:08
did not come to life until the thousand
21:09
years were ended. This appears to be the
21:11
resurrection in Daniel 12:1-2 since the
21:14
book of life is mentioned and since
21:16
believers and unbelievers are both
21:18
Looking at the passage, we read first
21:20
that books, plural, were opened, but
21:22
then another book, singular, the book of
21:23
life was opened. The dead were judged by
21:26
the plural books according to what they
21:27
had done, books that recorded their
21:29
sins, a record of their guilt before
21:31
God. That record was the basis of
21:33
suffering in the second death, hell.
21:35
These people were still in their sins
21:37
and trespasses, as Paul would say.
21:39
However, all that was necessary to avoid
21:41
the second death was to have one's name
21:43
written in the book of life. All that
21:44
mattered was inclusion in the book. If
21:46
you had sinned and had never received
21:48
Christ, you were in the bad book. If
21:50
not, those conditions didn't apply to
21:51
you. You weren't in the bad book. If you
21:54
had never incurred moral guilt and had
21:56
never rejected Christ, you weren't in
21:57
the bad book. Since moral innocence
21:59
never sinned and never rejected Christ,
22:01
they never had the opportunity. They are
22:04
not written in the bad book. They can
22:06
only be in the other book. That means
22:07
that they are raised with, by, and
22:09
because of Christ just like all humans,
22:11
but they never suffer the second death.
22:14
They simply don't fit the description.
22:16
They don't match the scriptural portrait
22:17
of those condemned to eternal
22:19
punishment. I would argue that babies,
22:21
aborted fetuses, the mentally
22:23
handicapped, and the infant or children
22:24
unable to believe are with Christ
22:26
because they are raised by, with, and
22:28
because of Christ and are not condemned
22:30
by their sin. It has nothing to do with
22:32
works, and resurrection is absolutely
22:34
essential. No one is in heaven by their
22:36
own merit. No one is in heaven that is
22:38
innocent without being resurrected by,
22:40
with, and because of Christ. Christ is
22:43
the essential means of salvation.
22:45
Without Christ, there is no eternal
22:47
life. That's the end of the excerpt, and
22:49
I couldn't agree more. Our actions are
22:51
what make us guilty before God, but our
22:53
actions can never make us worthy of
22:57
But at any rate, I pray that this video
22:58
has been a blessing to you, and if
22:59
you've made it this far, please like
23:01
this video, subscribe to Dance Like
23:02
David, and leave a comment that says
23:04
eternal life is only through Jesus
23:06
Christ, as any interaction with this
23:08
video allows our content to reach and
23:10
help more people. And may God shine his
23:12
face upon [music] you and give you